Not Yet Seen
What the fully-fulfilled view would raise, and my answer
I named the vindication reading as the strongest reading of Matthew 24:30. Here are the strongest other texts the fully-fulfilled view brings, in the NET's words, with what that view uses each one for and my answer.
- Matthew 16:28. "there are some standing here who will not experience death before they see the Son of Man coming in his kingdom." Their use: some of Jesus' hearers would live to see his coming, so it came in their lifetime. My answer: Matthew dates the next thing he tells: "Six days later Jesus took with him Peter, James, and John ... And he was transfigured before them. His face shone like the sun" (17:1-2). I read 16:28 as pointing to that: some of those standing there saw him in his glory within the week. Counting the six days from 16:28 is my reading too: Matthew prints no anchor for "Six days later", and he tells it after the sayings of 16:24-28. The chapter number between the two is not Matthew's. Matthew does not write "this fulfilled it", so that is my reading. The words just before speak of the Son of Man coming "with his angels in the glory of his Father" to "reward each person according to what he has done" (16:27). Which of the two 16:28 points to, the text does not say: not shown either way. The rules apply to my side too, so here is what the other branch gives. 16:28 prints no near-word. But the nearness rule (only a few things can give a saying a length or a limit, and one is a span measured by a death) takes "some standing here who will not experience death before they see" as such a span: whatever 16:28 names is seen before all of those standing there have died. The same rule does not say which event a saying names. So if 16:28 points to the coming of 16:27, that coming falls within the lifetime of some who stood there; if it points to the transfiguration, it came six days later. I read it as the transfiguration; that is my reading, not the text's words.
- Matthew 23:36. "I tell you the truth, this generation will be held responsible for all these things!" (Greek hēxei tauta panta epi tēn genean tautēn, "all these things will come upon this generation"). Their use: the same "all these things" and "this generation" come again in 24:34, so everything in Matthew 24 came on that generation. My answer: I grant "this generation": it means the people alive when Jesus spoke. I read "all these things" here as the blood of the verse just before: "on you will come all the righteous blood shed on earth, from the blood of righteous Abel to the blood of Zechariah" (23:35). The verse does not say "these things are" that blood, and no rule fixes what "these" covers, so that is my reading. On it, 23:36 is judgment for the blood of the prophets, and I read it as having come on that generation. Jesus goes straight on to Jerusalem: "Look, your house is left to you desolate!" (23:38), and then to the temple: "not one stone will be left on another" (24:2). But in the same breath he says, "you will not see me from now until you say, 'Blessed is the one who comes in the name of the Lord!'" (23:39; Greek ap' arti heōs an, "from now until"). I read that as a seeing of Jesus still ahead, after the house is left desolate. 23:36 names the judgment; it does not name the coming on the clouds or the raising of the dead. And 23:36 and 24:34 are said in different places to different hearers ("to the crowds and to his disciples", 23:1; "privately" on the Mount of Olives, 24:3). In the NA28 text the Greek words also stand in a different order (tauta panta in 23:36, panta tauta in 24:34), but the local STEP data marks a different place for them in 23:36 in the Tyndale House, Tregelles and Byzantine texts, so I rest nothing on the order. Shared words alone do not join two passages (Rule 2), on either side, so whether 24:34's "all these things" is the same list is not shown either way.
- Luke 13:35. "you will not see me until you say, 'Blessed is the one who comes in the name of the Lord!'" (Luke 13:35). Their use: Luke has this before Jesus reaches Jerusalem, where his disciples cry "Blessed is the king who comes in the name of the Lord!" (Luke 19:38), so it may be met there, not at a coming still ahead. My answer: in Luke it was said to Jerusalem (13:34) and cried by "the whole crowd of his disciples" (Luke 19:37); whether it was met there is not shown, and I rest nothing on Luke. Matthew, which I quote, has the other order: the crowds shout "Blessed is the one who comes in the name of the Lord!" (Matthew 21:9) as he enters the city, and later Jesus says "you will not see me from now until you say" (Matthew 23:39; Greek ap' arti, "from now"). So in Matthew the seeing is still ahead when he speaks. The verse gives no date; that it is his return is my reading.
