Michlaude Discipleship Project

Not Yet Seen

His return will be seen (2 of 5)

3. On the Mount of Olives, Jesus prepared his disciples for the years after he left.

Peter, James, John, and Andrew "asked him privately" (Mark 13:3; all four are among the twelve, Mark 3:14-18), and he told them: "You will be handed over to councils and beaten in the synagogues. You will stand before governors and kings because of me ... for it is not you speaking, but the Holy Spirit" (Mark 13:9-11). In a different talk, the night before he died ("Now it was night", John 13:30; 18:1, 28; 19:16-18), he told them why he warned them: "I have told you all these things so that you will not fall away" (John 16:1). Acts tells of the same kinds of things happening. The apostles were jailed and beaten (Acts 5), "a great persecution began" (Acts 8:1), and Paul stood before "King Agrippa" and "the governor" Festus (Acts 25:13, 23; 26:30). Acts does not say these things fulfilled Jesus' words, so that link is my reading.

4. The birth pains are only a beginning, and the birth is the resurrection. (The second half is my reading: Jesus does not say what the birth is.)

Wars, famines and earthquakes "are the beginning of birth pains" (Matthew 24:8). Of the wars Jesus says, "this must happen, but the end is still to come" (24:6); Luke has "the end will not come at once" (Luke 21:9). "Then they will hand you over to be persecuted" (Matthew 24:9). That "Then" (Greek tote) is a plain "then"; by itself it does not join the persecutions to the first pains or set their order. Luke's account says, "But before all this, they will seize you and persecute you" (Luke 21:12; Greek pro de toutōn pantōn, "before all these things"). So I do not rest anything on which comes first. Of the persecutions, here is what is written: "the person who endures to the end will be saved" (Matthew 24:13), and "this gospel of the kingdom will be preached throughout the whole inhabited earth as a testimony to all the nations, and then the end will come" (24:14). I read that whole stretch as labor. I read Paul's own labor picture as telling us what is being born: "we ... groan inwardly as we eagerly await our adoption, the redemption of our bodies" (Romans 8:22-23).

5. The resurrection is bodily, and nothing shows it happened in AD 70.

The fully-fulfilled view links Daniel 12:2 ("Many of those who sleep in the dusty ground will awake") to 1 Corinthians 15:54. That link brings in what Paul says there: "when ... this mortal puts on immortality, then the saying that is written will happen, 'Death has been swallowed up in victory'" (15:54). In Greek, "this mortal" is to thnēton touto. The NET adds "body" in 15:53, and the Greek has no word for it. But Paul's word "mortal" (thnētos) means the physical body in all six places he uses it. So the thing that puts on immortality is the physical body. Paul gives the order: "each in his own order: Christ, the firstfruits; then when Christ comes, those who belong to him" (15:23; Greek tagmati, "order"). His "then" is epeita ("then", the STEP gloss). As I read it, it is a word of sequence: it puts "those who belong to him" after Christ, at his coming, and it gives no length. No record shows the dead raised or the living changed in AD 70.

What "mortal" reaches. Rule 11 ("mortal" is the physical body) is about one word, thnētos, but Paul's own sentences set that word on "body" and "flesh": "do not let sin reign in your mortal body" (Romans 6:12; Greek sōmati); "will also make your mortal bodies alive" (Romans 8:11; sōmata); "made visible in our mortal body" (2 Corinthians 4:11; the Greek is thnētē sarki, "mortal flesh"). In 1 Corinthians 15 he pairs the words himself: "Flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom of God, nor does the perishable inherit the imperishable" (1 Corinthians 15:50); "this perishable puts on the imperishable, and this mortal puts on immortality" (1 Corinthians 15:54). And "what is raised is imperishable" (1 Corinthians 15:42; the same Greek word, aphtharsia), which Paul calls "a spiritual body" (15:44). That the "mortal" of 15:53-54 is the "body" of 15:35-44 is my reading, from these pairs and the run of the passage; shared words alone do not join passages (Rule 2). A further reading, as I read it: Paul's own verb for the mortal is "put on" (15:53-54; Greek enduō, "to put on" or "to clothe"), and in another letter he writes, "we do not want to be unclothed, but clothed, so that what is mortal may be swallowed up by life" (2 Corinthians 5:4; Greek ekdusasthai, "to be unclothed", ependusasthai, "to be clothed", and to thnēton, "the mortal"). So the mortal is clothed, not left behind. The text does not join the two letters, and shared words do not join them, so this step is my reading.

6. The early church was still waiting after AD 70.

Eusebius's Church History, Book 3, is the history usually cited for the flight to Pella before Jerusalem fell. The same book says this:

  • Jerusalem's fall came "in accordance with the prophecies of our Lord" (ch. 7). I agree with that; that is my own judgment, not a rule result.
  • Eusebius says "It is said" that John was condemned to dwell on Patmos "in this persecution", the one under Domitian (ch. 17-18).
  • Jude's grandsons told Domitian that Christ's kingdom "would appear at the end of the world, when he should come in glory to judge the quick and the dead" (ch. 20).
  • John lived "until the time of Trajan" (ch. 23, Eusebius quoting Irenaeus).
  • Eusebius names "the resurrection of the dead" among "the doctrines of the Church", and says those who followed false teachers instead "have fallen away from the true hope" (ch. 26).
  • Eusebius reports that Papias taught "a period of some thousand years after the resurrection of the dead" (ch. 39). So for Papias the resurrection was still ahead. Eusebius himself disagrees with Papias about the thousand years.

Irenaeus, about AD 180, writes, "then the Lord will come from heaven in the clouds" (Against Heresies 5.30.4). Tertullian reads the Olivet Discourse as I do: first the events "until the overthrow of Jerusalem", then events "up to the very end of the world". He asks, "Who has yet beheld Jesus descending from heaven in like manner as the apostles saw Him ascend?" (On the Resurrection of the Flesh 22). Polycarp writes that Christ "comes as the Judge of the living and the dead" (To the Philippians 2). The Apostles' Creed says, "From thence he shall come to judge the quick and the dead."

None of the early writers cited here (the Didache, Polycarp, Irenaeus, Tertullian, Eusebius, Cyril, Chrysostom) says everything was fulfilled in AD 70. These records show what the church believed, not that it was right.

An argument from silence, and why this silence may have a voice. What follows is an argument, not a rule result. Silence alone proves nothing, and I do not claim it does. But large acts of God like these are not quiet, and here we are arguing over something that, if it happened, went unnoticed.