Michlaude Discipleship Project

Chapter 10. What a record shows, and what it does not

The outside-record rule

Status: Passed, limited. Basis: both observed and forced, with some parts that are a choice I made.

The rule in one sentence

An outside record is a written account that is not in the Bible. Here is the rule for it.

Where the only record of an event lies outside Scripture, ask three things apart (did it happen; does it match what was predicted; is it inside the time the prediction fixes); write the record as "outside record: [source]", never as Scripture; a missing record never gives "did not happen" and never gives "will happen".

In everyday words: say a writer outside the Bible tells of an event. Ask three things. Did it happen? Does it match what was said ahead of time? Is it inside the time that saying fixes? Keep the three apart. A yes to the first is not a yes to the second. Write the record as an outside record, with its source. Never write it as if it were Scripture. And if there is no record, do not say "it did not happen". Do not say "it will happen" either.

Where Scripture does it

Most of this rule is observed in Scripture. I show you one part of it below.

One part is forced. Forced means that if we denied it, two Bible texts would contradict each other. The part is this: a missing record never gives "did not happen". The verses behind it are John 20:30 and John 21:25. Here is my own plain way to say why. Say a missing record meant "did not happen". Then John 20:30 would contradict itself. It says Jesus did many signs that are not recorded in this book. The signs happened, but they were not written. So "not written" cannot mean "did not happen". The same goes for John 21:25, which you will meet again below.

Some parts are definitions. Some are my own choice, and I say so. The two-or-three count in this rule is my own choice, and it is a help, never a requirement. One more part was carried over from a wording that is not in the tests I use. This rule has been tried only by AI readers.

An example, step by step

The words.

Now Jesus performed many other miraculous signs in the presence of the disciples, which are not recorded in this book. But these are recorded so that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God, and that by believing you may have life in his name. (John 20:30-31 NET)

What the rule gives. A missing record never gives "did not happen".

Shown. John says that many signs happened and that they are not recorded in this book. So a missing record in this book never gives "did not happen". That is shown by his own words.

Notice what John does next: he says why he wrote what he wrote. "But these are recorded so that you may believe". He does not say he wrote everything.

Not shown. What those other signs were, whether any outside record of them exists, and what such a record would show if it did.

One more care. This rule is for records outside the Bible, and John 20:30 is inside it. So here the rule is only showing you its forced part. When the Bible itself tells an event, this rule has nothing to write.

What it does not decide

The rule does not say whether an outside record meets the record-burden rule. That is a second question. You ask it after.

It does not say an outside record is true. It does not say it is false. It only says how to write it down, and what the three questions are.

Where Scripture tells the event itself, this rule is outside its limit. It has nothing to write.

Some parts are my own choice. The count of two or three witnesses is one of them. Careful readers read the count two ways. I have not settled that.

And the rule works the same for a record that seems to help your view and a record that seems to hurt it.