The Olivet Discourse and Daniel 12: A Dissertation on the Sorting Work
9. Daniel and the prohibition test (Round 7) (2 of 2)
This finding rests on two judgment calls, and the reader named both.
First, the king described in Daniel 11:21-31 is one continuous figure, with no gap before 11:36. A reader who puts a gap earlier weakens the finding.
Second, "ships of Kittim" in 11:30 means Rome. That rests on the Old Greek of Daniel, the oldest Greek translation, which renders Kittim as "Romans" [checked online]. The later Greek version by Theodotion keeps the name "Kittim," and the Hebrew itself says only "Kittim," so the Old Greek is early support for reading Rome and not proof. The NET note on Daniel 11:30 says the name can mean Cyprus or, more widely, "parts of the Mediterranean world that lay west of the Middle East (e.g., Rome)," and it adds that the Greek Old Testament has "Romans." That fits this reading but does not make it certain. If Rome is the one opposing this king, then Rome cannot also be the one who set up the abomination, and the abomination in 11:31 would belong to a different event than AD 70.
If either call fails, the finding drops from "passes" to "Open." The working session did not verify either call. If the author had accepted both, Daniel 11:31 would have moved from Open to Fulfilled before the New Testament, by Daniel's own anchors and not by outside history.
The working session put the choice to the author. His answer, in his own words, was: "i cant make that decision, nor do i feel a need to." So Daniel 11:31 stays Open. This was a decision to leave it unsettled, and it was honored as one. Two reasons support leaving it. First, under his own rule, no rule means Open. Second, the Open passage touches nothing else in the sort. Daniel 11:31 is not a dated statement of Jesus, so the dated-words input does not reach it. It is not one of the five awaited things. And none of the six decisions depends on it. This is the plainest example of the point made in Section 8: an Open passage does not stop the rest of the work from fitting together.
Three corrections the reader made
First, the claim "one observed occurrence" undercounts if Daniel 11:31 is a second event. The accurate form of the claim, in the reader's words, is that there is one occurrence dated by Jesus, and recurrence of the label is not precluded and has scriptural precedent. Because the author left Daniel 11:31 Open, this paper states only the part that does not depend on it: one occurrence is dated by Jesus, and a later one is neither required nor forbidden.
Second, the sighting in AD 70 rests on history from outside Scripture, which is Josephus. Josephus records events in the temple that a reader could match to it, such as the Zealots entering the sanctuary "with polluted feet" (Jewish War 4.150) and Roman troops offering sacrifices to their standards in the temple court (Jewish War 6.316). He never calls any of them "the abomination of desolation," so matching one of his events to Matthew 24:15 is the author's judgment [checked online]. The author's list of held observations did not include the fall of the temple at first. During the session he said he holds that the temple's destruction was a visible occurrence. It still carries the record rule (Rule 12) as a burden, as it did before. No passage moved because of this.
Third, a correction to the author's remark about the temple. He had said the new covenant has a person as the temple. Scripture does call the body of Jesus the temple (John 2:19-21). It also calls the church the temple (1 Corinthians 3:16 and Ephesians 2:21) and each believer the temple (1 Corinthians 6:19). So "a person as the temple" covers only the first of three uses. The reader added that Hebrews 8 to 10 limits the meaning of a third temple but does not say whether one could be built. The author's own remark about it, recorded in Section 7, stays as his observation of the world: some Jewish and Christian groups intend to rebuild a temple. That shows intent and not a building.
What the finished claim can and cannot do
The claim that a later event of the same label is possible can be used for two things. It can say that a later temple defilement, if one ever happened, would not overturn the first-century reading of Matthew 24:15. And it can classify such an event as a repeat of a pattern. The reader found that the Old Testament shows this pattern with named cases, where detestable things are placed in the sanctuary and desolation follows (for example, Ahaz and Manasseh in 2 Kings and the temple scenes in Ezekiel 8). In the NET, Ahaz has an altar built from a Damascus pattern and moves the bronze altar (2 Kings 16:10-14). Manasseh builds altars in the Lord's temple and puts an idol of Asherah in it (21:4-7). Ezekiel 8 shows a "statue of jealousy" at the entrance, "detestable images" on the wall, and men "worshiping the sun" (8:5, 10, 16).
It cannot be used to date anything. It cannot predict that a later event will happen. It cannot supply a "Not yet" for any passage. It cannot reopen the placement of Matthew 24:15-22 inside the generation. It cannot touch any of the five awaited things, because none of them involves the abomination. And it cannot give a third temple any covenant standing.
What this section did not verify
The reader marked the quotations it took from the English Standard Version as checked. That version is not the one the author uses for this work, which is the NET Bible, and the working session did not re-check them at the time. The final check in Section 11 later read the quotations in this paper in the NET. The point that carries the most weight is the Greek reading of Kittim in Daniel 11:30, which was later read online in the Old Greek and in Theodotion (Section 11). Section 11 collects every item that is still unchecked.

