Michlaude Discipleship Project

The Olivet Discourse and Daniel 12: A Dissertation on the Sorting Work

4. The rules (3 of 3)

The reader passed it as forced by inerrancy, within the book. It marked the rule as conditional. No rule says when the thousand years begins, so the rule bites only on what lies after the whole span. One tension should be named. Rule 7 says near-words can never exclude anything, while Rule 9 uses the book's own "soon" to keep later items out. No sort result depends on this, because the Revelation units stay Open.

Rule 10: A thousand years can mean a long span

Scripture sometimes uses "a thousand years" for a long stretch of time. Psalm 90:4 says, "a thousand years are like yesterday that quickly passes." Second Peter 3:8 says, "a single day is like a thousand years with the Lord and a thousand years are like a single day." Ecclesiastes 6:6 is a third case.

The reader passed it as observed but weak, because the word "can" does not fix the length in Revelation 20. It supports Rule 9 and does no more.

Rule 11: "Mortal" means the physical body

When Paul uses the Greek word for "mortal," he means the physical body. The word occurs six times, all in Paul [checked online]. It describes the body in Romans 6:12 and 8:11 and flesh in 2 Corinthians 4:11 (the Greek there says "flesh," and the NET translates it "body" [checked online]), where Paul writes, "so that the life of Jesus may also be made visible in our mortal body." It stands alone in 1 Corinthians 15:53-54 and 2 Corinthians 5:4. The reader found no counter-example. In 1 Corinthians 15:53 Paul says, "this mortal body must put on immortality." The rule ties the change in that chapter to the physical body.

Rule 12: The record rule

The dated-words input requires a record. Without an observed example from Scripture, a record is not shown to meet that requirement.

The reader passed this only as a burden rule. A burden rule says who has to bring the proof. The positive examples are Isaiah 13:10 and 19:1, where cosmic language is used for named judgments. Those examples are precedent for the language. They show that such language can describe a judgment inside history, but they are not themselves an event in the first century. The reader said that the stronger form, that no other kind of record can ever count, rests on silence and so fails. In practice the effect is the same. The record for the events of AD 70 comes from outside Scripture (Josephus) and so carries the burden. It is not excluded.

Rule 13: Matthew's account and Luke's are not shown to be one occasion

Matthew places the Olivet talk privately on the Mount of Olives. Luke attaches it to a remark about the temple's decorations [checked]. No text says these are one occasion. So wording from Luke 17, Luke 21, or Mark 13 is not carried into Matthew.

The reader passed this as a result of Rule 2 plus the default reading. An earlier round found the same thing from the other side. It looked for any place where Scripture uses one account to fix the meaning of another, and it found none. This rule rests on what has not been shown, so it is a default and not a proven rule. Round 7 also cited Mark 13:14 in one place (Section 9, Result three). That use dated nothing, but it does not match this rule's own wording, and a scholar may want the rule applied the same way both times.

The added rule: "This generation"

The reader proposed one more rule and passed it. "This generation" means the people alive when the speaker spoke. The NET has the words "this generation" in Matthew 11:16, 12:41-42, and 23:36, and in Luke 7:31, 11:29-32, 11:50-51, and 17:25. Other passages in the same group use "generation" with an adjective: "an evil and adulterous generation" (Matthew 12:39), "this evil generation" (12:45), "a wicked and adulterous generation" (16:4), and "you unbelieving and perverse generation" (17:17). In the Greek, "this" appears in Matthew 12:45 but not in 12:39, 16:4, or 17:17 [checked online]. In all four, Jesus is speaking to the people in front of him. The reader found no counter-example in Matthew or Luke. Without this rule, neither Matthew 24:34 nor Luke 21:32 can be dated. It is the one rule that gives the whole sort its fixed deadline.

Rules that were tried and dropped

Along with Rule 3, several other candidates were tested and failed. A scope rule, that "all these things" covers the events just before it, failed on Matthew 24:33. A rule that "you" always means the people addressed failed on Deuteronomy 30:1 and Matthew 28:20. A ceiling on near-words, drawn from Revelation 22:10 and Daniel 8:26 and 12:4, rested on shared wording only, and 2 Peter 3:8 cuts against any ceiling. A rule that a certain Greek word means "about to" failed because Luke 7:2 is imminent and Acts 24:15 is not. A rule that "never before or after" always means literally once failed on 2 Kings 18:5 and 23:25, where each verse says a different king had no equal. That last failure matters, because it means Daniel 12:1 and Matthew 24:21 cannot be ordered by their "never before" phrases.

Which rules pass only in a limited way

Rules 6 and 13 pass as statements of the method's default reading, not as independent proof. Rule 12 passes as a burden rule. Rule 7 passes, but it can never date anything. Rule 9 passes, but only if the thousand years is long. Rule 10 passes weakly. Rule 3 failed. Appendix A puts all of this in one table.