Michlaude Discipleship Project

The Michlaude Discipleship Project

Not Yet Seen

The cross, Pentecost, AD 70, and a return still ahead

Contents and reading screens →

Start Here

Start here: what do your eyes tell you?

Turn on the news. Is evil defeated? Is death gone? Has every tear been wiped away? No. People still die, graves are still full, and the world is still at war.

Scripture tells us what the finish will look like:

  • "The last enemy to be eliminated is death" (1 Corinthians 15:26).
  • "death will not exist any more—or mourning, or crying, or pain" (Revelation 21:4).
  • "we are waiting for new heavens and a new earth, in which righteousness truly resides" (2 Peter 3:13).
  • "this mortal puts on immortality" (1 Corinthians 15:54).

A word on the rules I use. This argument uses a small set of numbered reading rules. Each one is a short test of how far a text's words go: for example, "shared words alone do not join two passages", or "a near-word by itself sets no length". Each time I name one, its plain meaning stands right beside it, and the list at the end says where each one is used. The rules apply to my side as much as to the other side.

I read these verses as physical, and here are the cues. Each one sits among words about bodies, graves and the world we can see:

  • 1 Corinthians 15:26. Paul opens the passage with "since death came through a man, the resurrection of the dead also came through a man. For just as in Adam all die, so also in Christ all will be made alive" (15:21-22). Then he writes, "But someone will say, 'How are the dead raised? With what kind of body will they come?'" (15:35). He answers with seed, flesh, dust and body: "What is sown is perishable, what is raised is imperishable" (15:42); "Flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom of God" (15:50); "the dead will be raised imperishable, and we will be changed" (15:52). So I read the death that is "the last enemy" as the death that came "in Adam", swallowed up when "this mortal puts on immortality" (15:54).
  • Revelation 21:4. Just before it, in the order the book gives them: "The sea gave up the dead that were in it, and Death and Hades gave up the dead that were in them" (20:13); "Death and Hades were thrown into the lake of fire" (20:14); John sees "a new heaven and a new earth" (21:1); and then God "will wipe away every tear from their eyes, and death will not exist any more" (21:4; Greek ho thanatos ouk estai eti, "death will not be any longer"). The Greek joins these with a plain "and" (kai), not a time word, so taking them as one after another is my reading of the order the book gives.
  • 2 Peter 3:13. Peter sets it beside the flood: "the world existing at that time was destroyed when it was deluged with water. But by the same word the present heavens and earth have been reserved for fire" (3:6-7). Peter says "the heavens will be burned up and dissolve" (3:12), and, as I read it, after that come "new heavens and a new earth" (3:13; the Greek opens the verse with a plain de, "but", which gives no time order). The flood came on a real world, and Peter puts the fire beside it.

When Scripture calls living people "dead", it says so in the same breath: "you were dead in your offenses and sins" (Ephesians 2:1); "even though we were dead in offenses, made us alive together with Christ" (Ephesians 2:5); "I was once alive apart from the law, but with the coming of the commandment sin became alive and I died" (Romans 7:9-10); "We know that we have crossed over from death to life because we love our fellow Christians" (1 John 3:14); "you have a reputation that you are alive, but in reality you are dead" (Revelation 3:1). No marker of that kind was found in the passages around 1 Corinthians 15:26, Revelation 21:4 or 2 Peter 3:13. I read these verses as physical, from the cues the passages themselves give, and I use them that way. At 1 Corinthians 15:54 it is more than my reading: Paul's word "mortal" (thnētos) means the physical body in all six places he uses it (Rule 11), so "this mortal puts on immortality" is said of the body.

Two things in those passages, said plainly:

  • Paul does tie death to sin: "The sting of death is sin" (1 Corinthians 15:56). But two verses earlier, death is swallowed up "when ... this mortal puts on immortality" (15:54), and "mortal" is the body.
  • Revelation names "the second death—the lake of fire" (20:14). That is a second death with its own name. It is not a living person called dead, and Death itself is thrown into it, earlier in the book than "death will not exist any more".

