Not Yet Seen
What the fully-fulfilled view needs, and where each stands (1 of 2)
Writers who hold the fully-fulfilled view differ among themselves: for example, on whether the resurrection and Christ's risen body were bodily, on whether those who had died saw the coming, and on what shape the resurrection takes. So each need below is a need of the view as I state it here (everything fulfilled in AD 70). A writer on that side who does not hold a given need is not answered by it, and the other needs still stand.
- A non-bodily resurrection. Shown against on Rule 11 for what 1 Corinthians 15:53-54 says, and, as I read it, for the raising of the dead in 15:52. Paul's "mortal" (to thnēton touto) means the physical body in all six places he uses it. I take that to reach "the resurrection" because of how the passage runs. Paul writes, "the dead will be raised imperishable, and we will be changed" (15:52), and goes straight on: "For this perishable body must put on the imperishable, and this mortal body must put on immortality" (15:53; the Greek has gar, "for", and no word for "body"). I read the raising of 15:52 and the mortal putting on immortality in 15:53-54 as one subject, from that run; the verse numbers are not Paul's.
- Death defeated in AD 70.
- From the text: not shown. Paul says death is swallowed up "when ... this mortal puts on immortality" (15:54). On Rule 11, "mortal" is the physical body, and no record shows that happening in AD 70.
- From what we see (an observation, not a rule result): people still die. This fits the text, but the text result does not rest on it.
- An early Revelation. Not shown. Irenaeus, quoted in Greek by Eusebius, puts what "was seen" toward the end of Domitian's rule. The Greek form does not show whether "it" or "he" was seen (point 7).
- Witnesses who saw it fulfilled. Not shown. No early writer saying it was all fulfilled was found in the writers cited here (the Didache, Polycarp, Irenaeus, Tertullian, Eusebius's Church History Book 3, Cyril, Chrysostom), and "not found" is not the same as "none".
- A coming no one saw. Not shown. Jesus warned, "if someone says to you, 'Look, he is in the wilderness,' do not go out, or 'Look, he is in the inner rooms,' do not believe him. For just like the lightning comes from the east and flashes to the west, so the coming of the Son of Man will be" (Matthew 24:26-27). And the men in white said he "will come back in the same way you saw him go into heaven" (Acts 1:11). I read that warning as telling against a coming no one saw.
- "Near" meaning a few years. Not shown. A near-word by itself gives no length (Rule 7: near-words set no length). Scripture's own cases show it where the text itself states the link, and on my reading where it does not: it sets near-words beside things that came long after (how long, by the scholarship dates in the note below) and beside things that came soon. How each case is tied, said plainly: the first is tied by the text itself through a word of promising, because Hebrews calls the words a promise ("he has promised"); whether it is the same promise as Haggai's, the text does not say, and I read it as the same. In the second and third, joining the near-word to Babylon's fall is my reading, from the names and the scroll the texts give.
- Haggai 2:6 with Hebrews 12:26-27. Haggai said, "In just a little while I will once again shake the sky and the earth" (Haggai 2:6; Hebrew od achat me'at hi, "yet once, it is a little"). Hebrews has "once more" (Greek eti hapax, "yet once"; Haggai's Hebrew has od achat, "yet one") and calls it a promise: "now he has promised, 'I will once more shake not only the earth but heaven too'" (Hebrews 12:26; Greek epēngeltai, "he has promised"). Then it explains the word: "this phrase 'once more' indicates the removal of what is shaken" (12:27). Hebrews does not name Haggai, and its wording is not Haggai's (Haggai has "once again shake the sky and the earth"). The tie is the word of promising, "he has promised": the nearness rule counts a later text's word of saying or promising as a tie, and the same rule says it does not decide whether Hebrews 12:26 is the same promise as Haggai 2:6. I read it as the same promise. On that reading, long after "a little while" (how long, by the scholarship dates below), the shaking is still a promise ahead.
