Michlaude Discipleship Project

Not Yet Seen

Paul's own test

When some in Thessalonica were told "that the day of the Lord is already here" (2 Thessalonians 2:2; Greek enestēken, "has come" or "is present"), Paul did not just tell them to wait. He gave the church the defining elements of that day, so they could check the claim themselves:

  • What the claim is about. Paul makes his request "regarding the arrival of our Lord Jesus Christ and our being gathered to be with him" (2:1; Greek parousias, "coming", and episunagōgēs, "gathering together", with one "the", tēs, over both). The claim he answers is that "the day of the Lord is already here" (2:2). I read 2:1-2 this way: as Paul frames it, a claim that the day had come was a claim that the coming and the gathering had come. That is my reading; the words of 2:1 and 2:2 sit side by side, and no rule joins them by itself.
  • What must come first, in Paul's words:
  • "that day will not arrive until the rebellion comes and the man of lawlessness is revealed" (2:3; Greek apostasia, "falling away", and prōton, "first").
  • He "takes his seat in God's temple, displaying himself as God" (2:4). I read this as part of his being revealed (2:3).
  • What "holds him back" must be "taken out of the way" (2:6-7).
  • What comes with the day itself, in Paul's words:
  • Then "the Lord will destroy by the breath of his mouth and wipe out by the manifestation of his arrival" the lawless one (2:8; Greek tē epiphaneia tēs parousias, "by the appearing of his coming"). Paul's word for "arrival" here, parousia, is the word of 2:1, the arrival the claim is about: this destruction comes by the arrival itself, not before it.

Paul used these elements to settle the question: the day had not come, because what must come first had not yet happened. His words for what comes first are conditions ("that day will not arrive until", 2:3), and the test is as good today as it was then. On that reading, anyone who says the day came in AD 70 is saying that the coming of our Lord and our being gathered to him came then. To show it, they have to show that what Paul says must come first had come: the falling away, the man of lawlessness revealed and seated in God's temple, and the removal of what held him back. And they have to show that what Paul says comes with the day came with it: the lawless one's destruction by the appearing of Christ's coming. If one of them is not shown, the claim is not shown. Where the record does not show one, the answer is "not shown", never "did not happen". How each element is read is a reading, on both sides. That includes who the man of lawlessness is, what "God's temple" means here, and what holds him back.

One letter, one Lord, one coming. Paul wrote a letter, not chapters. The chapter number between 1:12 and 2:1 was added much later, so it is not Scripture's own division. From 1:3 to 2:12 is one continuous letter to the same readers about the same Lord Jesus and his coming.

He begins with a church that is suffering as he writes: "all the persecutions and afflictions you are enduring" (1:4); "the kingdom of God, for which in fact you are suffering" (1:5). The Greek verbs for the suffering are present tense (anechesthe, "you are bearing", 1:4; paschete, "you suffer", 1:5; thlibomenois, "being afflicted", 1:7). God will "give rest together with us when the Lord Jesus is revealed from heaven with his mighty angels" (1:7). In one sentence in the Greek (as the STEP data punctuates it; the NET ends a sentence at 1:7), this is "when he comes to be glorified among his saints and admired on that day" (1:10; Greek en tē hēmera ekeinē, "in that day"). Paul then prays for them: "we pray for you always ... that the name of our Lord Jesus may be glorified in you" (1:11-12).

Then he makes a request: "Now regarding the arrival of our Lord Jesus Christ and our being gathered to be with him, we ask you, brothers and sisters" (2:1). In Greek it opens Erōtōmen de humas, adelphoi, "Now we ask you, brothers", and goes on huper tēs parousias tou kuriou hēmōn Iēsou Christou, "concerning the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ". Those four opening words are the same ones Paul uses in his first letter when he turns to a new matter, respect for the church's leaders (1 Thessalonians 5:12). So 2:1 is a new request, and I say so plainly: the prayer turns into a request, and Paul calls them "brothers" for the first time since 1:3.

But I read the subject as carrying straight on. The Lord Jesus is the same (1:12; 2:1). The readers are the same, "you" (1:10-12; 2:1-2). The coming is the same: "when he comes" (1:10, elthē) and "the arrival", or coming (2:1, parousia). And I read the day as the same subject, from the run of the letter itself: "that day" (1:10) and then "the day of the Lord" (2:2). Paul put no chapter break between them. In my judgment, and not as a rule result, whoever says he changed to a different day carries the burden of showing it.

Point 8's test still applies here. Shared words alone do not join two passages (Rule 2), and that holds for two places in one letter as much as for two books. So I do not rest the same day on the shared word "day": "that day" (1:10) and "the day of the Lord" (2:2) are not even the same words. I rest it on the run of the letter: one letter and one run of thought, from the same writer to the same readers, and nothing marks a change of subject except the new request, and that request is about the same coming. That the day is the same is still my reading. The subject continues, Paul makes a new request about it, and the chapter break is not his. On that reading, the rest promised in 1:7-10 comes on the day that 2:2-8 says had not yet come, and Paul's own test applies to it. (In 2:3, the NET's "that day" is carried over from 2:2; the Greek of 2:3 has no word for "day".)

What is shown, and what is not:

  • Shown: the readers were suffering when Paul wrote, and their rest is tied to the Lord Jesus being "revealed from heaven" (1:7).
  • Not shown: whether those readers would be alive or dead when that day comes. The present-tense verbs say they were suffering when Paul wrote. They do not say who would be living when the Lord is revealed. The text does not settle it either way, so I do not draw that conclusion.

One thing the text does not say: 2:2 says some were told the day had already come. It does not say they feared they had missed being caught up (the "rapture"). That idea is not in the text.