One complication, and how the argument stands with it. Isaiah also speaks of "new heavens and a new earth" (Isaiah 65:17). In that same picture, "no one will die before the age of one hundred" (65:20; the Hebrew says the young man "will die", yamut, at a hundred years). So in Isaiah's picture, death is still there. 2 Peter 3:13 uses the same words, "new heavens and a new earth", and does not say whether death is there. So I do not use 2 Peter 3:13 to show that death ends. For that I use 1 Corinthians 15:26 and 15:54 and Revelation 21:4, which say it outright. I use 2 Peter 3:13 for what it does say: "the present heavens and earth" are burned up and dissolve (3:7, 3:10-12), and "we are waiting for new heavens and a new earth" (3:13); that the new ones come after that is my reading.

If all of that was fulfilled in AD 70, we would see it. We do not. Death still takes us, and the heavens and earth still stand.

Our testimony. The Holy Spirit gives testimony to Christ in the members of Christ's body, which is both the church and its people. Because the veil is torn, the members of Christ's body have communion with God directly, and in that communion His Spirit gives them comfort, continuously. Out of that communion, those of us who wait for his return are certain that the things we wait for have not yet happened. They were not completed in AD 70, as some say.

That is our testimony, and it cannot be proved the way a regular witness can, so nothing else in this argument rests on it. Here is what Scripture itself says:

  • Christ's body is both the church and its people. "Now the church is his body, the fullness of him who fills all in all" (Ephesians 1:23). "Now you are Christ's body, and each of you is a member of it" (1 Corinthians 12:27). In Greek, the whole is one sōma, "body", and the people are its melē, "members", each one individually (ek merous).
  • The veil is torn. When Jesus died, "the temple curtain was torn in two, from top to bottom" (Matthew 27:51). Hebrews uses the same Greek word for curtain, katapetasma, for the way Jesus opened for us: "the fresh and living way that he inaugurated for us through the curtain, that is, through his flesh" (Hebrews 10:20). Paul writes that "through him we both have access in one Spirit to the Father" (Ephesians 2:18).
  • The Spirit testifies about Christ. Jesus said, "he will testify about me" (John 15:26; Greek marturēsei peri emou, "he will bear witness concerning me"). John writes, "the Spirit is the one who testifies" (1 John 5:6).
  • The Spirit bears witness inside the believer. "The Spirit himself bears witness to our spirit that we are God's children" (Romans 8:16). That is the NET as printed; the Greek verb, summarturei, has "with" built into it, so word for word it is "bears witness with our spirit". And of each believer: "The one who believes in the Son of God has the testimony in himself" (1 John 5:10; some Greek editions read "in him").
  • The Spirit comforts the church. The church went on "in the encouragement of the Holy Spirit" (Acts 9:31). The Greek word, paraklēsis, means comfort as well as encouragement; the NET itself translates it "comfort" in "God of all comfort" (2 Corinthians 1:3).

The Spirit's testimony is to Christ, not a timetable. We know of no verse that says the Spirit tells a believer when the end will come, so our certainty is our testimony, not a verse. We do not say that anyone who reads these things differently lacks the Spirit. Scripture tells its readers to test: "do not believe every spirit, but test the spirits to determine if they are from God" (1 John 4:1), and "examine all things; hold fast to what is good" (1 Thessalonians 5:21). The Greek verb in both is dokimazete, "test". Testing by Scripture is what the rest of this argument does.

Now back to what our eyes see. Looking at the world as it is now and asking "is it finished?" is not a test I made up. Scripture uses it. "At present we do not yet see all things under his control" (Hebrews 2:8; Greek nun de oupō horōmen, "but now we do not yet see"). Paul answered people who said "the day of the Lord is already here" by naming what must come first, which had not come (2 Thessalonians 2:2-3). He also warned about Hymenaeus and Philetus, who were "saying that the resurrection has already occurred" (2 Timothy 2:17-18). Paul answered "it has already happened" from the start (2 Thessalonians 2:2-3; 2 Timothy 2:17-18). Peter answered the opposite complaint, from scoffers who asked "Where is his promised return?", with "we are waiting" (2 Peter 3:4, 13). The church has answered both ever since.

