Michlaude Discipleship Project

The Bible Reading OS

Appendix B. A page you can use before you comment

Twelve questions. Keep them near your thumb.

They grow out of the eight habits in chapter 11. Each question names the habit it comes from. Six are extra, from chapters 2 and 14. Habits six and seven, say the limit and a label is never a reason, have no question of their own here. They are for the moment you use a rule, so carry them then.

Use them on a video, a thread, a post, or your own words. Take your time. You are not in a race. If you can answer each one, you may post. If you cannot, wait. You may leave it for the morning.

A "no" is not a verdict on you. It is a place to look. Look, and then ask again.

  1. What does the verse say? Read it again. Say it in your own words. If you cannot, stop here. From habit one: start with the words.
  2. What is around it? Read the verses before it and the verses after it. A verse alone can say more than it says, or less. Extra, from chapter 2: how much we read around the verse.
  3. Who is speaking? Is it Scripture's own voice, or a person in the story? A person in the story may be right. He may be wrong. Know which one you hear. Extra, from chapter 2: who is speaking.
  4. Does one word carry more than one sense? If it does, which sense does this verse give? The verse has to tell you. Do not choose first and read after. Extra, from chapter 2: one word, more than one sense.
  5. Do the English and the original words differ? Where the wording matters, look at the Hebrew or the Greek behind the English. If the two differ, say both. Extra, from chapter 2: the words themselves.
  6. Was a step added? List the steps. Which ones do the words show? Which ones did someone put in? A step does not follow just because it sounds smooth. Extra, from chapter 2: a step added without being shown.
  7. Which group is it in? Shown, not shown, or shown against. Put the claim in one group. Use the words on the page. From habit three: sort into three groups.
  8. If it is not shown, can I rest there? The words have not settled it. That does not make it false, and it does not mean it did not happen. From habit four: rest in "not shown".
  9. Have I quoted the exact words I am answering? Quote them first. Then answer them. If I answer a thing the person did not say, I have not answered. From habit two: quote the exact words before you answer them.
  10. Have I checked every quote? Check each quote against a Bible. Check each "shown". If an AI helped, check it twice. A smooth answer is not a checked answer. From habit eight: check, and be willing to be checked.
  11. Am I saying why they said it? Do not. I can see what was said. I cannot see the heart. And would I hold myself to the same test? The tests are for me too. From habit five: judge the words, not the heart. Its last two lines are habit eight.
  12. Is this mine to post? Will it help someone stay, or will it add to the noise? If you are not sure, do not post. Take the person aside. Or close the thread. Extra, from chapter 14: is this mine to post?

Jesus says, "Remain in me, and I will remain in you" (John 15:4 NET). That is the aim. The questions only clear the way.