The Olivet Discourse and Daniel 12: A Dissertation on the Sorting Work
5. The history of testing (2 of 2)
It also named defects in the rules. There was no list of joining words. There was no rule for an interval the text itself states, such as the thousand years. There was no place for passages fulfilled before the New Testament. The record rule was weak, because any large disaster in the window would satisfy it. The working session did not re-check the texts. It recorded the net status: some results stood under both readers, and a small set of findings was still open.
Round 3b: The author's rule test
The author then set the two-source test described in Section 2. The working session applied it to every rule and wrote the results into a file, which Opus had not yet seen. Rules that stood were picture language, the claim that wording is not proof of identity, the link between a question and its answer (Matthew 24:3 to 24:30), the back-reference at Matthew 25:1 and 25:13, joining by explicit statement, and the claim that near-words are true. Rules that fell were the long list of marks said to identify the five, the claim that different wording means different events, any rule that picks one verse from "Daniel the prophet," the claim that a shared feature proves one event, the 170-year limit, and the general rules for scope, carrying a date forward, groups, and records. After this, Matthew 24:36-44 stayed with the first-century coming. Matthew 25:31-46 and Daniel 12:2 became Open as to placement, because the rules that had placed them were gone.
Round 4: the rules rebuilt
Opus rebuilt the rules using only those that passed. It reported that the line at Matthew 24:36 is ruled out, that Matthew 25:31-46 is Open, and that the five awaited things stay future by their own texts plus inerrancy plus a look at the world. It also reported that the Old Greek of Daniel 12:11 matches Matthew 24:15 exactly. The working session raised two cautions. First, a check of common Greek texts had suggested that the match was not exact. Second, the ruling on 24:36 relied on carrying Luke's joining statement into Matthew, which no rule supports. The first caution was later withdrawn, as described below. The second sent the work to Round 5.
Round 5: three hard passages
Opus took three passages that were left. For Matthew 24:36, it restated the ruling on Matthew's own text alone: the answer reuses the question's words "sign" and "coming," and the word "For" in 24:37 makes "that day" the day of that coming. For Matthew 25:31-46, it found no rule that joins it to the first-century coming and none that separates it, and it named one missing observation: whether "the end of the age" in 24:3 points back to Jesus's harvest teaching in Matthew 13:39-49. For Matthew 24:15, it found that Jesus names the label that Daniel uses, not one verse. That moved Daniel 12:7 from first century to Open. The author's thanks were passed to the chat.
The working session then wrote a first combined conclusion. This was not blind-tested in that form.
Round 6: the blind test of the final rules
The blind test described in Section 4 was Round 6. Twelve of the thirteen rules passed, and one added rule passed. The reader's sort fixed the deadlines and little else. It left the Olivet coming and Matthew 24:36-44 Open, pending a choice about the reach of "all these things." Only 1 Corinthians 15:51-52 and Romans 8:18-23 came out Not yet. The reader said 1 Thessalonians 4 and Acts 1 stayed Open unless the author held one more observation of the world, namely that no visible bodily return has occurred. And it found no rule that shows the devil's final judgment is still ahead.
A separate look-up pass followed, in a fresh chat at High effort. It retrieved the texts the reader had recalled from memory. Of 26 items that state a claim that can be checked, 20 were confirmed and 6 were confirmed in part. None was contradicted. Appendix C has the details. The pass confirmed that the Old Greek of Daniel 12:11 matches Matthew's Greek exactly. The working session then wrote a second combined conclusion.
After Round 6
The six decisions in Section 7 followed, one at a time. Round 7 tested one of them, and a third combined conclusion was written to fit the final record. Sections 7 and 9 give the details.
Corrections made along the way
Several errors were found and fixed during the work. They are listed here because they show how the method was checked.
- The working session once said that Matthew 24:15's wording was "not an exact match" for the Old Greek of Daniel 12:11. That check had used Theodotion's Greek, which many common websites label "Septuagint." The look-up pass showed the Old Greek matches exactly. The statement was withdrawn.
- The working session once said that under the narrow reading of "all these things," the coming in Matthew 24:29-31 would be Open. That was wrong. The word "immediately" in 24:29, read as written (Rule 6), dates it. It was corrected.
- In writing the Round 6 brief, the working session shortened Rule 3 and dropped the qualifier "unless the text marks a shift." It disclosed this. Rule 3 failed anyway, on Luke 10:29 and 10:36 and because it conflicts with Rule 2.
- Opus's Round 5 report used Matthew 25:41 to place the devil's judgment in the future while saying that Matthew 25:31-46 could not be placed. The working session flagged this as inconsistent.
- The second combined conclusion said the devil's final judgment "rests on nothing the world can show." The author corrected this: the presence of evil is what the world shows. The working session had also recorded Decision 5 without asking him, and he corrected that too. The third combined conclusion fixes both.
- The one new finding in Round 7, that Daniel 11:31 may belong to the Greek period, rests on two judgment calls that neither the working session nor the author has made. It is therefore left Open.
- The look-up pass corrected some details Opus had recalled. The Greek of Matthew 24:34 puts its two words in the reverse order from what had been recalled, Matthew 24:39 has an extra word, a Hebrew spelling in Daniel 11:31 differed, two verses in Matthew do not use the phrase that had been assumed, and a note in the NET at Revelation 20:7 says "now," not "then." The last one matters because it means the order of events in Revelation 20 rests on the text itself and not on a translator's note.

