Chapter 4. Where the rules come from, and how they were tried
Most rules, and a few working agreements
Most of the rules in this book rest on what Scripture shows, or on what keeps two texts from contradicting, or on both.
A few are of another kind. They are working agreements. One is a default: what you do when no rule fixes a word. One is a burden rule: it says who must bring what. One holds only on a condition. These make no claim about what Scripture says by themselves. They are choices I made to keep a reading honest. I mark each one plainly as a choice I made.
Two rules have no basis written down in my notes at all. They are the citation rule and the witness-limit rule. I say so where I teach them. I do not dress them up as observed.
Many rules that rest on Scripture also hold one part that is a choice I made. Where a rule has such a part, I name it.
So every rule in this book carries two plain labels in its first lines. One is its status, which I explain below. The other is its basis: observed, forced, both, a choice I made, or no basis is written down for it. You will always know what kind of rule you are holding. Appendix A lists all 25 with both labels.
Every rule must also say what would make it lose. A rule that cannot lose is not a test. It is a slogan.
That brings me to the honest claim for a rule that passed. It is small. No contradiction found in the passages checked. That is all. It does not say the rule is true. It does not say the rule is safe. It says that I looked in many places and did not find a break.
Where the rules came from
The rules grew out of work on Jesus' talk on the Mount of Olives. You can find it in Matthew 24 and 25, Mark 13 and Luke 21. Most of the rules were first tried there. That is the test bed.
The examples in this book come from across the Bible. They are applications outside the main test bed. I chose them that way on purpose, so you can see the rules at work in more than one place. And I say so, because you should know.
I also looked at what outside writers say about how to read Scripture. I kept an idea only where Scripture's own usage gave named examples. That left nine candidates. I had them challenged with objections, twice. None of those nine is taught in this book. All nine are still only proposed, and still being tested.
The rule about the Bible's age words began another way. It came from a sort of 703 uses of those words, each read in its own verse in the NET. Before that, an AI checked an earlier, smaller sort, without being told what to expect. It found that the earlier version failed two of its own tests. Those were repaired. I tell you this because a rule is only as good as its first checks.

