Michlaude Discipleship Project

The Olivet Discourse and Daniel 12: A Dissertation on the Sorting Work

10. The five things Christians still wait for

From the start, the study held that five things are still ahead. They are the final sentence on the devil, the raising of the body, the return of Christ, the new heavens and new earth, and the final judgment of everyone. These five were held from the start. What was tested is how each of the five is held, and what holds it. The question matters because the study placed much of the Olivet talk in the first century. A reader could fear that this takes away the hopes that Christians wait for. This section shows, one at a time, that it does not.

The short answer is that the Olivet talk does not carry any of them. Paul, the book of Revelation, and Matthew 13 carry them, together with two plain facts about the world that the author holds: death goes on, and evil goes on.

The five at a glance

The awaited thingFinal answerWhat holds itHow firm
The raising of the bodyNot yet1 Corinthians 15:51-54 with Rules 4, 8, and 11, and the fact that death continuesFirm. It rests on text and on an observation.
The return of ChristNot yetThe chain inside 1 Corinthians 15, and the author's observation that no visible bodily return has occurred (Decision 4)Firm on the author's observation, with a stated cost for Decision 4. The chain in 1 Corinthians 15 is a reading across sentences, not a Rule 4 join.
The new heavens and new earthNot yetRevelation 21:1-4, and Romans 8:18-23Firm for the version in Revelation 21 only
The final judgment of everyoneNot yetThe order of events in Revelation 20:12-14, with death continuingWeaker. It rests on sequence.
The devil's final sentenceNot yetThe author's observation that evil continues, and Matthew 13:39 (Decision 5)Held by observation, not by a rule

1. The raising of the body

Paul says the dead "will be raised imperishable," and that "this mortal body must put on immortality" (1 Corinthians 15:52-53, NET). Rule 11 says "mortal" means the physical body. Rule 4 joins the change of the body to the saying that death is swallowed up (15:54). Rule 8 says that the end of death happens once and for good. Death still happens every day. So the raising has not yet taken place. Nothing from the Olivet talk is needed for this.

The reader in Round 6 worked this out from the passing rules alone, with no help from any decision. That is why it was Not yet before the author made any choice.

2. The return of Christ

This one needed Decision 4. The Olivet talk speaks of the Son of Man coming (Matthew 24:29-31), and the study placed that coming in the first century. Someone could fear that this removes the second coming from the future. It does not, and the reason is worth stating plainly. The coming of Matthew 24 is dated by Jesus's own words, and the dated-words input needs a record of it. The author observes that no visible bodily return of Christ has occurred. Those two facts fit together only if the coming of Matthew 24 is a coming in history, which is how Scripture uses picture language of this kind for God's judgments (Isaiah 13:10 and 19:1, tested as Rule 1). So Matthew 24:29-31 describes a coming in history. The visible, bodily return is a different event, and it is held by other texts.

Those other texts are 1 Corinthians 15, where Paul places the making alive of those who belong to Christ "when Christ comes" (15:23, NET) and ties it to the end of death, then Acts 1:11 and 1 Thessalonians 4:16-17. The last two cannot carry the point alone, because neither has a time word and the rules cannot date them. The author's observation in Decision 4 does the work for them. That is why units 11 and 15 moved from Open to Not yet.

The cost is the one stated in Section 7. Matthew 24:30 says "they will see" the Son of Man and speaks of "all the tribes of the earth." Under this reading, "they will see" means seen in the event, and the Greek word for "earth" is read as "the land."

3. The new heavens and new earth

Revelation 21:1-4 ties the new creation to a world where "death will not exist any more" (21:4). Death does still exist, so that new creation has not come. Romans 8:21 says creation "will also be set free from the bondage of decay," and creation still decays, so that also has not come.

Two cautions keep this honest. The phrase "new heavens and a new earth" alone proves nothing, because Isaiah 65:17-20 uses it for a state in which people still die. And 2 Peter 3:10-13 could not be decided, because of Rule 1: its fire and melting may be picture language or may not, and no rule settles it. So this hope is future for the version in Revelation 21, and not by the phrase.

4. The final judgment of everyone

This is the weakest of the five placements, and the paper says so. Revelation 20:14 throws Death and Hades into the lake of fire. With Rule 8 and the fact that death continues, that is still ahead. The judgment of the dead in 20:12-13 is placed with it only because the vision runs on with a continuous "and." No joining statement ties them in the narrow sense of Rule 4. So this one rests on the order of Revelation's story, together with the observation.

Matthew 25:31-46, the judgment of the nations, is also Not yet. It does not carry this hope, though. It is placed by Decision 3, not by a rule.

5. The devil's final sentence

Until Decision 5, this hope was an assumption and not a result. Matthew 25:41 speaks of "the eternal fire that has been prepared for the devil and his angels," but it does not date that fire. Revelation 20:7-10 puts the devil's casting into the lake after the thousand years, but no rule fixes when the thousand years begin. The reader in Round 6 said plainly that this one rested on the order of Revelation's story alone.

The author then made Decision 5. The devil has been judged and defeated. The carrying out of the final sentence awaits. The author's evidence is that evil is present now. Matthew 13:39 names the devil as the one who sowed the weeds, and the weeds are still growing (13:30). So the presence of evil, which the author observes, points to a sentence not yet carried out.

The texts that speak of the devil already judged and defeated are John 12:31 and 16:11, Colossians 2:15, and Hebrews 2:14. The final check read all four in the NET. John 12:31 says, "Now is the judgment of this world; now the ruler of this world will be driven out." The double "now" reads as present, and "will be driven out" is future, so the verse points both ways.

What the Olivet talk does and does not do

Under the author's six choices, the line between "already" and "still ahead" in Matthew's answer falls at 25:31. That raises a fair question. Does moving the line weaken any of the five? The answer in the record is no. The record's final sort says the five are held by Paul, Revelation, Matthew 13, and two observations of the world, and that the Olivet talk does not carry them. The paper's own check of that, made while writing, agrees. For each of the five, ask what holds it if Matthew 24 is set aside. Each one still stands on the texts and observations named above. The Olivet talk does hold the judgment of the nations (25:31-46) and the harvest (13:39-50), and those are Not yet. But those passages sit beside the five, and none of the five depends on them.