Michlaude Discipleship Project

The Bible Reading OS

Chapter 4. Where the rules come from, and how they were tried

You may be asking a fair question. Why should you trust these tests any more than the voice in the video?

Here is my answer. Do not. Not yet.

I do not ask you to trust me. I ask you to see how the tests were made. Then check them. A test you can see into is better than a voice you cannot.

First, one caution, so you can hold it all the way through. These tests are mine. They are one man's way of keeping his reading honest. They are not Scripture, and they do not stand over it. They sit below its words. They cannot make a verse mean anything. They promise nothing. You can be wrong while you use them, and right without them. The picture from chapter 3 still fits: an operating system for reading, not for the Bible itself.

This chapter is the plain story. It has good parts and weak parts. I will tell both.

The working diary is not here. Appendix E keeps it, in order. It gives the dates and each round of testing. A round is one full pass of testing. It also gives the names I gave the other AI jobs, how the stopping rules came about, and my rulings on one rule. This chapter keeps what you need to check the tests.

What makes a rule stand

I use two tests to decide whether a rule can stand. I add one label.

The first test is observed. Scripture itself reads this way, and I can point to the verse. If I say a rule is observed, I must show where.

The second test is forced. If I denied the rule, two Bible texts would contradict each other. The rule is then forced, because the other choice breaks the text. This test starts from a belief I hold: Scripture does not contradict itself. I say that plainly. If you do not hold that belief, the forced test still shows you what the belief requires.

The label is a choice I made. Some parts of a rule are neither observed nor forced. No verse and no contradiction decides them. So I chose. In my notes the word for this is stipulated. Every time one comes up, I will say so: this part is a choice I made.

Please do not hear this as three equal ways to pass. A claim about what Scripture says stands only on the first two. The label marks what I decided, so that you can see it.

No such claim rests on silence. If Scripture's own usage does not support it, and denying it breaks no text, I make no claim. The passage stays open.

I put my own test this way. The text must support the rule. And the rule must not contradict the text.