Michlaude Discipleship Project

Appendix C. Using the tests with an AI chatbot

Step five: check it yourself

Here is your part. The AI does not do this for you. The same checks apply to my own work.

  1. Check every quote. Put each one beside your own Bible. Check the words, not just the sense.
  2. Check every step that says shown. Ask where the words are. If you cannot point to the words, the step was added.
  3. Check that no rule was used outside its limit. Each rule states what it cannot decide. The answer should state it too.
  4. Check that nothing only proposed was used as support. A proposed wording is never support.
  5. Check that the answer did not say why a person did a thing. The rules give no verdicts on motive. Neither should you.

Do one more thing. Notice whether the answer sounds smooth and sure. If it does, slow down. A smooth answer is not a checked answer. A machine's own checks can miss things, as chapter 12 shows. So do not let a chatbot's checking stand in for yours.

What this cannot do

It cannot settle a question the passage leaves open. If the text does not tell, the answer will say so. Rest there.

It cannot make you right. A reader can be wrong with the tests and right without them.

It was tried by AI readers on the cases I gave them. It was not tried by a crowd of outside readers. I did not test which chatbots can take the prompt. Different chatbots may behave differently. So hold the answer loosely, and let the page have the last word.

If you find a place where the tests broke, I want to know. That is how they get better.