Not Yet Seen
His return will be seen (3 of 5)
- Scripture says the coming will be seen: "every eye will see him" (Revelation 1:7); "They will see the Son of Man arriving on the clouds of heaven" (Matthew 24:30).
- At Matthew 27:53, when the raised saints came out, Scripture says people saw them: they "went into the holy city and appeared to many people" (Matthew 27:53; Greek enephanisthēsan pollois, "were made to appear to many").
- Other great acts are recorded as noticed, even by opponents. At Pentecost "a crowd gathered" from "every nation under heaven" (Acts 2:5-6). The council said, "it is plain to all who live in Jerusalem that a notable miraculous sign has come about through them, and we cannot deny it" (Acts 4:16). After Lazarus was raised, "some of them went to the Pharisees and reported to them what Jesus had done", and the council was called together (John 11:46-47). Paul told the king, "this was not done in a corner" (Acts 26:26).
The limits, said plainly:
- Scripture also records acts that few saw, or that were hidden on purpose. The risen Jesus was seen "not by all the people, but by us, the witnesses God had already chosen" (Acts 10:41). At Cana the head steward did not know where the wine came from, "though the servants who had drawn the water knew" (John 2:9). To those outside, Jesus spoke in parables, "so that although they look they may look but not see" (Mark 4:12). So silence alone is not proof.
- The record of those years is not silent about everything. Josephus (Jewish War 6.5.3) lists signs around the war: a star like a sword over the city, a comet that lasted a year, a light around the altar, the heavy temple gate opening by itself, and "chariots and troops of soldiers" seen "among the clouds". Tacitus (Histories 5.13) reports armies seen meeting in the sky and the temple doors opening by themselves. If anyone takes the armies in the clouds to be the coming, look at what is described: chariots and soldiers, not the Son of Man. And Josephus says the people did not agree on what the signs meant.
- So the silence is specific. People in AD 66-70 noticed strange things and wrote them down. In Josephus's Jewish War and Antiquities, Tacitus's Histories and Eusebius's Church History, Book 3, no passage was found that describes the dead raised, or the Son of Man seen, in AD 66-70. That is "not found", not "none exists".
That is why the absence is worth weighing. The same writers who recorded a comet and a gate that opened by itself recorded no resurrection of the dead and no Son of Man on the clouds. This does not prove the fully-fulfilled view wrong, and it bears only on the forms of that view that claim a coming people could see, just as the needs below are needs of the view as I state it there. It means those forms of the view ask us to believe that the two largest events they claim went unrecorded by the people who were writing down the strange things of those very years.
7. If Revelation was written late, the fully-fulfilled reading of Revelation falls.
Irenaeus gives the date. His Greek survives because Eusebius quotes it twice (3.18.3 and 5.8.6):
oude gar pro pollou chronou heōrathē, alla schedon epi tēs hēmeteras geneas, pros tō telei tēs Dometianou archēs.
"For it was seen not long ago, but almost in our own generation, toward the end of Domitian's rule."
The verb "was seen" (heōrathē) is the same verb as "the one who saw the revelation" just before it, so the thing seen is the revelation. The Greek form itself does not show whether "it" or "he" is meant. That is why some say Irenaeus meant that John was seen. But Eusebius, a native Greek reader, sums the passage up as "recorded ... about the Apocalypse" (5.8.7). And Irenaeus says John lived until Trajan's reign. If he had meant that John was seen alive, he would have named Trajan's time, not the end of Domitian's reign.
Domitian ruled from AD 81 to 96 by the standard dating, so this means about AD 95 or 96, some 25 years after the temple fell. If that is when John wrote:
- A book that shows "what must happen after these things" (4:1) cannot be announcing the AD 70 judgment as still ahead.
- "Do not seal ... because the time is near" (22:10) points past AD 70: as I read it, on the late date, a time still called near in AD 95 had not yet come.
- "Come, Lord Jesus!" (22:20) is the church still praying for his coming after AD 70.
If Revelation was written before AD 70 instead (the early date, as some scholars date it), then, as I read them, these three places show nothing about AD 70 either way, and my case does not depend on which date is right.
The arguments for an early date do not hold up:
- The temple is measured in Revelation 11. Ezekiel measured a temple in a vision "in the fourteenth year after the city was struck down" (Ezekiel 40:1-3).
- "Near" means before AD 70. That uses the date to prove the meaning and the meaning to prove the date.
- The sixth king is Nero. The verse names no one.
- 666 is Nero. Irenaeus counted it "according to the reckoning of the Greeks", by Greek letters, not Hebrew ones. He tested three names, and Nero was not one of them.
The date stays open, because the Bible does not print it. But the fully-fulfilled reading of Revelation needs the early date, and it is not shown. My case works with either date.
8. Matthew 24:30 is the future return.
"Then the sign of the Son of Man will appear in heaven, and all the tribes of the earth will mourn. They will see the Son of Man arriving on the clouds of heaven with power and great glory. And he will send his angels with a loud trumpet blast, and they will gather his elect from the four winds, from one end of heaven to the other." (Matthew 24:30-31)
I read this as Jesus' return, still ahead. Here is why, from the verses.
- It is seen. "They will see" (Greek opsontai). Mark has the same: "Then everyone will see the Son of Man arriving in the clouds" (Mark 13:26). There, "everyone" is the NET's word; the Greek has only opsontai, "they will see", so I do not lean on "everyone". Three verses earlier, Jesus said his coming would not be hidden "in the inner rooms" but would flash "like the lightning ... from the east ... to the west" (24:26-27).
- It matches how he left. He went up "while they were watching" and "a cloud hid him from their sight". He "will come back in the same way you saw him go into heaven" (Acts 1:9-11). In Matthew 24:30, he comes "on the clouds of heaven".
- "Every eye will see him." Revelation speaks of the same two pictures, the clouds and the mourning of "all the tribes on the earth": "He is returning with the clouds, and every eye will see him, even those who pierced him, and all the tribes on the earth will mourn because of him" (Revelation 1:7).
- What comes with it is the end. He sends angels with "a loud trumpet blast" to "gather his elect" (24:31). Paul says, "the Lord himself will come down from heaven ... with the trumpet of God, and the dead in Christ will rise first" (1 Thessalonians 4:16), and "the trumpet will sound, and the dead will be raised imperishable" (1 Corinthians 15:52). Paul also gives the order: "then when Christ comes, those who belong to him" (15:23; epeita, "then", the STEP gloss; as I read it, a word of sequence, as in point 5). Jesus uses a like picture for "the end of the age": "The Son of Man will send his angels, and they will gather" (Matthew 13:39-41). The Greek words for "gather" differ (sullexousin in 13:41, episunaxousin in 24:31), and a like picture does not by itself make one event.
- I read a turn at 24:36, from three marks together. "But as for that day and hour no one knows it—not even the angels in heaven—except the Father alone" (24:36). Three marks come together there. Jesus opens with Peri de, "Now concerning". "Day" is singular for the first time, "that day" (tēs hēmeras ekeinēs), after "those days" in the plural every time before it in the speech (24:19, 22, 29). And "hour" (hōras) appears for the first time in the speech. Mark has Peri de and the first singular "that day" at the same place (Mark 13:32). Peri de alone does not always open a new subject: Jesus uses it to take up the resurrection the Sadducees had already raised (Matthew 22:31; Mark 12:26), and Paul uses it for what the Corinthians wrote to him about (1 Corinthians 7:1). So my reading of a turn rests on the three marks together, not on Peri de by itself; no rule gives it. From there on, Jesus speaks of a coming whose day and hour no one knows, and of staying alert for it.