- 1 John 2:18. "Children, it is the last hour ... so now many antichrists have appeared. We know from this that it is the last hour." Their use: John's readers stood at the very end, so the end came in their time. My answer: the verse says "it is the last hour" (Greek eschatē hōra), and it gives John's own sign for it: "many antichrists have appeared". It does not say that Christ has come, and it does not say how long the hour lasts. In the same letter, John still looks ahead: "remain in him, so that when he appears we may have confidence and not shrink away from him in shame when he comes back" (2:28; Greek en tē parousia autou, "at his coming"), and "whenever it is revealed we will be like him, because we will see him just as he is" (3:2). So John wrote in "the last hour" and still waited for Christ to appear.
- James 5:8 and 1 Peter 4:7. "the Lord's return is near" (James 5:8; Greek hē parousia tou kuriou ēngiken, "the coming of the Lord has drawn near"); "the culmination of all things is near" (1 Peter 4:7; Greek pantōn de to telos ēngiken, "the end of all things has drawn near"). Their use: "near" means within a few years. My answer: need 6: a near-word by itself gives no length. James himself tells his readers to wait like a farmer: "be patient, brothers and sisters, until the Lord's return. Think of how the farmer waits for the precious fruit of the ground and is patient for it until it receives the early and late rains" (James 5:7).
- John 5:25. "a time is coming—and is now here—when the dead will hear the voice of the Son of God, and those who hear will live." Their use: the resurrection was already under way when Jesus spoke, so it is spiritual, not bodily. My answer: John 5:25 does speak of a raising that was "now here", and the words just before explain it: the one who believes "has crossed over from death to life" (5:24). But Jesus goes straight on to a second raising: "a time is coming when all who are in the tombs will hear his voice and will come out" (5:28-29). There is no "and is now here" this time, and the dead are "in the tombs" (Greek en tois mnēmeiois). So John 5 has both: a raising now, by faith, and a raising from the tombs, still to come. I read Paul as tying death's defeat to that second kind; joining John 5 to 1 Corinthians 15 is my reading, because they are different books, and shared words alone do not join them. Paul writes, "when ... this mortal puts on immortality, then the saying that is written will happen, 'Death has been swallowed up in victory'" (1 Corinthians 15:54). His own "when ... then" joins the two in one sentence, and two things are one occasion when the text itself joins them that way (Rule 4). And "mortal" is the physical body in all six places Paul uses it (Rule 11). A raising by faith does not meet that.
- Genesis 2:17. "when you eat from it you will surely die" (Genesis 2:17). Their use: Adam's body did not die that day, so the death "in Adam" was covenantal. My answer: Genesis does not say his body died that day. The Hebrew "in the day" (beyom) is the phrase the same account uses for a making that Genesis tells over six days (Genesis 2:4); the NET gives "when" in both, and so I read it. God then quotes his command, "You must not eat from it" (Genesis 3:17; the same Hebrew words as 2:17), and names the sentence in the body's own words: "until you return to the ground ... for you are dust, and to dust you will return" (Genesis 3:19). "The entire lifetime of Adam was 930 years, and then he died" (Genesis 5:5; the Hebrew verb of 2:17, mut). That the death of 2:17 is this return to dust is my reading, and none of this shows the penalty was only bodily. Paul ties death to Adam: "death through sin" (Romans 5:12); "in Adam all die" (1 Corinthians 15:22). In the same chapter Paul uses the same Greek verb for "Christ died for our sins ... and that he was buried" (1 Corinthians 15:3-4); that the "die" of 15:22 is that kind of dying is my reading, from the run of the chapter.
