Michlaude Discipleship Project

Not Yet Seen

His return will be seen (4 of 5)

What the text does not settle, said plainly.

  • Matthew 24:30 comes before 24:34: "this generation will not pass away until all these things take place". The fully-fulfilled view says 24:30 is among "all these things", so it happened within that generation.
  • "Immediately after the suffering of those days" (24:29) ties the signs closely to the trouble just described. This is the hardest verse for my reading. Here is what the text gives on it, and no more:
  • "Immediately" (Greek eutheōs, with its short form euthus) is used 18 times in Matthew, and 24:29 is the only one in Matthew 24. In a story it joins two things in one scene: "Immediately his leprosy was cleansed" (8:3). In a parable no time is stated: "when trouble or persecution comes because of the word, immediately he falls away" (13:21); the servant with five talents "went off right away" (25:15-16). None of the 18 gives a number of days or years.
  • The three accounts agree in order, but not in the word. Mark says, "But in those days, after that suffering, the sun will be darkened" (Mark 13:24), with no "immediately". Luke has no matching clause. Between "those days" (Luke 21:23) and the "signs in the sun and moon and stars" (21:25), Luke puts "Jerusalem will be trampled down by the Gentiles until the times of the Gentiles are fulfilled" (21:24). Luke's only "immediately" word in the whole talk is a "not": "the end will not come at once" (21:9; Greek ouk eutheōs, "not immediately").
  • "Those days" are the days of the flight from Judea, the great suffering, and the days "cut short" (Matthew 24:16-22). The text says they will be cut short, and states no length for them.
  • So the text does not say how long "immediately" covers, or how long "those days" last. Whether Luke's "until the times of the Gentiles are fulfilled" stands at the same place as Matthew's "immediately" is not shown. I do not claim this settles the verse: not shown either way. My aim is to say what the text gives.
  • The text itself does not say where the break falls between the events of that generation and "that day".

So the claim that 24:30 is the future return is my reading from the verses. My answer rests on 24:33: "when you see all these things, know that he is near, right at the door." There, "all these things" are signs that are seen, and they point to something else that is near. Jesus goes straight on: "this generation will not pass away until all these things take place" (24:34). The same two Greek words, panta tauta, "all these things", stand back to back, first for what the readers "see" (24:33) and then for the things that "take place" (24:34). (That order is the NA28 text's; the local STEP data marks a different place for the words in 24:33 in the Tyndale House, Tregelles and Byzantine texts, and I rest nothing on the order.) The text names no list of what they are. If they are the same set, then the generation sees the signs, not necessarily the coming itself. But that is a reading too, and the rules do not decide what "all these things" covers. My reading also carries a burden. Rule 12 (dated words need a record that they were met) asks it of both sides: with "this generation" granted, whatever "all these things" covers took place within that generation, and that needs a record. I hold the other side to it ("No record shows", point 5), so I hold mine to it too: on my reading, a record has to show that the signs of 24:33 took place within that generation. One record is in Scripture: Acts tells that events of the kind Jesus foretold on the Mount of Olives happened, beginning with the apostles who heard him, who were jailed and beaten (Acts 5), and going on to "a great persecution" (Acts 8:1) and Paul before a king and a governor (point 3). So for such events happening within that generation, the record is in Scripture itself. The other records I cite for those years are outside Scripture (Josephus and Tacitus, point 6). None of these records, Acts included, says that those events are the signs of 24:33 (Acts does not say they fulfilled Jesus' words, point 3); that link is my reading. So on my reading Rule 12's burden is not shown to be met; the two parts are these: Scripture records that such events happened (Acts), and the link between those events and the signs of 24:33 is not shown. "Not shown" is not "did not happen".

The same test applies to both sides. Shared words alone do not prove two passages speak of one event. That test cuts against my use of 1 Thessalonians 4 and 1 Corinthians 15 here just as much as against theirs. It also applies to my joining of Acts 1:11 and Revelation 1:7 to Matthew 24:30. Those joins are my reading, and whoever joins passages carries the burden of showing the join.

The strongest opposing reading, named fairly: the vindication reading. Scholars who put 24:30 in AD 70 do not say Jesus came in a way no one saw. They say 24:30 is about Jesus being vindicated and enthroned in heaven, with the fall of Jerusalem as the sign of it. R. T. France reads the coming in 24:30 "not of a "coming" to earth at the parousia but of a "coming" to God" (The Gospel of Matthew). Kenneth Gentry writes that "the judgments serve as a sign that the Son of Man is enthroned" ("The Sign of the Son of Man (1)"). N. T. Wright reads the "coming on the clouds" sayings in Mark 13:26 and 14:62 as "about Jesus' vindication, his "coming" to heaven from earth" ("Farewell to the Rapture"); that article does not name Matthew 24:30. Their key verse is Daniel 7:13: "with the clouds of the sky one like a son of man was approaching. He went up to the Ancient of Days and was escorted before him." In Daniel, the son of man comes to God to receive a kingdom, not down to earth. They also point to Jesus' words to the high priest: "from now on you will see the Son of Man sitting at the right hand of the Power and coming on the clouds of heaven" (Matthew 26:64; Greek ap' arti, "from now on").

The answer from the verses.

  • Daniel 7:13 fits my reading too. Daniel sees one like a son of man "with the clouds of the sky" coming to the Ancient of Days, and he receives "ruling authority, honor, and sovereignty" (Daniel 7:13-14). The Aramaic says he "reached" (meta) the Ancient of Days and was "brought near" (haqrevuhi) before him. The New Testament shows that movement toward God at the ascension. "a cloud hid him from their sight" (Acts 1:9). He is "exalted to the right hand of God" (Acts 2:33). "All authority in heaven and on earth has been given to me" (Matthew 28:18). Then the men in white say he will "come back in the same way you saw him go" (Acts 1:11). John takes the same cloud picture and writes "every eye will see him" (Revelation 1:7; the Greek verb is erchetai, "he is coming"). Jesus' own words to the high priest fit the same two steps: "from now on you will see the Son of Man sitting at the right hand of the Power and coming on the clouds of heaven" (Matthew 26:64). The sitting at the right hand begins at the ascension (Acts 2:33). The coming on the clouds is the part Acts 1:11 and Revelation 1:7 place at the return. All of this is my reading, and shared words alone do not prove one event, so the burden is mine. This point does not carry my case. My case rests on Matthew 24:26-27, 24:31, Acts 1:11 and Revelation 1:7. If Daniel 7:13 shows only movement to the Ancient of Days, it does not decide between the two readings, and it does not rule mine out.
  • In Matthew 24:30-31, the coming is followed by action on earth. He sends angels "from one end of heaven to the other" to gather his elect, and "all the tribes of the earth will mourn" as they "see" him.
  • Jesus has just said that his coming is like lightning seen from east to west (24:27), not a scene in heaven that people on earth cannot see.
  • Cloud language by itself cannot prove a final event or rule one out. So the case rests on what Matthew 24 itself speaks of with the clouds: seeing, lightning, trumpet, angels and the gathering of the elect.