Chapter 9. Who saw it?
The bodily-act witnesses rule
Status: Passed. Basis: observed.
The rule in one sentence
When Scripture says God did a bodily act in history, it says who saw it (not always the public).
In everyday words: if Scripture says God did something in the body, in history, it also says who saw it. It tells us who. It does not always say everyone.
Where Scripture does it
I count this rule as observed. The place I show you is in Acts, and I must label it with care. The words are Peter's. Luke reports them. Peter starts speaking at Acts 10:34, and the words below come a few verses later.
By this chapter's own line, that is a man's voice inside the story, not Scripture's own voice. Luke does not correct Peter's words. Still, a speech inside a story is not the same as the writer speaking. So take this as a picture of the rule, given in a speech that Luke reports. It is not Scripture's own voice saying it.
The rule does not say exactly what a bodily act is. That is a gap. In some verses no one is named as doing the act, and the rule does not say whether those count. So I chose a plain case. "God raised him up" is plainly an act done to a body. My example tests the rule, not its gap.
An example, step by step
The words.
but God raised him up on the third day and caused him to be seen, not by all the people, but by us, the witnesses God had already chosen, who ate and drank with him after he rose from the dead. (Acts 10:40-41 NET)
The Greek word behind "witnesses" is martusin. A Greek word list gives it as "witness".
What the rule gives. When Scripture says God did a bodily act in history, it says who saw it.
Shown. In Peter's words, God's act is stated: he raised him up. And the words say who saw him: the witnesses God had already chosen, who ate and drank with him. So the words do two things. They say who saw. And they say who did not: "not by all the people". Both are in the words.
Not shown. That the public saw it. The words say "not by all the people", so the rule does not say the public saw. The rule's limit says the number varies and the answer is not always the public. And there is a third line: the witnesses are never the only thing.
The rule does not explain that third line. So here is how I read it, and it is only my reading. In Acts 10:41 God is the one who chose the witnesses. God is the one who raised him. God is the one who caused him to be seen. So the seeing sits inside what God did. The witnesses are not the whole story.
What it does not decide
The rule does not say the public saw. These words themselves say "not by all the people".
It does not give a number. The number varies from place to place.
It does not say what a bodily act is in every case. Where no one is named as doing an act, it does not say.
It does not say that a witness is all you need. It does not say what any witness saw, beyond what the passage says. And it does not settle whether a speech inside a story, like Peter's, counts as Scripture saying it. I note that so you can weigh the example.

