The Olivet Discourse and Daniel 12: A Dissertation on the Sorting Work
3. The method
The method sorts passages one at a time, and it writes down the reason for every answer. This section explains the passages, the answers, and how a passage gets sorted. Section 5 tells how the method was tested and rebuilt.
The passages
A fixed list of 18 passages was chosen when the test plan was written in Round 2, before any blind reader used it. This paper calls each one a unit. The units are listed in Appendix B. Fifteen are the passages that matter most. They come from Matthew 24 and 25, Matthew 16, Luke 21, Daniel 12, 1 Thessalonians 4, 1 Corinthians 15, Acts 1, and Revelation 1 and 22. Three are controls. A control is a passage where the right answer was expected in advance, so it shows whether the method behaves sensibly. The expected answers are the author's and the working session's, and not every school would grant them. The three controls are Isaiah 13:6-19 (with 13:20-22 treated separately), a warning against Babylon that uses sun, moon, and star language; Romans 8:18-23, which should come out as plainly still ahead; and Matthew 10:23, a dated saying outside the Olivet talk. The list was fixed in advance so that no one could cut a passage a different way to get a wanted answer.
Some items in the final sort were not among the 18 units. Examples are Matthew 24:15-22, the harvest in Matthew 13:39-43 and 13:49-50, the carrying out of the devil's sentence, and a later abomination of desolation. They came up when the author made his choices, and this paper calls them added passages. Parts of Matthew 24 outside the units (24:4-14, 24:23-26, 24:32-33, and 24:35) were not sorted in the original record. A final check of the paper (Round 9) took them up, and Section 11 says what was done.
The five possible answers
Each unit receives one of five answers: First century, Not yet, Open, Conflict, or Fulfilled before the New Testament. Section 1 defines them. The method began with fewer labels. A reader in Round 3 pointed out that Isaiah 13 had no place to land, because its main event came true long before the New Testament. So that label was added.
How the first design worked
The first design asked three questions about each passage. Does it describe one of the five awaited things? If not, does it carry a deadline? A deadline puts it in the first century, and a record is owed. If it does describe an awaited thing and has no deadline, it is Not yet. If it describes an awaited thing and also carries a deadline, that is a Conflict. A Conflict could be settled only by a clear break inside the passage. The design also said that the point where the text turns from one side to the other, called a seam, must be found by this process and never assumed. Small markers, such as the Greek words "peri de" at Matthew 24:36, which the NET renders "But as for", could back up a seam but could not create one.
What changed
The first test showed that this design worked as a check on a position but could not decide the hard cases. Later rounds added rules, and then the author's rule test removed every rule that did not pass. A long list of marks that were supposed to identify the five awaited events was dropped, because it argued from silence. The method that remained is simpler. A passage is placed only by a rule that passed the two-source test, by an observation of the world, or by a choice that the author made and that is labeled as a choice.
How a passage is sorted now
The record does not state the final method as one numbered procedure. This is the paper's summary of how the sorting was done in the last rounds.
- Read the verses as written, using only rules that passed.
- Look for time words that fix a deadline, such as "this generation" or "some standing here."
- Ask whether the passage is tied to one of the five awaited things by its own words, or by a statement in the text that joins it to a passage that is.
- Use the observations of the world to see whether an awaited event has happened yet.
- If a deadline reaches the passage, check that a record of fulfillment exists or can be named.
- If no rule and no observation decides, mark the passage Open and say what would close it. If the text allows two readings and the choice matters, take it to the author as a decision.
- Write down the trail: which rules, which observations, and which decisions led to the answer.

