Michlaude Discipleship Project

The Olivet Discourse and Daniel 12: A Dissertation on the Sorting Work

6. What the rules alone settled (1 of 2)

The rules alone fixed a deadline, put two of Paul's passages in the future, and placed one Old Testament warning before the New Testament. Almost everything else stayed Open. This section gives the sort as it stood after Round 6 and before the author made any of his six choices. It comes from the blind reader's sort in Round 6.

UnitPassageAnswer from the rules aloneWhy
1Matthew 24:27-31, the coming of the Son of ManOpenVerse 29 begins "Immediately after the suffering of those days." But no rule says whether the deadline in 24:34 reaches back to that suffering. What "all these things" covers is not fixed.
2Matthew 24:34, "this generation"First centuryThe generation rule and the dated-words input fix a deadline inside the lifetime of Jesus's hearers. The rules do not fix what the deadline covers.
3Matthew 24:36-44, "that day and hour"Open"That day" has no fixed starting point. The passage holds no deadline and nothing that can be observed.
4Matthew 25:31-46, the judgment of the nationsOpenNothing joins it to a dated or observable text. Rules 2 and 13 stop it from being tied to Matthew 16:27-28 or to John 5 by wording alone.
5Matthew 16:27-2816:28 First century; 16:27 Open"There are some standing here" is a deadline. No joining word ties 16:27 to 16:28.
6Luke 21:20-3221:32 First century; 21:20-31 OpenThe generation rule fixes the deadline. Even a deadline that reached 21:20-24 would not reach 21:25-28, which begins "And there will be signs" with no time word.
7Daniel 12:1Open"At that time" points back to Daniel 11:40-45, and whose time that is is not fixed.
8Daniel 12:2OpenIt has no time word. It is tied to 12:1 only by the Hebrew word for "and," which the NET leaves untranslated [unchecked in the Hebrew].
9Daniel 12:7OpenThe "time, times, and half a time" has no stated start. Daniel 11:31 and Matthew 24:15 pull on it, and Rules 2 and 5 block both links.
10Daniel 12:13Open"The end of the days" points to the day counts in 12:11-12, and those depend on an abomination that is not yet placed.
111 Thessalonians 4:15-17OpenThe Lord's coming, the rising of the dead, and the catching up are one occasion (Rule 4). But there is no time word, and nothing in it would conflict with the observations if it lay in the past. Rule 2 stops it from being joined to 1 Corinthians 15:52.
121 Corinthians 15:51-52Not yetSee below.
13Revelation 1:1-3Open"Soon" is true but undated (Rule 7). Rule 9 depends on when the thousand years begins.
14Revelation 22:6-12OpenThe same. Rule 2 stops 22:12 from being identified with the judgment in 20:12.
15Acts 1:9-11OpenIt has no time word. Nothing in the observations tests it, unless the author holds that no visible bodily return has occurred.
C1Isaiah 13:6-19Fulfilled before the New Testament; 13:20-22 OpenSee below.
C2Romans 8:18-23Not yetSee below.
C3Matthew 10:23First centurySee below.

The deadline

The dated-words input and the generation rule together fix one thing. Matthew 24:34 and Luke 21:32 each say "this generation" will not pass away until the things take place. The rules say that means Jesus's contemporaries. So something must be on record from that time. Two other deadlines follow the same logic. Matthew 16:28 says, "I tell you the truth, there are some standing here who will not experience death before they see the Son of Man coming in his kingdom." Matthew 10:23 says, "you will not finish going through all the towns of Israel before the Son of Man comes." In 16:28 the people are the bystanders. In 10:23 they are the Twelve, who are named earlier in the chapter (Matthew 10:2-4).

Each of these needs a record. For Matthew 16:28, two records are available: the Transfiguration, which Peter calls "the power and return of our Lord Jesus Christ" in 2 Peter 1:16-18, or the events of AD 70. The record rule cannot rank them, and the answer is the same either way. For Matthew 24:34 and Matthew 10:23, the record is the fall of Jerusalem in AD 70. That record comes from outside Scripture (Josephus; his account of the siege, the famine, the burning of the temple, and the tearing down of the city was read online and supports each event [checked online]). Rule 12 admits it as a burden to be carried, not as proof, through the picture-language cases of Isaiah 13:10 and 19:1.