Michlaude Discipleship Project

The Olivet Discourse and Daniel 12: A Dissertation on the Sorting Work

9. Daniel and the prohibition test (Round 7) (1 of 2)

The last round of testing looked at Daniel and at one claim the author made in Decision 6. This section tells what was asked, who ran the test, what was found, and what the author did with the one finding that was left for him to decide.

What was asked

In Decision 6, the author chose to treat "the abomination of desolation" as a label from Daniel. Jesus dates one sighting of it in the first century. The author also said a later, similar event is "not precluded," which means nothing in Scripture rules it out. That is a claim about what the Bible forbids, and the author's own rule test applies to it. A rule stands only if Scripture's own usage shows it, with named cases, or if inerrancy forces it. So the question for Round 7 was this. Does any text pass that test as a prohibition on a later event of the same label?

Who ran it

The test was run in a fresh chat outside the project, with Opus 5.5 at the High setting. That reader was blind to the working session's own list of candidate texts. The reader was given the question and the rules, and was asked to look for any text that forbids a later event, and also for any text that requires or allows one. The brief that was sent is saved in the project library as `Olivet_Round7_Prohibition_Test_Brief.md`, and the full report is saved as `Olivet_Round7_Prohibition_Test_Opus55_v1.md`. The working session added its own reading at the top of that file.

The reader searched Daniel 7 to 9 and 11 to 12, Matthew 23 and 24, Mark 13, Luke 19 and 21, John 2 and 4, Acts 6 and 7, 1 Corinthians 3, Ephesians 2, 2 Thessalonians 2, Hebrews 7 to 10 and 13, and Revelation 11, 13, and 21. The reader also searched the Old Testament passages about the temple being defiled, and the passages that say a disaster will never be matched again.

Result one: no text forbids a later event

The reader listed ten candidates for a prohibition. None passed. Each one either limits the size, the length, or the meaning of an event without forbidding it, or fails the two-source test outright. The table gives the reason for each in plain terms.

CandidateWhy it does not forbid a later event
Matthew 24:21, the suffering greater than any before or afterIt limits size, and only softly. The same kind of "never again" language is used of other disasters that were later matched, such as Ezekiel 5:9, Joel 2:2, and 2 Kings 18:5 set beside 23:25. It does not forbid a later event.
Daniel 9:27It ends that one desolator by decree. It does not say no other will come.
Daniel 9:24, the seventy weeksIt ties 9:27 to the seventy weeks. It says nothing about what lies outside them.
Daniel 12:11It limits how long that one occurrence lasts. It is silent about recurrence.
Matthew 24:2, not one stone left on anotherThis describes how complete that demolition would be. It does not say no temple would ever stand again. Rule 8 would need a stated permanence, and none is stated.
Matthew 23:38-39, the house left desolate until a timeIt gives an end point and forbids nothing.
Luke 21:24 and Romans 11:25"Until" ends the trampling in Luke 21:24 and the partial hardening of Israel in Romans 11:25. Reading a ban into what comes after would rest on silence, and silence is not allowed to carry a rule.
Hebrews 8:13, 9:8-12, and 10:18They deny that any later sacrifice has value. They do not deny that a building or a defilement could happen. They limit meaning, not possibility.
John 4:21-23It detaches worship from one place. It does not speak to events at that place.
Revelation 21:22, no temple in the new cityIt applies to the new creation only.

The strongest of the ten is Matthew 24:21. Even that one is weak, for the reason in the table.

Result two: no text requires a later event either

The reader also looked for texts that demand a later abomination. The nearest were 2 Thessalonians 2:4 and Revelation 11 and 13. None uses the label, and the dating of each is Open. So the opposite view, that a later abomination or a third temple is required, fails the same test the claim had to pass. Anyone who says a later abomination is required has no passing text. Anyone who says it is forbidden has none either. Both sides are in the same position. A later abomination is therefore Open as to whether it will occur. What is established is only that it is possible.

Result three: John's pattern does not carry over by rule

The author's reasoning in Decision 6 had borrowed from John, who says that "antichrist" was expected as one figure and that many have now come (1 John 2:18). The reader checked whether that pattern can be moved over to the abomination. It would take a chain of four steps. First, the abomination is the act of a person. Second, that person is the antichrist. Third, antichrist is many. Fourth, so the abomination can be many. The first step has some support, because Mark 13:14 uses a masculine form for "standing" [checked online]. The NET reads "standing where it should not be" and has no note on the point. The second step has no text. First John never mentions a temple, and 2 Thessalonians 2:4 never uses the word antichrist. To link them would rest on similar wording, and Rule 2 says wording alone is not enough. So the chain breaks. John's pattern stays an analogy and not a rule. This agreed with the working session's earlier second correction, recorded in Section 7.

The reader also said the author does not need John's pattern, because a better ground exists inside Daniel. That is the next result.

Result four: the finding left Open on purpose

The reader found that Daniel's own named anchors may place Daniel 11:31 in the time of the Greek kings who followed Alexander. Daniel names Persia and Greece in 11:2, and he describes the kingdom being divided in 11:4. Jesus, in Matthew 24:15, dates his sighting in the first century. If both are right, then Scripture itself already uses the label for two events, one in the Greek period and one in the first century. That would show recurrence of the label has a precedent inside Scripture.