A fair objection, answered. Some say the kingdom is spiritual and grows over time, and they point out that evil is still "outside" the city even in Revelation's picture (22:15). Revelation does say that. But the things Scripture says end at the finish are things we can check: death, our dying bodies, graves, tears. Those are not only spiritual, and they are still here.

The Case for a Return Still Ahead

His return will be seen

Christians have always expected to see Jesus come back. To say he came in a way no one saw goes against everything Scripture says about it.

  • He left in plain sight, and he will come back the same way. "While they were watching, he was lifted up and a cloud hid him from their sight" (Acts 1:9; Greek apo tōn ophthalmōn autōn, "from their eyes"). "This same Jesus ... will come back in the same way you saw him go into heaven" (Acts 1:11; Greek houtōs eleusetai hon tropon etheasasthe, "he will come in the manner you watched").
  • As I read it, Jesus warned against a hidden coming. "If someone says to you, 'Look, he is in the wilderness,' do not go out, or 'Look, he is in the inner rooms,' do not believe him. For just like the lightning comes from the east and flashes to the west, so the coming of the Son of Man will be" (Matthew 24:26-27). The Greek word for "coming" there, parousia, is the same word the disciples used when they asked about "your coming" (24:3). Luke has a similar warning in another setting (Luke 17:23-24).
  • Every eye will see him, and he will appear. "Every eye will see him" (Revelation 1:7). "We will see him just as he is" (1 John 3:2). "He will appear a second time" (Hebrews 9:28). "When Christ ... appears, then you too will be revealed in glory with him" (Colossians 3:4).

A fair objection, answered. Some say "coming on the clouds" is picture language that the prophets used for God's judgments, when no one saw God with their eyes. The prophets do use cloud language that way. But Acts 1:9-11 is not a prophet's picture. It is an account of what eyewitnesses saw: they watched him go, and they were told he will come "in the same way".

Isaiah 19:1. Some point to a coming on a cloud that no one saw: "Look, the Lord rides on a swift-moving cloud and approaches Egypt" (Isaiah 19:1). Its "Look" (Hebrew hinneh) is a call to the hearers; the verse prints no verb of anyone seeing the Lord. So it does not say that anyone saw him on the cloud, or that no one did: cloud language by itself decides neither (Rule 1). So I rest sight not on clouds but on words for eyes and watching: "while they were watching, he was lifted up and a cloud hid him from their sight" (Acts 1:9; Greek apo tōn ophthalmōn autōn, "from their eyes"); "in the same way you saw him go into heaven" (Acts 1:11; etheasasthe, "you watched"); and lightning that "comes from the east and flashes to the west" (Matthew 24:27). What "in the same way" covers, the verse does not list; that it includes being seen, and a bodily return of "this same Jesus", is my reading.

1. The cross ended the old covenant, and AD 70 cleared away what was left of it. (This heading is my reading of the verses below; no verse says it in these words.)

Jesus said, "This cup that is poured out for you is the new covenant in my blood" (Luke 22:20). A covenant like a will "takes effect only at death" (Hebrews 9:17). God took the decrees that stood against us away "by nailing it to the cross" (Colossians 2:14).

