Michlaude Discipleship Project

Chapter 9. Who saw it?

The two-or-three witnesses rule for events

Status: Passed, limited. Basis: observed, with one sentence that is a choice I made.

The rule in one sentence

The first rule had a limit. It is not applied to events. But later I opened a small door in that limit. This rule is the opened part. It speaks of records outside Scripture. An outside record is a written account that is not in the Bible. Here is its plain sentence.

Agreeing witnesses may also count toward an outside record that an event in history happened, and toward the time the record states for it, only through the outside-record rule; the count is a help, never a requirement, and one witness who saw can be enough (John 19:35).

That is long, so let me say it in everyday words. Agreeing witnesses can help when we weigh an outside record. But this rule never works alone. It works only through the outside-record rule. That rule is taught in chapter 10. For now you need only its heart: a record from outside the Bible is written down as an outside record, never as Scripture. The count of witnesses is a help. It is never a requirement. And one person who saw can be enough.

Where Scripture does it

Scripture uses witnesses for events. It uses them in more than one place. In this chapter I show you two pictures of that. Chapter 12 shows one more, from the book of Ruth, and tells where readers read the count two ways.

I must tell you what is mine here. The sentence about the count is my own choice. Neither Scripture's usage nor a contradiction decides it. So I chose it, and I say so. When the rule was tried, careful readers read the count sentence two ways. That split is mine to settle, and I have not settled it. No test has yet looked at this rule by itself.

And hear this. The two pictures in this chapter are from inside Scripture. The rule itself is not for those. It is for records outside Scripture. So the pictures only show you that Scripture treats witnesses and records this way. They do not run the rule.

An example, step by step

Jeremiah buys a field. "So I bought the field at Anathoth from my cousin Hanamel." (Jeremiah 32:9 NET). Then he tells how the purchase was made firm.

The words.

I signed the deed of purchase, sealed it, and had some men serve as witnesses to the purchase. I weighed out the silver for him on a scale. There were two copies of the deed of purchase. One was sealed and contained the order of transfer and the conditions of purchase. The other was left unsealed. I took both copies of the deed of purchase and gave them to Baruch son of Neriah, the son of Mahseiah. I gave them to him in the presence of my cousin Hanamel, the witnesses who had signed the deed of purchase, and all the Judeans who were housed in the courtyard of the guardhouse. (Jeremiah 32:10-12 NET)

What the rule gives. Agreeing witnesses may count toward a record that an event happened. The count is a help, never a requirement.

Shown. Scripture itself uses witnesses and a written record to stand behind an event. The event is a purchase. There are men who serve as witnesses. There are two copies of the deed. There are people present when the deed is handed over. The words give no number of witnesses, only "some men", so the example does not turn on a count.

Not shown. That two or three are required for events. The verses do not say so. And not shown that falling short of some count would make an event "not shown". The rule says the count is a help, not a bar.

Now one more verse. The rule points to John 19:35. "And the person who saw it has testified (and his testimony is true, and he knows that he is telling the truth), so that you also may believe." Here one person is named. He saw it. He testified. The verse gives no count. That is why the rule says one witness who saw can be enough. I want to be careful. This verse is a pointer, not a full answer. It does not show that one witness is enough for every event. It shows that Scripture's own voice leans on one person who saw.

What it does not decide

The opened part works only through the outside-record rule. If that rule is not selected, this one has no work to do.

It does not set a number. It does not say that two or three are needed for an event. It does not say that a smaller count makes an event "not shown".

The count sentence is my own choice, and I say so again. Careful readers read it two ways.