- Isaiah 13:6 with 13:1, 13:17 and Daniel 5:30-31. "Wail, for the Lord's day of judgment is near" (Isaiah 13:6; Hebrew qarov, "near"). The text ties it to Babylon: it is "an oracle about Babylon that Isaiah son of Amoz saw" (13:1), and in the same oracle God says, "I am stirring up the Medes to attack them" (13:17). Isaiah's messages came in the reigns of Uzziah, Jotham, Ahaz and Hezekiah (Isaiah 1:1). Daniel records Babylon's end: "that very night Belshazzar, the Babylonian king, was killed. So Darius the Mede took control of the kingdom" (Daniel 5:30-31). That Daniel's night is the day Isaiah called near is my reading, from the names the two texts share: the Chaldeans (Isaiah 13:19; Daniel 5:30) and the Medes (Isaiah 13:17; Daniel 5:31). Isaiah names "the Chaldeans" (Isaiah 13:19; Hebrew kasdim) and "the Medes" (Isaiah 13:17; Hebrew madai). Daniel has "the Babylonian king" (Daniel 5:30) in the NET, where the Aramaic word is kasdaah, "Chaldeans", and "Darius the Mede" (Daniel 5:31; Aramaic madaah).
- Jeremiah 51:33 with 51:59-64. "The time for her to be cut down and harvested will come very soon" (Jeremiah 51:33; Hebrew od me'at, "yet a little"). I read it as part of the scroll's prophecies: "Jeremiah recorded on one scroll all the judgments that would come upon Babylon—all these prophecies written about Babylon" (51:60). He sent it in "the fourth year" of King Zedekiah (51:59), to be read aloud in Babylon and thrown into the Euphrates with the words, "In the same way Babylon will sink and never rise again" (51:64). That the time Jeremiah called "very soon" is Babylon's fall, which Daniel records (Daniel 5:30-31), is my reading, from the scroll's words against Babylon.
- Dates, as scholarship (not the text):
- Haggai's "second year" of King Darius (Haggai 1:1, 1:15) is about 520 BC.
- Hebrews is about AD 63-64 if early, or AD 70-100 if late. So the shaking was still a promise about 580 to 620 years after Haggai.
- Hezekiah's reign ended about 687 BC, and Babylon fell in 539 BC: about 150 years or more after Isaiah 13:6.
- Zedekiah's fourth year is about 594/593 BC: about 55 years before Babylon fell.
- In fairness, near-words also stand before short waits.
- In Gethsemane (Matthew 26:36) Jesus said, "Look, the hour is approaching, and the Son of Man is betrayed into the hands of sinners" (26:45; Greek ēngiken hē hōra, "the hour has drawn near"). "While he was still speaking, Judas, one of the twelve, arrived" (26:47), and "they came and took hold of Jesus and arrested him" (26:50). Here the near-word and the event stand in one scene, told by the narrator: Judas arrives while Jesus is still speaking. The nearness rule names exactly this, in its own words, as "an event the text tells as arriving while the word is being spoken", one of the few things that can add a length or a bound to a near-word. It is not one of the rule's ties between a saying and another text. Earlier, on "the first day of the feast of Unleavened Bread" (26:17), Jesus had sent a message to a man in the city: "My time is near" (26:18; Greek ho kairos mou engus). That evening he ate the Passover with the twelve (26:20) and told Peter, "on this night, before the rooster crows, you will deny me three times" (26:34). That the "time" of 26:18 is the hour of 26:45 is my reading: 26:18 is a message for a man in the city, and its word is kairos, "time", not hōra, "hour".
- Ezekiel said "the day is near" (Ezekiel 7:7) to "the land of Israel" (7:2). That message is not dated ("The Lord's message came to me", 7:1); it stands in the book before his "sixth year" (8:1). The news "The city has been defeated!" reached him in "the twelfth year of our exile" (33:21). The year numbers are Ezekiel's own. A wait of six years or more is my reading, and the order of the book is the only reason for it: the message of 7:7 is undated, and an undated message's place in the book is not a date. That the day of 7:7 is the fall reported in 33:21 is my reading too.
- So Scripture has both kinds.

