Michlaude Discipleship Project

Chapter 3. The noise, and what it costs

A habit: three groups

Here is one habit I will give you now. It is small. It is the habit of sorting what you hear into three groups.

Shown. The words on the page, read with the tests, give it.

Not shown. The words on the page do not settle it either way.

Shown against. The words on the page, read with the tests, give the opposite.

Try it on John 21. Take three claims about it. They are plain, and they are low in stakes.

Claim one: that Jesus asked a question that began with If. Look at John 21:22. Jesus' answer begins "If I want him to live until I come back". The claim is shown.

Claim two: that Jesus said that disciple would not die. Look at the next verse: "Jesus did not say to him that he was not going to die" (John 21:23 NET). The words say Jesus did not say it. The claim is shown against.

Claim three: that this disciple lived until Jesus came back. Look at the words again. Jesus asks, "If I want him to live until I come back". The If names a condition. These verses do not say whether it was met. They do not say it was. They do not say it was not. The claim is not shown.

Now the opposite of claim three: that this disciple died before Jesus came back. These verses do not say that either. It is also not shown.

I treat the two alike. Both go in the same group. Neither is shown. Neither is shown against.

Here is the sentence I want you to keep. Not shown is not false. It only means the words on the page have not settled it.

A claim in this group may be true. It may be false. The page is silent on it. That is all the group says. It does not say the claim did not happen. It does not say the person who made it is wrong. It says only that the words have not settled it.

Many of us feel that a gap must be filled. A thread rewards the one who fills it fast. But not shown is a resting place, not a loss. A traveler who rests has not failed. He can keep the question, and come back to it with more light.

Not shown is hard to say out loud. In a thread it can sound like weakness. It is not. It is honest. The words do not say. That is a full sentence, and it is a true one.

Here is how it looks in a thread. Say someone posts a line that reads: John 21 says that disciple would not die. You do not need to answer yet. You do three small things.

First, find the words. Open John 21 and read verses 22 and 23.

Second, ask what step was made. Did the words say it, or did someone say it for them?

Third, sort the claim. Here it is shown against, because the verse says Jesus did not say it.

That took a minute. It took no fight. And you can do it in quiet.

Two more things about the three groups.

They sort what the words show. They do not sort people. I will never use them to say that a person is false or good or bad.

And they apply to everyone. The calm voice in the video. The one who lectured you. The one who left you with doubts. You. Me. If I put a claim in the wrong group in this book, you should be able to catch me.