The Bible Reading OS
Chapter 9. Who saw it?
If you tell me, "I saw it," I may believe you. If five people tell me, I may believe it more. But then I should ask three plain questions. What did they see? What did they not see? And what can a witness speak to?
A witness is a person who says what he saw or heard. A record is a written account. Scripture has both. It names witnesses, and it keeps records. This chapter asks how Scripture treats the people who saw things happen.
I need one more word. Scripture's own voice means the writer of a book of the Bible speaking in his own words. It is not a person he quotes. When a Gospel writer tells you what happened, that is Scripture's own voice. When a man in his story says something, that is a man's voice inside the story. The two are not the same. Keep them apart, and many knots come loose.
There are five tests in this chapter. They come in a line. The first two are about counting witnesses. The next two are about what kind of witness a person is. The last one is about the edge of what a witness can say.
Keep one caution in view: these tests are for reading, not for the Bible itself, and no rule can make a witness see more than he saw.
The two-or-three witnesses rule
Status: Passed. Basis: observed.
The rule in one sentence
This rule is about a charge. A charge is a claim that a person did wrong.
In a charge against a person, two or three agreeing witnesses are needed.
In everyday words: one voice is not enough to charge a person. Two or three voices that agree are. The rule is for charges. Keep that word in mind. It matters in a moment.
Where Scripture does it
This rule is observed. Observed means that Scripture itself reads this way, and we can point to the verse. Scripture says it in its own words in Deuteronomy 19:15.
This is a law. It tells a people how to handle a charge. Nothing in the verse tells you how to handle a report of an event. We will come to events in a moment. They have their own rule.
An example, step by step
The words. Here is the verse. "A single witness may not testify against another person for any trespass or sin that he commits. A matter may be legally established only on the testimony of two or three witnesses." (Deuteronomy 19:15 NET).
What the rule gives. In a charge against a person, two or three agreeing witnesses are needed.
Shown. For a charge of trespass or sin, one witness is not enough. The verse says it twice: first what may not be done, then what must be done. The words are plain.
Not shown. Any use for events in history. The verse speaks of a charge against a person. It does not say that every event needs two witnesses before we may say it happened. A missing witness does not show that a claim is false.
What it does not decide
The rule is for charges. It is not applied to events in history.
Here is why this matters. You may hear someone say, "The Bible says only two witnesses count." Ask one thing. Count for what? If it is a charge against a person, the verse says so. If it is whether an event happened, the verse has not said so. Do not carry a rule from one use to another.
A missing witness does not show a claim is false. It does not show a claim is true. It leaves the claim where it was.
Now a habit for the thread. Say three people repeat one claim. Ask a plain question. Did each of them see it, or did all three hear it from one source? A witness is a person who saw or heard. A voice that repeats is not a witness. If three saw, you have three. If one saw and two repeated, you have one. The verse says "witnesses". So count the ones who saw.

