The Olivet Discourse and Daniel 12: A Dissertation on the Sorting Work
7. The six decisions (2 of 3)
The observation needed. One more observation of the world was required: that righteousness and evil are still growing together. Matthew 13:30 says, "Let both grow together until the harvest." The author answered: "the observation that righteousness and evil are both growing in the world currently is indeed true and easily seen." The result follows. The wheat and weeds grow together until the harvest. The harvest is the end of the age. The world still shows them together, so the harvest of 13:39-43 and 49-50 has not happened. Matthew 25:31-46 therefore moves from Open to Not yet. Its last verse reads, "And these will depart into eternal punishment, but the righteous into eternal life" (25:46, NET).
The label. Best fit, applied by the working session on the author's instruction to use his criteria, with the observation confirmed by the author. No rule joins 25:31 to 13:39-49.
The cost, stated plainly. In the Greek of 24:3 one article ("the") stands over both "your coming" and "end of the age" [checked]; the NET words the verse "your coming and of the end of the age." That reads the two as one event. Reading Y has Jesus pull apart what the disciples bundled. No text joins 25:31 to 13:49. The link is Matthew's own definition at 13:39 and the content of the scene. It also rests on a shared phrase, "the end of the age," which Rule 2 says cannot settle identity by itself, so it is chosen for fit. Decision 3 also puts a second, still future event (25:31, "When the Son of Man comes in his glory") inside the one answer. Decision 2 counted a second coming against option (ii), so the two decisions rest on different grounds. Decision 2 rests on the "For" at 24:37 and on leaving fewer passages Open. Decision 3 rests on Matthew's own use of "the end of the age."
Decision 4: Has a visible, bodily return happened?
The question. Does the author hold, as something he observes, that no visible bodily return of Jesus has occurred, and that the dead in Christ have not been raised?
The author's answer: "no visible bodily return of christ has occurred is also obviously true as that would nullify 3." The working session read "3" as the third input in the record's list of inputs: the five awaited things, the dated-words input, and the observation that death and decay are present now. The author did not say which item he meant, so this is the session's reading. On that reading, a visible return together with the raising of the dead would end death.
What it settles. That no visible bodily return has occurred is the author's observation. The author's answer spoke only to the visible return. The working session added the second claim, that the dead in Christ have not been raised, and it follows from the awaited-things input and the fact that death continues. As a result, 1 Thessalonians 4:15-17 and Acts 1:9-11 move from Open to Not yet. First Thessalonians 4:16 joins the Lord's coming down to the rising of the dead in Christ, which has not happened. Acts 1:11 says that "This same Jesus who has been taken up from you into heaven will come back in the same way you saw him go into heaven," bodily and seen. The phrase "we who are alive" in 4:15 and 4:17 is read as the class of believers living when it happens. The instances for that reading, 1 Corinthians 6:14 and 2 Corinthians 4:14, both say in the NET that God will raise "us": "he will raise us by his power" (6:14) and "will also raise us up with Jesus" (4:14).
A forced result for Decisions 1 and 2. The comings dated at Matthew 24:29-31 and 16:28 are dated by the dated-words input, and no visible bodily return has occurred. So these comings are not the visible bodily return. They are the comings inside history that picture language allows (Rule 1). This turns Rule 1 from a possibility into the only reading that keeps the dated-words input and the observation together.
The cost. Matthew 24:30 says, "Then the sign of the Son of Man will appear in heaven, and all the tribes of the earth will mourn. They will see the Son of Man arriving on the clouds of heaven with power and great glory." The words "they will see" and "all the tribes of the earth" must be read as seen in the event, with the Greek word for "earth" read as "the land." The second coming stays a separate event, as in Decision 3.
The label. The author's observation.
Decision 5: The devil's final judgment
The question. How is the devil's final judgment held?
What happened. The working session first recorded this as held by the awaited-things input alone. It did not ask the author. He corrected it: "i say he has been judged, defeated, but execution of final sentence awaits execution - apparent by observation of the presence of evil."
What is held. The devil has been judged and defeated. The carrying out of the final sentence is still to come. The evidence is the presence of evil now, the same observation as in Decision 3. So this is the awaited-things input plus an observation of the world, not the input alone.
The text link that makes the observation bear on it. In Matthew 13:39 Jesus says, "the enemy who sows them is the devil," and he sets the harvest at the end of the age. The weeds still grow with the wheat, so the work of the one who sowed them continues and the harvest has not come. Matthew 25:41, "the eternal fire that has been prepared for the devil and his angels," sits in 25:31-46, which is Not yet under Decision 3, and it agrees.
The record. The author did not cite texts for "already judged." Four are usually offered, and the final check read them in the NET. John 12:31 says, "Now is the judgment of this world; now the ruler of this world will be driven out." The double "now" reads as present, but "will be driven out" is future, so the verse points both ways. John 16:11 says he "has been condemned." Colossians 2:15 speaks of "triumphing over them by the cross." Hebrews 2:14 speaks of destroying "the one who holds the power of death." None is needed for the sort.
The label. The author's observation, with his own statement. The second combined conclusion had said this judgment "rests on nothing the world can show." That line was wrong and was changed.

