Michlaude Discipleship Project

Chapter 9. Who saw it?

The witness-kinds rule

Status: Passed, limited. Basis: observed in most parts, with parts that are a choice I made.

The rule in one sentence

For each record, write who the witness is, what he witnessed, and how; a writer who did not himself see or hear is giving a report, and its weight follows the chain he names back to someone who did.

In everyday words: do not just say "a witness says". Ask three things. Who is he? What did he see or hear? And how does he know? If a writer did not see or hear it himself, he is giving a report. A report is a real thing. It is not thrown out. But its weight follows the chain he names. If he names a chain back to someone who saw, the report is as strong as that chain.

Where Scripture does it

Most of this rule is observed. Scripture points to the people who saw, and it points to the way each one knew.

Its last line is different. It was carried over from a wording that is not in the tests I use, and it was not tested on its own. That line says no kind of witness decides which event a prophecy named. Because it was carried and not tested, I treat it as a limit, not as a finding.

I use three kinds. The first kind is the people Scripture shows with Jesus and chosen as his witnesses. Jesus says to them, "You are witnesses of these things." (Luke 24:48 NET). Acts 10:41 names them, as you saw.

The second kind is Paul. Paul says the risen Jesus appeared to him. "he appeared to me also" (1 Corinthians 15:8 NET). He also says where the gospel he preached came from. "I received it by a revelation of Jesus Christ." (Galatians 1:12 NET). I write Paul's witness in the words of the verse the finding rests on. I write "revelation" only where the verse itself says so.

The third kind is every other writer. He is a witness only of what he himself saw or heard. Beyond that, he gives a report.

Now hear this. The three kinds are a frame, and the frame is my own choice, since no verse in Scripture sorts witnesses into three kinds. I made the frame to help us look. If it does not help, put it down.

An example, step by step

Here is how Luke begins his Gospel.

The words.

Now many have undertaken to compile an account of the things that have been fulfilled among us, like the accounts passed on to us by those who were eyewitnesses and servants of the word from the beginning. So it seemed good to me as well, because I have followed all things carefully from the beginning, to write an orderly account for you, most excellent Theophilus, so that you may know for certain the things you were taught. (Luke 1:1-4 NET)

The Greek behind "eyewitnesses" is autoptai. The word list gives "eyewitness". The Greek behind "followed" is parēkolouthēkoti. The list gives "having been acquainted", from the word "to follow". The English and the Greek are near each other. I tell you both.

What the rule gives. Write the witness, what he witnessed, and how. A writer who did not see it is giving a report. Its weight follows the chain he names.

Shown. Luke names a chain: there are eyewitnesses, there are those who passed on accounts, and there is Luke himself. He writes as one who followed the chain. He does not write as an eyewitness. By the rule, his account is a report, with the chain named. And he says why he writes. He writes "so that you may know for certain the things you were taught". So the account is offered to be used.

Not shown. What each eyewitness saw, or which event a prophecy named. No kind of witness decides that. And the account is not thrown out because Luke was not an eyewitness. The rule says a report is not a witness, and it is not thrown out.

What it does not decide

The three kinds are a frame, and the frame is my own choice.

The rule does not sort people a record only reports, who wrote nothing. It does not decide which event a prophecy named. That last line was carried over, not tested, so it stands here as a limit. A witness of one thing may not be a witness of another. A letter writer counts as Scripture's own voice, unless he says otherwise in the passage.

And this rule has been tried only by AI readers, so weigh it with that in mind.