Michlaude Discipleship Project

The Bible Reading OS

Chapter 10. What a record shows, and what it does not

Someone says, "That prophecy has been fulfilled." Or someone says, "That already happened." You hear it in a thread, a video, a message. What do you need to see before you say yes?

I will give you the plain answer first. You need to see a record. And you need to know what the record shows. If a record is there, you may say so. If a record is not there, you may not say "false". You may say "not shown".

Let me define two words. A fulfilment is when what was said comes to be. A claimed fulfilment is when someone says it has. A record is a written account.

Four tests are in this chapter. The record-burden rule says what a claimed fulfilment needs. The outside-record rule says how to treat a record that is not in the Bible. The unnarrated-event rule says what to write when someone claims an act that Scripture does not tell. The already-claims rule says how Scripture answers "it has already come".

These questions run hot, so the caution comes first. The tests are for reading, not for the Bible itself, and none can make a prophecy fulfilled or unfulfilled.

Some of these tests touch things people argue about. When they do, I treat every reading alike. I use the same three words for each one: shown, not shown, shown against. In this chapter more than any other, hold on to what "not shown" means. A missing record is not a "no". It is only a silence.

The record-burden rule

Status: Passed, limited. Basis: a choice I made. It says who must bring the proof.

The rule in one sentence

A burden is who has to bring something. This rule says who.

A claimed fulfilment by a dated event needs a record; without one the record is not shown.

In everyday words: if you say a saying with a date in it was met, then you bring the record. If you bring none, I do not say your claim is false. I say the record is not shown.

The rule's full wording says it in a slightly different way, and you should know it. It says the dated part of a claim needs a record. Then it says that without an observed case from Scripture, a record is not shown to meet it. As I read it, the full wording asks for a record of a kind Scripture itself shows. The sentence above says only "a record". The two are close, but they are not the same, and I will not blur them.

Where Scripture does it

This is a burden rule. It is not a claim about what happened. It only says who must bring what. That is a working agreement, a choice I made. So I do not call it observed, and I do not call it forced.

But Scripture does give us an observed case of the thing the rule asks for. It is a case where a dated saying is met, and a record tells it. We will see it in a moment.

An example, step by step

Hananiah the prophet speaks in the temple, and he says God will break the yoke of Babylon. He gives a date. "Before two years are over, I will bring back to this place everything that King Nebuchadnezzar of Babylon took from it and carried away to Babylon." (Jeremiah 28:3 NET). I give this as context only. The verses I use do not tell what happened to that saying. I do not go past the verses.

Now Jeremiah speaks to Hananiah.

The words. "So the Lord says, ‘I will most assuredly remove you from the face of the earth. You will die this very year because you have counseled rebellion against the Lord.’" (Jeremiah 28:16 NET). Then the narrator writes this. "In the seventh month of that very same year the prophet Hananiah died." (Jeremiah 28:17 NET).

The Hebrew behind "this very year" is hashanah, and behind "that very same year" is bashanah hahi. A Hebrew word list gives "year" and "that", and the NET adds "very" in English. The dating is plain in both.

What the rule gives. A claimed fulfilment by a dated event needs a record. Without one, the record is not shown.

Shown. There is a dated saying: "You will die this very year". There is a record that meets it, in the narrator's own voice. So here is a dated saying, and a record that meets it. Scripture supplies this case itself, and it is the kind of observed case the full wording speaks of.

Not shown. That no other kind of record could count. That stronger form of the rule fails, so I do not use it. Also not shown: what counts as dated words in every case. The rule speaks of dated words, but it never says exactly what counts as them. In this example the dating is plain. In other cases it may not be. Where two readings would give two answers, the rule asks me to tell you how I read it, and to give both.

What it does not decide

The rule does not say a record exists. It says who must bring one.

It does not say that only a record like the one in Jeremiah 28 counts. That stronger form fails.

It does not say exactly what counts as dated words. That is a known gap, and readers' answers turn on it. I say so every time.

And it asks the same of everyone. If a claim helps a reading you love, the rule asks for the record. If a claim hurts a reading you love, the rule asks for the record. The rule does not pick sides. It picks the record.