Michlaude Discipleship Project

The Olivet Discourse and Daniel 12: A Dissertation on the Sorting Work

7. The six decisions (3 of 3)

Decision 6: Which verse of Daniel does Matthew 24:15 name?

The question. In Matthew 24:15 Jesus speaks of "the abomination of desolation... spoken about by Daniel the prophet." In the Hebrew, Daniel has the same word pair in 9:27, 11:31, and 12:11. The NET words 11:31 and 12:11 as "the abomination that causes desolation" and words 9:27 differently. Which does Jesus mean, and does the sighting he dates happen only once?

The options. The working session proposed option (a): Daniel 12:11, because the Old Greek wording of 12:11 matches Matthew's wording exactly. That would place Daniel 12:11 in the first century, and it was the best-fit result. Option (b) is that Jesus names the label and not one verse.

The author's own reasoning. He chose option (b), and his reasons were his own. In his words: "i think there was a visible occurence with the destruction of the temple and what happened around that, and that doesnt preclude a similar and parallel future event. this is arrived at by john's discussion of antichrist as 'many' and also a spiritual intention. therefore an abomination of desolation has one observed event and doesnt preclude similar events." After two corrections from the working session, he added: "not precluded clearly in my mind and conviction. no evidence that the text would prohibit it, and that might be worth testing."

What is held. The sighting Jesus dates in 24:15 is the first-century one. It happened inside the great distress of 24:15-22, by Decision 1 and the generation rule. A similar, parallel future event is held as not precluded, and not as a position.

The working session's two corrections, which the author accepted. First, "not precluded" is a possibility only. So a future parallel is Open: neither Not yet nor asserted. It cannot date anything and cannot touch the five awaited things. It applies equally to the claim of a future abomination made by others. Second, the bridge from the antichrist label to the abomination label is an analogy, not an observed instance, because wording alone is not identity (Rule 2). It would become a rule only with a text in Scripture linking the two labels. A candidate is 2 Thessalonians 2:3-4, where the NET says of a figure that "he takes his seat in God's temple, displaying himself as God."

The support. John speaks of one expected label with many instances and a spiritual intention (1 John 2:18; 4:3; 2 John 7).

The label. The author's own reasoning. It was not chosen for best fit. It leaves Daniel 12:11 Open where option (a) would have placed it.

The cost. Matthew's place clause, "standing in the holy place," fits Daniel 11:31 better than 12:11, and fits the Greek of 9:27 but not its Hebrew [checked online]. The exact Old Greek phrase matches 12:11 only. Neither settles it. The author chose the label.

The temple remark. The author added: "there is movement and intent by some in both jewish and christian tradition to rebuild a temple. it's tangental to the fact that the new covenant has a person as the temple and jesus as high priest - a third temple remains a possibilitty, but doesnt replace the new convenant temple of the body." This is recorded as his observation of the world. It shows intent, not a building. The working session's reading was that Matthew 24:2 says not one stone will be left on another but does not say that a building can never be built again. Ezra 6 is Scripture's own case of a destroyed temple being rebuilt. The prohibition test in Section 9 tested this directly.

The sort effects. The sighting in Matthew 24:15 is First century. Daniel 9:27, 11:31, and 12:11 are Open as to which instance each is. Daniel 12:1, 12:2, 12:7, and 12:13 are Open. A future parallel is Open.

The six decisions at a glance

QuestionThe author's answerHow it was madeThe cost
1What do "all these things" cover?The temple's fall and the distress of those days. The coming of 24:29-31 is dated by "immediately."Best fit24:31 read as the spread of the gospel; a strict regathering would have no record
2What is "that day" in 24:36?The day of the coming in 24:29-31.Best fit24:40 through 25:30 read as judgment inside history
3What is "the end of the age," and where is the seam?It points back to Matthew 13:39-49. The seam is at 25:31. Matthew 25:31-46 is Not yet.Best fit, with the author's confirmed observationJesus pulls apart what the disciples bundled; no text joins 25:31 to 13:49
4Has a visible bodily return happened?No.The author's observation"They will see" and "all the tribes of the earth" read as seen in the event
5How is the devil's final judgment held?Judged and defeated; the sentence awaits carrying out, as shown by the presence of evil.The author's observationSupporting texts read in the NET; John 12:31 points both ways
6Which Daniel verse does Matthew 24:15 name?The label, not one verse. One dated sighting; a later parallel is not precluded.The author's own reasoningThe place clause fits 9:27 and 11:31 better than 12:11