Michlaude Discipleship Project

The Bible Reading OS

Chapter 12. Where the rules split, ran out, or failed

Did these tests ever get it wrong? Yes. I will show you where.

If I hid it, you would have no reason to trust the rest. A voice that never says it was wrong is a voice you cannot check. A test that shows where it failed is a test you can use. You know where it stops.

So this chapter is about the dark places. The splits. The edges. The failures. And my own mistakes.

Here is the honest claim for a rule that passed. It is small. No contradiction was found in the passages checked. That is all. Nothing in this chapter makes it bigger.

A split

A split is what happens when two careful readers read the same words of a test and get two different answers. I look for splits on purpose. A split shows where my wording is loose.

Here are four.

The tie clause in the death-sense rule

The death-sense rule sorts the uses of "die", "dead" and "death" (chapter 8). One clause in it is about when two sayings are tied together. Readers split on it. They split on who counts as the second speaker. They split on what the words between the speakers mean. They split on whether the narrator's words count as speech.

So I mended the clause. Then readers split again, on something new. Mend, split. Mend, split.

So I stopped. I froze the text and gave the rule the label Passed, limited. I also wrote a stopping rule, and I wrote it down before I read the next result. Later I changed one other clause of the rule. No reader has tested that clause since, and the rule says so each time it runs. Appendix E tells the whole story once, with the dates and the stopping rule. I will not tell it twice.

The nearness-length rule

Chapter 7 teaches this rule. Chapter 4 tells its life in short. Here I give only what is still open.

Fresh readers ran it three times. Each time, it passed in part. Two disagreements stay open.

The first is how much weight one part of its basis carries. That part says a near word by itself gives no length. The readers weighed it on Haggai 2:6 with Hebrews 12:26.

The second is how far a narrow exception reaches. That exception is tied to Matthew 28.

After my rulings, fresh readers have not tested the wording again. The rule says so every time it runs.

The old line about what a witness can speak to

The old line said that witnesses speak to what happened, not to which event a prophecy named. One reader read it two ways at 1 Kings 16:34.

During Ahab’s reign, Hiel the Bethelite rebuilt Jericho. Abiram, his firstborn son, died when he laid the foundation; Segub, his youngest son, died when he erected its gates, in keeping with the Lord’s message that he had spoken through Joshua son of Nun. (1 Kings 16:34 NET)

Here is the question. Does the line reach a statement, in Scripture's own voice, that an event fulfilled a saying? Here the narrator ties the deaths to a message spoken through Joshua. The old line, read alone, did not say.

I left the old line word for word. It stays a limit, not a rule, and it never supports anything. Then I set a new wording beside it. The new wording keeps the first sentence. It adds two more. A statement in Scripture's own voice is not cancelled. That is Scripture naming the link. It is not a witness deciding the link. I said yes to all three sentences. The new form is the witness-limit rule in chapter 9.

The count of witnesses

The opened part of the two-or-three witnesses rule says that agreeing witnesses may count toward an outside record that an event happened. The count is a help. It is never a requirement.

Readers read the rule's count sentence two ways. That happened on writings outside the Bible, from two early writers. It happened beside a wording that is still being tried. The question was this. Does falling short of the count make an event not shown?

I wrote down that the count is a help and never a requirement. The count sentence is my own choice. I left the split in the rule's limit, as mine to settle.

Scripture itself has a picture of agreeing witnesses to an event. Boaz speaks at the gate.

You are witnesses today that I have acquired from Naomi all that belonged to Elimelech, Kilion, and Mahlon. (Ruth 4:9 NET)

The people answer, "We are witnesses" (Ruth 4:11 NET). The verses name witnesses. They give no number. I come back to Ruth below.