Michlaude Discipleship Project

Chapter 4. Where the rules come from, and how they were tried

When to stop

A test with no stopping point never ends. Each fix gives the next reader something new to split on. A split is when two careful readers get two different answers from the same words. A split is useful, because it finds where the words are not tight. But I needed a place to stop, so I wrote down two stopping rules. The first is for a rule's wording. I change a wording only when a reader shows one of three things from the text. It gives a wrong label. It gives two different labels on one passage. Or it says the text does not tell where the text does tell. Any other split I write beside the rule as a limit. I wrote that rule down before I read the next result. The second is for the long argument. I stop testing it after two rounds in a row with no new confirmed error. That is a problem I checked and found true against the NET, the Greek and Hebrew word list, or the source the argument cites.

What the labels mean

Each rule in this book wears one of two status labels.

Passed. The rule held when it was tried.

Passed, limited. The rule held only in a narrower form, and the rule states that form.

There are 25 rules in this book. Ten are Passed. Fifteen are Passed, limited. A rule can be limited for plain reasons. It may be a working agreement: a default, a burden rule, or a rule that holds only on a condition. It may be weak. Part of it may be a choice I made. It may have been tested only by AI readers. It may hand one hard question to a wording that is still only proposed. Or it may not have been tested again since I ruled on it.

Each rule says what it cannot decide. That limit goes with the rule every time it is used.

Seven of the rules in this book came out of the tests themselves. They began as new wordings. Fresh readers tried them more than once, with fixes in between. Four other wordings were tried beside them in the same rounds, and those four did not pass. They stay proposed, with their open breaks listed. Many more wordings are only proposed. I leave them all out of this book on purpose, and the book never uses them as support.

Now hear a hard rule of my own. A status is a label on a rule. It is never the reason for a conclusion. I will not tell you a reading holds because its rule is Passed. If the verse and the rule do not show it, the label does not either.

A human sets every status. Each one has my own words behind it in my notes. For the nearness-length rule, my word was limited.