Chapter 10. What a record shows, and what it does not
The already-claims rule
Status: Passed. Basis: observed.
The rule in one sentence
Scripture answers "it has already come" by naming what must come with it and noting it has not come.
In everyday words: someone says the awaited event has already come. Scripture does not argue the date. It names what must come with the event. And it says that thing has not come.
Where Scripture does it
This rule is observed. Its own named example is in the second letter to the Thessalonians (2 Thessalonians 2:2-3). There, a message said that the day of the Lord was already here. The letter names what must come first. Chapter 12 looks at that example, because it names what comes first, and the rule says what comes with. That is a place where careful readers can differ.
So for this chapter I use a different place, in Luke, because it fits the rule's word "with" better. I must be honest that it does not fit the rule exactly. In Luke the claim is not "it has already come". The claim is "Look, here he is!" It fits the shape of the rule, not the exact words. And, as you will see, it shows only the first half of what the rule gives. Weigh it yourself.
An example, step by step
The words.
Then people will say to you, ‘Look, there he is!’ or ‘Look, here he is!’ Do not go out or chase after them. For just like the lightning flashes and lights up the sky from one side to the other, so will the Son of Man be in his day. (Luke 17:23-24 NET)
One of the eight printed Greek editions in the word list leaves out "in his day". My example does not lean on those words.
What the rule gives. Two things. Scripture answers the claim by naming what must come with the event. And it notes that the event has not come.
Shown. The first half. The claim is "Look, there he is!" or "Look, here he is!" The answer names what comes with the event, which is like lightning that lights up the sky from one side to the other. So a claim that points to one place, "here" or "there", is answered by what the event looks like.
Not shown. The second half. These words do not say that the event has not come. Jesus says, "Do not go out or chase after them." That is not the same as saying it has not come. So this example shows the rule's first half only. Also not shown: any date, when "his day" is, what the lightning is a picture of, or whether it is a picture at all. The rule cannot date anything.
A reader may hold that the coming is still ahead. Another reader may hold that it came in an earlier event. This rule gives the same limit to both. The verses name what comes with it, but they do not name a year. I use the same three words for both readers: shown, not shown, shown against. And note this. It is an answer given ahead of time. Jesus says the claims will come.
What it does not decide
The rule cannot date anything. If you use it to say when, you have used it past its limit.
It does not say that a given claim today is right. It does not say that it is wrong. It says what Scripture does when a claim like this is made. It names what comes with the event.
It does not tell you what "his day" means. It does not tell you what the lightning means.
Here is a habit to take from it. When someone says "it has come" or "here he is", do not start with the date. Start with the words. What does the verse say comes with it? Say what the verse shows, and say what it does not. If you cannot tell, rest in "not shown". That is not a failure. It is a quiet place to stand.

