33. The Person Drawn to Socialism Who Was Told They Were the Enemy

The Christian Statement

Secular progressive: Every time I engage with Christians on poverty or inequality, they tell me I'm a socialist and treat me like I'm the enemy. But I care about poor people. I think that's supposed to be something Christians care about too.

This is one of the most important conversations in the current cultural moment and one of the most badly handled by the political-Christianity that has identified economic conservatism with Christian faithfulness.

Disciple: You're absolutely right that care for the poor is central to the biblical witness. Amos, Isaiah, Micah, Jesus - the prophetic tradition is full of God's concern for economic justice. The question I want to ask you is not whether poor people matter - they obviously do. It's whether the systems we propose to address poverty are actually capable of addressing the root causes. And what those root causes are.

The conversation can then explore the theological roots of human dignity, the question of whether material poverty is ultimately addressable by material means alone, the difference between state provision and genuine community, and the early church's extraordinary record of voluntary, Spirit-driven generosity that produced a community where no one was in need (Acts 4:34).

The political-Christianity that dismisses concern for the poor as socialism has not read the prophets. The secular progressivism that dismisses the church as a defender of privilege has not read Acts 2-4. Both are missing something. The disciple who can engage the genuine concern for the poor while questioning the adequacy of purely material solutions is doing the work that neither the political Christian nor the secular progressive is doing.

--