Michlaude Discipleship Project

Chapter 12. Where the rules split, ran out, or failed

Rules that failed

A rule that fails is not a shame. It is a result. Here are some of them.

The reused-word rule. This one sounded good. Here it is.

When an answer reuses a word from the question, it is about what the question asked.

Test it on Luke 10. An expert in the law asks Jesus a question.

But the expert, wanting to justify himself, said to Jesus, “And who is my neighbor?” (Luke 10:29 NET)

At the end of the story, Jesus asks him a question.

Which of these three do you think became a neighbor to the man who fell into the hands of the robbers?” (Luke 10:36 NET)

The word neighbor is in the question and in Jesus' answer. By the rule as I have given it here, Jesus' last question is about what the man asked. But the verses show another question, and my notes say this rule conflicts with the same-words rule, which chapter 5 teaches. The rule failed.

Here is my plain reading of why. It is my own reading. My notes give only the verses and the conflict. The man asks who counts as his neighbor. Jesus' last question uses the same word, but asks something else. It asks which of the three acted as a neighbor to the man in the road. Same word. Different question. A reused word did not mean the answer was about what was asked.

I must be exact about one more fact. The full rule had a short qualifier: unless the text marks a shift. When the rule was written into a reader's instructions, a short form went in without those words. That was a mistake in the instructions, and my long paper says so. It matters here. Luke 10:36 does mark a shift. So the full rule survives this one verse. It still failed, because it conflicts with the same-words rule. The verse alone would not have sunk it.

The rule was marked Failed. I dropped it, and it is nowhere in this book as a rule. I tell you about it because a rule that sounds right can still fail on one verse. That is why we test.

The near-word-means-lifetime rule. This rule said that a near word places an event within the hearers' lifetime. It failed on Haggai 2:6 with Hebrews 12:26. Haggai says, "In just a little while I will once again shake the sky and the earth, the sea and the dry ground" (Haggai 2:6 NET). A later writer takes up the promise and says "now he has promised" (Hebrews 12:26 NET). On this pair, the near words alone did not place the event in the first hearers' lifetime. I say nothing here about what the shaking is.

One sentence of another rule. An earlier rule had two sentences. The first said a near word by itself gives no length, and it passed. The second said only a stated span or a sign sets a length, and it failed. Scripture has other ways to give a length. A number. A date. Or words like these.

Indeed in your days, O rebellious house, I will speak the word and accomplish it, declares the Sovereign Lord. (Ezekiel 12:25 NET)

Seven ideas dropped. Seven more ideas were tried early and dropped. Here they are, in plain words.

  • That "all these things" covers the events just before it (Matthew 24:33). No usage fixes how far it reaches.
  • That "you" always means the people addressed (Deuteronomy 30:1; Matthew 28:20).
  • That near words have a ceiling of about 170 years. It rested on shared wording, and 2 Peter 3:8 cuts against any ceiling.
  • That the Greek word mellō, "to be about to", always means soon. In Luke 7:2 the sense is near. In Acts 24:15 it is not.
  • That the words "before or after" mean once, literally. The test pair was 2 Kings 18:5 and 2 Kings 23:25. Both use those words of a king.
  • A list of marks to pick out certain awaited events. It was argued from silence.
  • That different wording means different events.