The old system still stood for a while. Priests still offered "the gifts prescribed by the law" (Hebrews 8:4), and believers met "in the temple courts" (Acts 2:46). Hebrews 8:4 is a record that the old system still ran only if Hebrews was written before AD 70, and its date is open (see the dates at the end, which are scholarship, not the text). If it was, then, as I read it, Hebrews 8:4 is a record from the old system's own days; if it was written later, it does not show this. Acts 2:46, and Acts 21:26 below, do not depend on its date. Years after the cross, Paul (who had by then spent "three years" with the church at Ephesus, Acts 20:17, 31) joined four men who had "taken a vow" (Acts 21:23), and "after he had purified himself along with them, he went to the temple and gave notice of the completion of the days of purification, when the sacrifice would be offered for each of them" (Acts 21:26), a record that the old system still ran. Hebrews says the first covenant is already "obsolete" yet still "about to disappear" (Hebrews 8:13; Greek engus aphanismou, "near to vanishing"). That is a near-word too, and a near-word by itself gives no length, in either direction. So setting Hebrews 8:13 beside AD 70 is my reading, not something the verse says. Jesus foretold that "not one stone will be left on another" (Matthew 24:2). Josephus records that the temple burned "in the second year of the reign of Vespasian" (Wars of the Jews, bk 6, ch. 4), which is AD 70.

On Matthew 5:18. Jesus said, "Do not think that I have come to abolish the law or the prophets. I have not come to abolish these things but to fulfill them" (5:17). Then he said, "until heaven and earth pass away not the smallest letter or stroke of a letter will pass from the law until everything takes place" (5:18). The wording differs from the "all these things" of Matthew 24. In Greek, 5:18 says heōs an panta genētai, "until everything takes place". Matthew 24:34 says heōs an panta tauta genētai, "until all these things take place". In 24:34 the extra word tauta, "these", points to things just described; 5:18 has no such word. The rules do not fix the scope of either phrase, so the different wording does not prove that the two mean different things. It only means that 5:18 cannot simply be read as the Matthew 24 list. I read "until everything takes place" as fulfilled in Christ, who came "to fulfill" (5:17). That is my reading.

In fairness: the two verses share the same frame ("until everything takes place" in 5:18, "until all these things take place" in 24:34; the Greek has the same verb, genētai, in both), and Matthew 24:35 repeats "Heaven and earth will pass away". The fully-fulfilled view uses those links to tie the two verses together. But shared words alone do not prove one meaning, and that test applies to my side as much as to theirs.

2. The church began at Pentecost. (This heading is my reading of the verses below; no verse says it in these words.)

Jesus said, "I will build my church" (Matthew 16:18). The Spirit "had not yet been given, because Jesus was not yet glorified" (John 7:39). At Pentecost, "All of them were filled with the Holy Spirit" (Acts 2:4), and Peter calls that day "the beginning" (Acts 11:15). Paul writes, "In one Spirit we were all baptized into one body" (1 Corinthians 12:13).

As I read these verses, the cross put the new covenant in force, and Pentecost gave the Spirit and formed the body. Believers live "in the present age" while they "wait for ... the glorious appearing" (Titus 2:12-13). They have "tasted ... the coming age" (Hebrews 6:5). I read these verses as the two ages overlapping until he comes. The verses do not say "overlap", so that is my reading.

3. On the Mount of Olives, Jesus prepared his disciples for the years after he left.

Peter, James, John, and Andrew "asked him privately" (Mark 13:3; all four are among the twelve, Mark 3:14-18), and he told them: "You will be handed over to councils and beaten in the synagogues. You will stand before governors and kings because of me ... for it is not you speaking, but the Holy Spirit" (Mark 13:9-11). In a different talk, the night before he died ("Now it was night", John 13:30; 18:1, 28; 19:16-18), he told them why he warned them: "I have told you all these things so that you will not fall away" (John 16:1). Acts tells of the same kinds of things happening. The apostles were jailed and beaten (Acts 5), "a great persecution began" (Acts 8:1), and Paul stood before "King Agrippa" and "the governor" Festus (Acts 25:13, 23; 26:30). Acts does not say these things fulfilled Jesus' words, so that link is my reading.

4. The birth pains are only a beginning, and the birth is the resurrection. (The second half is my reading: Jesus does not say what the birth is.)

