Chapter 10. What a record shows, and what it does not
The unnarrated-event rule
Status: Passed, limited. Basis: observed in one part, a choice I made in others. The rest is built on the two rules it limits.
The rule in one sentence
Here is the case in plain words. Someone claims an act happened at a named time, and Scripture does not tell that act. This rule says what to do.
A claim that an act happened at a named time Scripture does not narrate does not trigger the bodily-act witnesses rule; the record-burden rule is used only inside its own stated input; an unmet burden is "not shown to meet the burden", never "it did not happen". For a claim that the resurrection has already happened, one may write that Scripture's own voice presents it as future when it was written and no narrator records it happening (with the verses logged).
In everyday words, for the first part: the rule that asks "who saw it?" is not set off here. The record-burden rule is used only where it applies. And if the burden is not met, the answer is "not shown to meet the burden". It is never "it did not happen".
The last sentence is about one claim only: that the resurrection has already happened. I treat that sentence in chapter 12. I do not use it here.
Where Scripture does it
This rule is built on the two rules it limits. It leans on them. Most of it is not a new observation of its own. The special sentence about the resurrection is observed: it rests on verses in the letters (1 Corinthians 15:52, 1 Thessalonians 4:16 and 2 Timothy 2:18). But the exact words the rule writes are my own choice, and I say so.
Here is the plain Scripture behind the main part. Scripture itself says that Jesus did many things it does not tell. So an act that Scripture does not tell is not, for that reason alone, an act that did not happen.
An example, step by step
Here is a made-up claim. I make it up on purpose, so that it points at no one. A post says that Jesus healed a man in a village by the lake, on a feast day in a named year. No book of Scripture tells that deed.
The words.
There are many other things that Jesus did. If every one of them were written down, I suppose the whole world would not have room for the books that would be written. (John 21:25 NET)
What the rule gives. The rule that asks "who saw it?" is not set off. Scripture has not said that God did that bodily act, so it has not set the question. The record-burden rule runs only inside its own input. If the burden is not met, the answer is "not shown to meet the burden".
Shown. Scripture itself says that there are many other things that Jesus did. So an act that Scripture does not tell is not shown to be an act that did not happen. And no one may say, "No witnesses are named, so it did not happen." The rule that names witnesses has not been set off.
Not shown. That the claimed act happened, or that it did not. The claim sits in the middle, and the middle is a resting place.
So how does a reader ever say no to a wild claim? Not with this rule. This rule only keeps you from saying "it did not happen" when the page is silent. If the claim says something the verses speak against, other rules and the verses themselves can show that. A silent page cannot.
What it does not decide
The rule leans on the record-burden rule, and that rule never says exactly what counts as dated words. That is a known gap.
The special sentence about the resurrection is worded by my choice, and I ruled it for that one claim only. Readers differed on whether the verses must also show its second part, that no narrator records it happening. Chapter 12 shows that.
The rule does not say the claimed act happened. It does not say it did not. It does not give a date to anything.
And it has been tried only by AI readers.

