Michlaude Discipleship Project

The Olivet Discourse and Daniel 12: A Dissertation on the Sorting Work

4. The rules (2 of 3)

Rule 4: A clear joining statement

Two things count as one occasion only when the text itself joins them, with words like "when... then" or "together with." A plain "then" does not join anything.

The reader marked this rule as forced by inerrancy and read it narrowly. The examples below show how Scripture words a join and a plain sequence. They do not show two texts that would contradict each other if the rule were denied, so this label should be held loosely. In Matthew 25:31 the verse says, "When the Son of Man comes in his glory and all the angels with him, then he will sit on his glorious throne." The coming and the sitting on the throne are one occasion. But Matthew 24:9-10 uses a plain "then" for events that follow one another and are distinct, so a plain "then" is not a join.

The reader passed it. It can bind things inside one sentence, such as 1 Thessalonians 4:16-17, where the Lord comes down, the dead in Christ rise, and the living are caught up. It cannot join passages across chapters or across books.

Rule 5: A citation formula points to a verse only if the quoted words occur in one place

When a New Testament writer says that a prophet spoke certain words, the citation points to one verse only if those words appear in one place.

The rule rests on logic and on observed practice. A parallel case is Hebrews 1:5, which quotes words found in both 2 Samuel 7:14 and 1 Chronicles 17:13 (the NET note on Hebrews 1:5 says so). There the words are credited to God and not to a prophet, so it shows only that one quotation can match two places. In Matthew 24:15, Jesus speaks of "the abomination of desolation... spoken about by Daniel the prophet." The NET words Daniel 11:31 and 12:11 as "the abomination that causes desolation." It words Daniel 9:27 differently ("On the wing of abominations will come one who destroys"), but the Hebrew word pair behind "abomination of desolation" was checked in an earlier round and found in all three verses [checked]. So the citation does not fix one verse.

The reader passed it, with one limit. The rule compares words and does not compare small grammar details such as which word has "the" in front of it. A later check showed that the Old Greek of Daniel 12:11 matches Matthew's Greek exactly. That fact is true, but it does not change the rule, because the label also appears elsewhere in Daniel and because Matthew's place clause, "standing in the holy place," fits Daniel 11:31 better than 12:11, because 11:31 names the sanctuary. It also fits the Greek of Daniel 9:27, which says "upon the temple," though the Hebrew of 9:27 says "on the wing" [checked online]. Decision 6 in Section 7 uses this.

Rule 6: Time words are read verse by verse, as written

There is no general rule for how far a deadline reaches or for whether a word like "immediately" carries a date forward. So each time word is read in its own verse, as written.

This rule passes as the method's default. It is not an independent warrant. A tested candidate, that "all these things" always covers the events right before it, failed on Matthew 24:33, where the same words come before a verb whose subject the Greek does not state (the NET supplies "he"). The working session noted that this does not prove such a rule is false. It only shows that no rule from Scripture's own usage fixes the reach. Examples of reading as written are "Immediately after the suffering of those days" in Matthew 24:29 and the thousand years in Revelation 20:3, 5, and 7.

The rule leaves one question unanswered: what "all these things" covers in Matthew 24:33-34. That is Decision 1.

Rule 7: Near-words are true but cannot date anything

Words like soon, near, and at hand are true statements about time. But they do not set a number of years, and they do not set a limit.

The reader marked the rule as observed. Acts 25:4 says Festus will go "shortly," and 25:6 follows with a stay of "not more than eight or ten days." In Isaiah 13:6 the day of the Lord is called near for a judgment on Babylon that came in 539 BC, when the Persian king Cyrus, whose empire included the Medes, took the city, about 150 to 175 years after Isaiah's time [the verses are checked; the dates were read in an online encyclopedia, [checked online]]. An earlier idea that near-words top out at about 170 years was tested and dropped, because the evidence for the number was weak.

The reader passed it, with a note that this rule can never bind a unit or exclude one. It keeps "soon" in Revelation 1:1 and 22:6 true, and it gives that word no date.

Rule 8: A permanent end of death happens once

If the text says that death or decay is ended for good, that ending happens once. The rule applies only where the text states that the ending is complete.

The reader marked this as forced by inerrancy and by logic. Paul writes, "Death has been swallowed up in victory" (1 Corinthians 15:54, NET). Revelation 21:4 says "death will not exist any more." If each describes the end of death, they describe one end. The reader added a caution. Second Timothy 1:10 says Christ "has broken the power of death," while 1 Corinthians 15:26 speaks of its end as future. So the Greek word can mean "made powerless," not only "removed" [checked online in the Greek]. That is why the rule is limited to texts that state completeness.

The reader found that every Not yet result in its sort ran through this rule, together with the observation that death and decay still continue.

Rule 9: A book cannot call "soon" what it places after its own long wait

Revelation 1:1 says "what must happen very soon," and 22:6 says "what must happen soon." But Revelation 20:3 says the devil is locked up "until the one thousand years were finished," and 20:7 says, "Now when the thousand years are finished, Satan will be released from his prison." So the book's "soon" cannot cover what the book itself puts after the thousand years, if the thousand years is long.