Wars, famines and earthquakes "are the beginning of birth pains" (Matthew 24:8). Of the wars Jesus says, "this must happen, but the end is still to come" (24:6); Luke has "the end will not come at once" (Luke 21:9). "Then they will hand you over to be persecuted" (Matthew 24:9). That "Then" (Greek tote) is a plain "then"; by itself it does not join the persecutions to the first pains or set their order. Luke's account says, "But before all this, they will seize you and persecute you" (Luke 21:12; Greek pro de toutōn pantōn, "before all these things"). So I do not rest anything on which comes first. Of the persecutions, here is what is written: "the person who endures to the end will be saved" (Matthew 24:13), and "this gospel of the kingdom will be preached throughout the whole inhabited earth as a testimony to all the nations, and then the end will come" (24:14). I read that whole stretch as labor. I read Paul's own labor picture as telling us what is being born: "we ... groan inwardly as we eagerly await our adoption, the redemption of our bodies" (Romans 8:22-23).

5. The resurrection is bodily, and nothing shows it happened in AD 70.

The fully-fulfilled view links Daniel 12:2 ("Many of those who sleep in the dusty ground will awake") to 1 Corinthians 15:54. That link brings in what Paul says there: "when ... this mortal puts on immortality, then the saying that is written will happen, 'Death has been swallowed up in victory'" (15:54). In Greek, "this mortal" is to thnēton touto. The NET adds "body" in 15:53, and the Greek has no word for it. But Paul's word "mortal" (thnētos) means the physical body in all six places he uses it. So the thing that puts on immortality is the physical body. Paul gives the order: "each in his own order: Christ, the firstfruits; then when Christ comes, those who belong to him" (15:23; Greek tagmati, "order"). His "then" is epeita ("then", the STEP gloss). As I read it, it is a word of sequence: it puts "those who belong to him" after Christ, at his coming, and it gives no length. No record shows the dead raised or the living changed in AD 70.

What "mortal" reaches. Rule 11 ("mortal" is the physical body) is about one word, thnētos, but Paul's own sentences set that word on "body" and "flesh": "do not let sin reign in your mortal body" (Romans 6:12; Greek sōmati); "will also make your mortal bodies alive" (Romans 8:11; sōmata); "made visible in our mortal body" (2 Corinthians 4:11; the Greek is thnētē sarki, "mortal flesh"). In 1 Corinthians 15 he pairs the words himself: "Flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom of God, nor does the perishable inherit the imperishable" (1 Corinthians 15:50); "this perishable puts on the imperishable, and this mortal puts on immortality" (1 Corinthians 15:54). And "what is raised is imperishable" (1 Corinthians 15:42; the same Greek word, aphtharsia), which Paul calls "a spiritual body" (15:44). That the "mortal" of 15:53-54 is the "body" of 15:35-44 is my reading, from these pairs and the run of the passage; shared words alone do not join passages (Rule 2). A further reading, as I read it: Paul's own verb for the mortal is "put on" (15:53-54; Greek enduō, "to put on" or "to clothe"), and in another letter he writes, "we do not want to be unclothed, but clothed, so that what is mortal may be swallowed up by life" (2 Corinthians 5:4; Greek ekdusasthai, "to be unclothed", ependusasthai, "to be clothed", and to thnēton, "the mortal"). So the mortal is clothed, not left behind. The text does not join the two letters, and shared words do not join them, so this step is my reading.

6. The early church was still waiting after AD 70.

Eusebius's Church History, Book 3, is the history usually cited for the flight to Pella before Jerusalem fell. The same book says this:

  • Jerusalem's fall came "in accordance with the prophecies of our Lord" (ch. 7). I agree with that; that is my own judgment, not a rule result.
  • Eusebius says "It is said" that John was condemned to dwell on Patmos "in this persecution", the one under Domitian (ch. 17-18).
  • Jude's grandsons told Domitian that Christ's kingdom "would appear at the end of the world, when he should come in glory to judge the quick and the dead" (ch. 20).
  • John lived "until the time of Trajan" (ch. 23, Eusebius quoting Irenaeus).
  • Eusebius names "the resurrection of the dead" among "the doctrines of the Church", and says those who followed false teachers instead "have fallen away from the true hope" (ch. 26).
  • Eusebius reports that Papias taught "a period of some thousand years after the resurrection of the dead" (ch. 39). So for Papias the resurrection was still ahead. Eusebius himself disagrees with Papias about the thousand years.

