The Olivet Discourse and Daniel 12: A Dissertation on the Sorting Work
8. The final sort (1 of 2)
This section gives the finished sort. It is the answer as it stands after the rules, the six decisions, and the prohibition test in Section 9. Each answer comes with its trail, which is the list of rules, decisions, and observations that put it there. If you want to check any answer, the trail tells you where to look. Sections 4 and 7 explain the rules and the decisions in full.
Three kinds of trail appear below. A trail that names only rules means the rules settled it. A trail that names a decision means the author's choice settled it, and the label from Section 7 tells you what kind of choice it was. A trail that names an observation means something the author sees in the world today helped settle it. The input called the dated-words input follows from who the author holds Jesus to be: the Word, God and man. All of his words are trustworthy by definition, so a dated statement of his must have a recorded fulfillment (Deuteronomy 18:21-22 with Acts 3:22-23).
The eighteen passages that were tested
These are the eighteen units that the Round 2 test plan set and that the blind readers in Rounds 3 and 6 sorted. Round 7 asked a narrower question and did not use them. Units 1 to 15 are the core passages, and the three marked C are controls. Numbering is the same as in Section 6, so you can set the two tables side by side and see what changed.
| Unit | Passage | Final answer | The trail |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Matthew 24:27-31, the coming of the Son of Man | First century | Decision 1 (best fit). Verse 29 begins "Immediately after the suffering of those days," and Rule 6 reads that time word as written. The dated-words input dates the coming, and the author's observation in Decision 4 is that no visible bodily return has happened. Picture language (Rule 1) is the one reading that keeps both facts. So it is a coming in history. |
| 2 | Matthew 24:34, "this generation" | First century | The generation rule plus the dated-words input. No decision was needed. |
| 3 | Matthew 24:36-44, "that day and hour" | First century | Decision 2 (best fit). "That day" is the day of the coming in 24:29-31. The same decision gives first-century status to everything from 24:36 through 25:30. |
| 4 | Matthew 25:31-46, the judgment of the nations | Not yet | Decision 3 (best fit, with the author's confirmed observation from Matthew 13:30 that good and evil are both growing now). "The end of the age" in 24:3 points back to Matthew 13:39-49, and the seam falls at 25:31. No rule joins 25:31 to 13:39-49, so this is a decided reading and not a rule result. |
| 5 | Matthew 16:27-28 | 16:28 First century; 16:27 Open | 16:28 is a deadline ("some standing here"), so the dated-words input needs a record. No joining word ties 16:27 to 16:28, and Rules 2 and 13 keep it from being tied to other passages by wording alone. |
| 6 | Luke 21:20-32 | 21:32 First century; 21:20-31 Open | The generation rule fixes the deadline at 21:32. The record says the deadline reaches 21:20-24, but no rule or decision in this paper shows that step, and Rule 13 keeps Matthew's wording from being carried into Luke. So 21:20-24 is not securely placed. Verses 21:25-28 begin "And there will be signs" with no time word, so they stay Open. See Section 11 for a note on how this range was written in the record. |
| 7 | Daniel 12:1 | Open | "At that time" points back to 11:40-45, and whose time that is has no rule. |
| 8 | Daniel 12:2 | Open | No time word. It is tied to 12:1 only by the Hebrew word for "and," which the NET leaves untranslated [unchecked in the Hebrew]. |
| 9 | Daniel 12:7 | Open | "A time, times, and half a time" has no stated start. Rules 2 and 5 block the links to Daniel 11:31 and Matthew 24:15. |
| 10 | Daniel 12:13 | Open | "The end of the days" depends on the day counts in 12:11-12, and those depend on which abomination is meant. Decision 6 left that Open. |
| Unit | Passage | Final answer | The trail |
|---|---|---|---|
| 11 | 1 Thessalonians 4:15-17 | Not yet | Decision 4 (the author's observation: no visible bodily return has occurred). Rule 4 makes the coming, the rising of the dead, and the catching up one occasion. The dead in Christ are not yet raised, which follows from the five awaited things plus the fact that death is still present. This placement does not come from a rule. It rests on the author's observation and on the awaited raising of the body. Matthew 24:29-31 is treated differently on purpose. It carries a dated word ("immediately," and the generation deadline), so the dated-words input requires it to have happened, and picture language allows that. First Thessalonians 4:16-17 carries no dated word, and it joins the Lord's coming to the rising of the dead in Christ, which the author observes has not happened. Rule 2 still blocks tying it to 1 Corinthians 15 by the shared trumpet. |
| 12 | 1 Corinthians 15:51-52 | Not yet | Rules 4, 8, and 11, with the observation that death continues. This was already Not yet from the rules alone, with that one observation. |
| 13 | Revelation 1:1-3 | Open | "Soon" is true but cannot date anything (Rule 7). Rule 9 keeps items placed after the thousand years from being called "soon," but the start of the thousand years has no rule. |
| 14 | Revelation 22:6-12 | Open | The same. Rule 2 stops 22:12 from being tied to the judgment in Revelation 20:12 by wording alone. |
| 15 | Acts 1:9-11 | Not yet | Decision 4. The author's observation is that no visible bodily return has occurred, and Acts 1:11 speaks of a return in the same way he departed. |
| C1 | Isaiah 13:6-19 | Fulfilled before the New Testament; 13:20-22 Open | Verse 17 names the Medes, and Daniel 5:30-31 records the kingdom passing to Darius the Mede. Verse 19, which says Babylon will be destroyed like Sodom and Gomorrah, is taken with this, although Babylon was not left empty in 539 BC. So 13:20-22 stays Open. The pairing rests on the named city and the named agent. No tested rule says that a name fixes an event, so it is held as a reading. |
| C2 | Romans 8:18-23 | Not yet | Rule 8, with the observation that creation still decays. Romans 8:21 says creation "will also be set free from the bondage of decay." |
| C3 | Matthew 10:23 | First century | The deadline logic, as with Matthew 16:28. The Twelve would not finish the towns of Israel before the Son of Man came. |