- 1 Corinthians 10:11. "These things happened to them as examples and were written for our instruction, on whom the ends of the ages have come." Their use: Paul's readers stood at the end of the ages, so the end came in their lifetime, in AD 70. My answer: Paul's verb is katēntēken, "have come", already: the ends of the ages had reached his readers when he wrote. So the phrase itself does not point to AD 70. Hebrews speaks the same way of Christ's first coming: "now he has appeared once for all at the consummation of the ages to put away sin by his sacrifice" (Hebrews 9:26; Greek epi sunteleia tōn aiōnōn), and in the next breath, "he will appear a second time, not to bear sin but to bring salvation" (9:28). The Greek words differ (telē in 1 Corinthians, sunteleia in Hebrews), so I do not join the two verses as one event. I show only that the New Testament speaks of the end of the ages as already come with Christ's first coming, with his second appearing still ahead. Paul's own letter fits that: his readers "wait for the revelation of our Lord Jesus Christ" (1 Corinthians 1:7), and "then when Christ comes, those who belong to him" (15:23). In 1 Corinthians the ends of the ages had come, and the coming was still ahead.
- Daniel 12:7. "It is for a time, times, and half a time. Then, when the power of the one who shatters the holy people has been exhausted, all these things will be finished." Their use: the holy people's power was shattered in AD 70, and "all these things" include the raising of 12:2, so the resurrection was finished then. My answer: the Hebrew has no separate word for "the one who". Word for word it says "and when the shattering of the power of the holy people is finished, all these will be finished" (ukhekhallot nappets yad-am-qodesh tikhleynah khol-elleh; yad is "hand", used for power). So the verse ties "all these things" to "a time, times, and half a time" and to the end of a shattering of the holy people's power. It does not name the year or the one who shatters, and it does not list what "all these things" are; the question just before asks, "When will the end of these wondrous events occur?" (12:6). Whether that shattering is AD 70, and whether "all these things" include 12:2, the verse does not say: not shown either way. What 12:2 and 12:13 add: those who awake are "those who sleep in the dusty ground" (12:2; Hebrew admat-afar, "the ground of dust"), a physical cue like the ones at the start of this argument. And Daniel himself is told, "You will rest and then at the end of the days you will arise to receive what you have been allotted" (12:13; Hebrew tanuach, "you will rest", and ta'amod, "you will stand"). That his arising is out of the dust is my reading: the "dusty ground" is said of the "many" of 12:2, and 12:13, said to Daniel in a later answer (12:8-9), prints neither "dust" nor 12:2's "will awake" (Hebrew yakitsu). 12:13's own words carry the point: "You will rest" and "you will arise" are said to Daniel himself, so the raising he is promised is his own. No record shows that in AD 70 (point 5).
- Revelation 20:4-6. "They came to life and reigned with Christ for a thousand years. (The rest of the dead did not come to life until the thousand years were finished.) This is the first resurrection." Their use: the first resurrection is spiritual, or it came in AD 70. My answer: whatever the first resurrection is, Revelation itself ties things to the finishing of the thousand years, with time words of its own: "The rest of the dead did not come to life until the thousand years were finished" (20:5; Greek achri telesthē, "until ... are finished"), and "when the thousand years are finished, Satan will be released" (20:7; Greek hotan telesthē, "when ... are finished"). Later in the book come the sea, Death and Hades giving up their dead (20:13) and "death will not exist any more" (21:4). The Greek joins those with a plain "and", so placing them after the thousand years is my reading of the order the book gives them. So, on its own time words, the book ties at least two things to the finishing of the thousand years: it does not put the rest of the dead coming to life before the finishing ("until", 20:5), and it puts Satan's release no earlier than the finishing ("when", 20:7). Rule 9, in its own words: "A book cannot call 'soon' what it places after its own long wait" (it names Revelation 1:1 and 22:6 against 20:3 and 20:7). Its own wording needs the wait to be long. So it bears on Revelation's "what must happen very soon" (1:1; 22:6; Greek en tachei) only if the thousand years are a long wait, and whether they are is not fixed: a thousand years can mean a long span ("in your eyes a thousand years are like yesterday", Psalm 90:4; "a thousand years are like a single day", 2 Peter 3:8), but "can" does not fix the length in Revelation 20 (Rule 10). The rules stop there, and I do not claim the condition is met. And whether Revelation's "soon" says when or how is not decided either: the nearness rule says the word sources allow both. When the thousand years begin, no rule says (that is Rule 9's own limit), and I do not claim to know: not shown either way.