Irenaeus, about AD 180, writes, "then the Lord will come from heaven in the clouds" (Against Heresies 5.30.4). Tertullian reads the Olivet Discourse as I do: first the events "until the overthrow of Jerusalem", then events "up to the very end of the world". He asks, "Who has yet beheld Jesus descending from heaven in like manner as the apostles saw Him ascend?" (On the Resurrection of the Flesh 22). Polycarp writes that Christ "comes as the Judge of the living and the dead" (To the Philippians 2). The Apostles' Creed says, "From thence he shall come to judge the quick and the dead."

None of the early writers cited here (the Didache, Polycarp, Irenaeus, Tertullian, Eusebius, Cyril, Chrysostom) says everything was fulfilled in AD 70. These records show what the church believed, not that it was right.

An argument from silence, and why this silence may have a voice. What follows is an argument, not a rule result. Silence alone proves nothing, and I do not claim it does. But large acts of God like these are not quiet, and here we are arguing over something that, if it happened, went unnoticed.

  • Scripture says the coming will be seen: "every eye will see him" (Revelation 1:7); "They will see the Son of Man arriving on the clouds of heaven" (Matthew 24:30).
  • At Matthew 27:53, when the raised saints came out, Scripture says people saw them: they "went into the holy city and appeared to many people" (Matthew 27:53; Greek enephanisthēsan pollois, "were made to appear to many").
  • Other great acts are recorded as noticed, even by opponents. At Pentecost "a crowd gathered" from "every nation under heaven" (Acts 2:5-6). The council said, "it is plain to all who live in Jerusalem that a notable miraculous sign has come about through them, and we cannot deny it" (Acts 4:16). After Lazarus was raised, "some of them went to the Pharisees and reported to them what Jesus had done", and the council was called together (John 11:46-47). Paul told the king, "this was not done in a corner" (Acts 26:26).

The limits, said plainly:

  • Scripture also records acts that few saw, or that were hidden on purpose. The risen Jesus was seen "not by all the people, but by us, the witnesses God had already chosen" (Acts 10:41). At Cana the head steward did not know where the wine came from, "though the servants who had drawn the water knew" (John 2:9). To those outside, Jesus spoke in parables, "so that although they look they may look but not see" (Mark 4:12). So silence alone is not proof.
  • The record of those years is not silent about everything. Josephus (Jewish War 6.5.3) lists signs around the war: a star like a sword over the city, a comet that lasted a year, a light around the altar, the heavy temple gate opening by itself, and "chariots and troops of soldiers" seen "among the clouds". Tacitus (Histories 5.13) reports armies seen meeting in the sky and the temple doors opening by themselves. If anyone takes the armies in the clouds to be the coming, look at what is described: chariots and soldiers, not the Son of Man. And Josephus says the people did not agree on what the signs meant.
  • So the silence is specific. People in AD 66-70 noticed strange things and wrote them down. In Josephus's Jewish War and Antiquities, Tacitus's Histories and Eusebius's Church History, Book 3, no passage was found that describes the dead raised, or the Son of Man seen, in AD 66-70. That is "not found", not "none exists".

That is why the absence is worth weighing. The same writers who recorded a comet and a gate that opened by itself recorded no resurrection of the dead and no Son of Man on the clouds. This does not prove the fully-fulfilled view wrong, and it bears only on the forms of that view that claim a coming people could see, just as the needs below are needs of the view as I state it there. It means those forms of the view ask us to believe that the two largest events they claim went unrecorded by the people who were writing down the strange things of those very years.

7. If Revelation was written late, the fully-fulfilled reading of Revelation falls.

Irenaeus gives the date. His Greek survives because Eusebius quotes it twice (3.18.3 and 5.8.6):

oude gar pro pollou chronou heōrathē, alla schedon epi tēs hēmeteras geneas, pros tō telei tēs Dometianou archēs.

