The Olivet Discourse and Daniel 12: A Dissertation on the Sorting Work
7. The six decisions (1 of 3)
Six questions could not be answered by the rules, so each was put to the author one at a time, with the options and the working session's analysis. His answers are recorded here as he made them. Each decision carries one of three labels. "Best fit" means the reading was chosen because everything else fits together best under it. The author chose Decisions 1 and 2 that way, and the working session applied the same principle to Decision 3 on his instruction. "The author's observation" means the choice rests on something he sees in the world. "The author's own reasoning" means he reasoned it out himself, and the working session did not pick it for him. The principle for the first kind was his own: choose the reading under which the inputs and the passing rules agree, with no conflict and the fewest Open passages left behind.
Decision 1: What do "all these things" cover? (Matthew 24:33-34)
The question. In Matthew 24:33 Jesus says, "So also you, when you see all these things, know that he is near, right at the door." In 24:34 he says, "this generation will not pass away until all these things take place." What are "all these things"?
The options. Reading A is narrow. It means the temple's fall and the great distress of those days (24:2-3 and 24:15-22), with the signs before them. Reading B reaches through the coming in 24:15-31. Reading C reaches all the way to 25:46.
The analysis. Under Reading A, the coming in 24:29-31 is dated by the words of 24:29, "Immediately after the suffering of those days," read as written (Rule 6). It is not dated by 24:34. Reading C does not fit. It would put 25:31-46 inside the deadline, so the dated-words input would need a record of a judgment of all the nations with eternal outcomes, and none exists. It would also contradict the five awaited things if that passage is the final judgment. Reading B reaches the same result on the coming, but it asks the word "all" in 24:34 to carry 24:15-31, and the text does not say that. Reading A claims only what 24:2-3 sets up, and it leaves Decisions 2 and 3 free.
The label. Best fit. The author's answer was Reading A, on the fit principle.
What it commits him to. It commits him to three things: that "all these things" means the temple's fall and the distress of those days; that "immediately" in 24:29 is read as written; and that the "record" for 24:29-31 is the use of sun, moon, and cloud language for judgments inside history (Isaiah 13:10 and 19:1). That is precedent for the language, not an event. If a first-century event is wanted, the natural one is the fall of Jerusalem in AD 70, which rests on Josephus [checked online]. It also commits him to reading the gathering of the elect in 24:31 as the spread of the gospel (24:14; Colossians 1:23; "angels" meaning messengers, as in Luke 7:24 and 9:52). The NET renders the word in Luke 7:24 and 9:52 as "messengers." That the Greek word there is "angel" is [checked online].
The cost. The reading of 24:31 is the soft spot. A strict regathering of people to the land would have no record. This is a reading to confirm, not a rule.
A correction was made here. The working session once said that under Reading A the coming would be Open. That was wrong, because the word "immediately" dates it.
Decision 2: What is "that day"? (Matthew 24:36)
The question. Jesus says that about "that day and hour" no one knows it except the Father. Which day is that?
The options. Option (i) is that "that day" is the day of the coming in 24:29-31. Option (ii) is that it is a different, undated day.
The analysis. Under option (i), everything from 24:36 through 25:30 takes the first-century status of the coming. The sentence "so the coming of the Son of Man will be" appears in the NET at 24:27 and again at 24:37. Nearly the same Greek clause appears at 24:39, with one added word, "also," which the NET words "It will be the same at the coming of the Son of Man." The opening words of 25:1, "At that time," tie the parable of the ten virgins back to what comes before. The delays in 25:5 and 25:19 stay inside one lifetime. The generation is known and only the hour is hidden. The word "For" at 24:37 ties "that day" to that same coming. (The idea that one question gets one answer was Rule 3, which failed, so it is not used here.) The only Open passage left in the whole Olivet answer is 25:31-46. Under option (ii), 24:36 through 25:30 becomes undated, and the coming of 24:29-31 would be joined by a second, undated one. That leaves more passages Open and gains no consistency. Neither option conflicts with the five awaited things, because the second coming rests on Acts 1:11, 1 Thessalonians 4, and 1 Corinthians 15, not on the Olivet talk.
The label. Best fit. Rule 3 failed, so no rule picks the day. The author said to apply his earlier criteria: "apply my previous decision criteria as my choice which is apparently i" (he meant option i).
What it commits him to. The sayings about one taken and one left, and the judgments in the parables of 24:40 through 25:30, are judgment inside history. The nearest example in Scripture is Matthew 22:7 with 22:13, where one parable has a burned city and also "the outer darkness, where there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth" (22:13, NET). In Matthew 22:7 the king sets the city on fire.
Decision 3: What is "the end of the age," and is 25:31 a seam? (Matthew 24:3)
The question. The disciples ask about "your coming and of the end of the age" (Matthew 24:3). Matthew uses the phrase "the end of the age" five times: 13:39, 13:40, 13:49, 24:3, and 28:20 [checked]. Does the phrase in 24:3 point back to Jesus's own harvest teaching in Matthew 13?
The options. Reading X says the end of the age is AD 70. Then Matthew 25:31-46 either lands in the first century or has no seam. Reading Y says the phrase points back to Matthew 13:39-49, the final end. Then the disciples bundled three things in one question, and Jesus answers the first two inside the generation (24:4 through 25:30). The end of the age is answered by 25:31-46.
The analysis. Under Reading Y, the dated-words input gives the placed parts of 24:4 through 25:30 to the first century. The five awaited things keep the final judgment ahead, so no record is owed for a judgment of all nations. Matthew's five uses of the phrase read as one event. Matthew 13:39 says, "The harvest is the end of the age, and the reapers are angels." Matthew 28:20 says, "I am with you always, to the end of the age," a promise to the eleven for a mission to all nations. On the rival reading, that promise would end in the apostles' lifetime. Also, 25:31-46 uses none of the Greek words for the noun "coming," or for "sign" or "end of the age" [checked], though the NET verb "comes" appears in 25:31. Its scene of separating people shares its content with 13:41-43 and 49-50, not its wording with 24:27-31. Under Reading X, the passage is either in the first century, which conflicts with both the dated-words input and the five awaited things, or it is Open with no seam.

