Chapter 11. The habits under every rule
Habit two: quote the exact words before you answer them
Go back to John 21. Peter asks Jesus about the other disciple. Jesus answers with a question. Then a saying goes around. Here is how the writer deals with it.
So the saying circulated among the brothers and sisters that this disciple was not going to die. But Jesus did not say to him that he was not going to die, but rather, “If I want him to live until I come back, what concern is that of yours?” (John 21:23 NET)
Look at what the writer does not do. He does not argue with the saying. He does not call anyone names. He puts the saying beside the exact words of Jesus. Then you can see the gap.
That is the habit. Before you answer a claim, write down the exact sentence you are answering. Put it in quotes. If you cannot quote it, you may be answering a different sentence.
Remember the room in chapter 1. You asked a plain question. The answer you got was about a different question. No one had quoted yours. No one had answered it.
Do the same with every verse. Copy it from a Bible. Do not trust your memory. Do not trust a smooth voice. If the quote is wrong, the answer is built on sand.
Habit three: sort into three groups
When you ask what the words do for a claim, put the claim in one of three places.
Shown. The words on the page, read with the tests, give it.
Not shown. The words on the page do not settle it either way.
Shown against. The words on the page, read with the tests, give the opposite.
Use the three groups when you are asking what the words show. They are a way to sort. They are not a way to score points.
Habit four: rest in "not shown"
This one is hard, so I come back to it.
Silence in the words does not make a claim false. It does not mean the thing did not happen. The page has only left it open.
If the words are silent, you have two ways to go wrong. You can fill the silence with a yes. Or you can fill it with a no. Both are a step the words did not give.
No test in this book rests on silence. Where the verse says nothing, the answer is "not shown". Rest there.
It is a resting place. It is not a loss. You can say "I do not know yet", and still be standing on solid ground.