"For it was seen not long ago, but almost in our own generation, toward the end of Domitian's rule."

The verb "was seen" (heōrathē) is the same verb as "the one who saw the revelation" just before it, so the thing seen is the revelation. The Greek form itself does not show whether "it" or "he" is meant. That is why some say Irenaeus meant that John was seen. But Eusebius, a native Greek reader, sums the passage up as "recorded ... about the Apocalypse" (5.8.7). And Irenaeus says John lived until Trajan's reign. If he had meant that John was seen alive, he would have named Trajan's time, not the end of Domitian's reign.

Domitian ruled from AD 81 to 96 by the standard dating, so this means about AD 95 or 96, some 25 years after the temple fell. If that is when John wrote:

  • A book that shows "what must happen after these things" (4:1) cannot be announcing the AD 70 judgment as still ahead.
  • "Do not seal ... because the time is near" (22:10) points past AD 70: as I read it, on the late date, a time still called near in AD 95 had not yet come.
  • "Come, Lord Jesus!" (22:20) is the church still praying for his coming after AD 70.

If Revelation was written before AD 70 instead (the early date, as some scholars date it), then, as I read them, these three places show nothing about AD 70 either way, and my case does not depend on which date is right.

The arguments for an early date do not hold up:

  • The temple is measured in Revelation 11. Ezekiel measured a temple in a vision "in the fourteenth year after the city was struck down" (Ezekiel 40:1-3).
  • "Near" means before AD 70. That uses the date to prove the meaning and the meaning to prove the date.
  • The sixth king is Nero. The verse names no one.
  • 666 is Nero. Irenaeus counted it "according to the reckoning of the Greeks", by Greek letters, not Hebrew ones. He tested three names, and Nero was not one of them.

The date stays open, because the Bible does not print it. But the fully-fulfilled reading of Revelation needs the early date, and it is not shown. My case works with either date.

8. Matthew 24:30 is the future return.

"Then the sign of the Son of Man will appear in heaven, and all the tribes of the earth will mourn. They will see the Son of Man arriving on the clouds of heaven with power and great glory. And he will send his angels with a loud trumpet blast, and they will gather his elect from the four winds, from one end of heaven to the other." (Matthew 24:30-31)

I read this as Jesus' return, still ahead. Here is why, from the verses.

  • It is seen. "They will see" (Greek opsontai). Mark has the same: "Then everyone will see the Son of Man arriving in the clouds" (Mark 13:26). There, "everyone" is the NET's word; the Greek has only opsontai, "they will see", so I do not lean on "everyone". Three verses earlier, Jesus said his coming would not be hidden "in the inner rooms" but would flash "like the lightning ... from the east ... to the west" (24:26-27).
  • It matches how he left. He went up "while they were watching" and "a cloud hid him from their sight". He "will come back in the same way you saw him go into heaven" (Acts 1:9-11). In Matthew 24:30, he comes "on the clouds of heaven".
  • "Every eye will see him." Revelation speaks of the same two pictures, the clouds and the mourning of "all the tribes on the earth": "He is returning with the clouds, and every eye will see him, even those who pierced him, and all the tribes on the earth will mourn because of him" (Revelation 1:7).
  • What comes with it is the end. He sends angels with "a loud trumpet blast" to "gather his elect" (24:31). Paul says, "the Lord himself will come down from heaven ... with the trumpet of God, and the dead in Christ will rise first" (1 Thessalonians 4:16), and "the trumpet will sound, and the dead will be raised imperishable" (1 Corinthians 15:52). Paul also gives the order: "then when Christ comes, those who belong to him" (15:23; epeita, "then", the STEP gloss; as I read it, a word of sequence, as in point 5). Jesus uses a like picture for "the end of the age": "The Son of Man will send his angels, and they will gather" (Matthew 13:39-41). The Greek words for "gather" differ (sullexousin in 13:41, episunaxousin in 24:31), and a like picture does not by itself make one event.
  • I read a turn at 24:36, from three marks together. "But as for that day and hour no one knows it—not even the angels in heaven—except the Father alone" (24:36). Three marks come together there. Jesus opens with Peri de, "Now concerning". "Day" is singular for the first time, "that day" (tēs hēmeras ekeinēs), after "those days" in the plural every time before it in the speech (24:19, 22, 29). And "hour" (hōras) appears for the first time in the speech. Mark has Peri de and the first singular "that day" at the same place (Mark 13:32). Peri de alone does not always open a new subject: Jesus uses it to take up the resurrection the Sadducees had already raised (Matthew 22:31; Mark 12:26), and Paul uses it for what the Corinthians wrote to him about (1 Corinthians 7:1). So my reading of a turn rests on the three marks together, not on Peri de by itself; no rule gives it. From there on, Jesus speaks of a coming whose day and hour no one knows, and of staying alert for it.

