Michlaude Discipleship Project

Chapter 12. Where the rules split, ran out, or failed

One place the rules run out

This last one is open. I have not sorted it, and I do not sort it here.

The a-book's-soon rule says that a book cannot call "soon" what it places after its own long wait. Chapter 7 teaches it. Here is a place in Jeremiah where a reader may ask how that rule fits. I give you the verses, and what each one says. Nothing more.

First, Jeremiah 25 gives a span of seventy years.

These nations will be subject to the king of Babylon for seventy years. (Jeremiah 25:11 NET) But when the seventy years are over, I will punish the king of Babylon and his nation for their sins. (Jeremiah 25:12 NET)

These verses say the nations will serve the king of Babylon for seventy years. When the seventy years are over, the king of Babylon and his nation are punished.

Second, Jeremiah 29 speaks of a long wait. In that chapter, a man in Babylon writes a letter. In it he reports what Jeremiah wrote to the exiles there: "You will be there a long time" (Jeremiah 29:28 NET). So the words come to us inside one letter that quotes another.

Third, much later in the book, comes a word about Babylon itself.

The time for her to be cut down and harvested will come very soon. (Jeremiah 51:33 NET)

Earlier in that verse, the one called "her" is "Fair Babylon" (Jeremiah 51:33 NET). The NET's "very soon" stands on two Hebrew words, od, "still", and me'at, "little".

A reader may ask whether one book calls "soon" something it places after a long wait. That turns on another question first. Do Jeremiah 51:33 and Jeremiah 25:12 speak of one event? Both name Babylon. The same-words rule speaks of shared words that describe. It does not speak of names. Whether it reaches a shared name like Babylon is not settled. This book does not rule on it.

So I leave these verses side by side, unsorted. I do not say what they mean for the a-book's-soon rule. I do not say what they mean for Revelation. I say only that this is a place where the rules run out, and I will not hide it.