Chapter 12. Where the rules split, ran out, or failed
Six places where a rule could be read two ways
When the examples for this book were checked, six were flagged as readable two ways. I did not use them as clean examples. I show them here.
2 Thessalonians 2:1-3, and the already-claims rule. Some message said that the day of the Lord was already here. The rule says what must come with the event. The verse names what comes first.
For that day will not arrive until the rebellion comes and the man of lawlessness is revealed, the son of destruction. (2 Thessalonians 2:3 NET)
"With" and "first" are not the same word. A careful reader can read the rule two ways here. So I write that the verse names what must come first, or I quote the rule's own word and note the verse. The verses do not say who or what the rebellion or the man of lawlessness is. Not shown.
Revelation 1:1, 20:3, 20:7 and 22:6, and the a-book's-soon rule. The book says what "must happen very soon" (Revelation 1:1 NET) and what "must happen soon" (Revelation 22:6 NET). It also has a binding "until the one thousand years were finished" (Revelation 20:3 NET) and "when the thousand years are finished" (Revelation 20:7 NET). The rule says a book cannot call "soon" what it places after its own long wait. Two things stay open. The rule needs the thousand years to be a long wait. The thousand-years rule says only that a thousand years can be long. And the Greek word behind "soon" is tachei, "quickness". Whether it says when something happens, or how fast, is not shown. I do not say what Revelation 20 means. The tests leave it open, both ways.
2 Kings 7:1 and 7:16-17, and the record-burden rule. Elisha says "About this time tomorrow" flour will sell at a set price (2 Kings 7:1). The narrator records the sale "just as in the Lord’s message" (2 Kings 7:16 NET). The rule speaks of dated words. It does not say what dated words are. So readers' answers turn on how they read that phrase. One reader could count "About this time tomorrow" as dated words, so the narrator's record meets the rule. Another could ask whether dated words means more than that, and the rule does not say.
1 Kings 14:19, and the outside-record rule. This one is not read two ways so much as only half fitting. The verse says the rest of the events of Jeroboam's reign "are recorded in the scroll called the Annals of the Kings of Israel" (1 Kings 14:19 NET). Scripture names a record outside its pages. But the rule has nothing to write when Scripture itself tells the event, and here Scripture tells part of the reign itself. So the verse is only a likeness of the rule's case.
2 Timothy 2:16-19, and the unnarrated-event rule. Two men were saying "that the resurrection has already occurred" (2 Timothy 2:18 NET). The rule's sentence for this claim says that Scripture's own voice presents the raising as still to come when it was written, and that no narrator records it happening. Elsewhere "the dead will be raised imperishable" (1 Corinthians 15:52 NET). Readers differed on whether the verses must also show the second part: that no narrator records it. The rule never says "it did not happen". The letter names two men in their own day. I apply it to no one today.
Ruth 4:9-11, and the count of witnesses. You met this one above. Ruth is a picture of agreeing witnesses with no number. The split on the count sentence came on writings outside the Bible, not on Ruth. I put Ruth here because the count is the open point.