What the text does not settle, said plainly.

  • Matthew 24:30 comes before 24:34: "this generation will not pass away until all these things take place". The fully-fulfilled view says 24:30 is among "all these things", so it happened within that generation.
  • "Immediately after the suffering of those days" (24:29) ties the signs closely to the trouble just described. This is the hardest verse for my reading. Here is what the text gives on it, and no more:
  • "Immediately" (Greek eutheōs, with its short form euthus) is used 18 times in Matthew, and 24:29 is the only one in Matthew 24. In a story it joins two things in one scene: "Immediately his leprosy was cleansed" (8:3). In a parable no time is stated: "when trouble or persecution comes because of the word, immediately he falls away" (13:21); the servant with five talents "went off right away" (25:15-16). None of the 18 gives a number of days or years.
  • The three accounts agree in order, but not in the word. Mark says, "But in those days, after that suffering, the sun will be darkened" (Mark 13:24), with no "immediately". Luke has no matching clause. Between "those days" (Luke 21:23) and the "signs in the sun and moon and stars" (21:25), Luke puts "Jerusalem will be trampled down by the Gentiles until the times of the Gentiles are fulfilled" (21:24). Luke's only "immediately" word in the whole talk is a "not": "the end will not come at once" (21:9; Greek ouk eutheōs, "not immediately").
  • "Those days" are the days of the flight from Judea, the great suffering, and the days "cut short" (Matthew 24:16-22). The text says they will be cut short, and states no length for them.
  • So the text does not say how long "immediately" covers, or how long "those days" last. Whether Luke's "until the times of the Gentiles are fulfilled" stands at the same place as Matthew's "immediately" is not shown. I do not claim this settles the verse: not shown either way. My aim is to say what the text gives.
  • The text itself does not say where the break falls between the events of that generation and "that day".

So the claim that 24:30 is the future return is my reading from the verses. My answer rests on 24:33: "when you see all these things, know that he is near, right at the door." There, "all these things" are signs that are seen, and they point to something else that is near. Jesus goes straight on: "this generation will not pass away until all these things take place" (24:34). The same two Greek words, panta tauta, "all these things", stand back to back, first for what the readers "see" (24:33) and then for the things that "take place" (24:34). (That order is the NA28 text's; the local STEP data marks a different place for the words in 24:33 in the Tyndale House, Tregelles and Byzantine texts, and I rest nothing on the order.) The text names no list of what they are. If they are the same set, then the generation sees the signs, not necessarily the coming itself. But that is a reading too, and the rules do not decide what "all these things" covers. My reading also carries a burden. Rule 12 (dated words need a record that they were met) asks it of both sides: with "this generation" granted, whatever "all these things" covers took place within that generation, and that needs a record. I hold the other side to it ("No record shows", point 5), so I hold mine to it too: on my reading, a record has to show that the signs of 24:33 took place within that generation. One record is in Scripture: Acts tells that events of the kind Jesus foretold on the Mount of Olives happened, beginning with the apostles who heard him, who were jailed and beaten (Acts 5), and going on to "a great persecution" (Acts 8:1) and Paul before a king and a governor (point 3). So for such events happening within that generation, the record is in Scripture itself. The other records I cite for those years are outside Scripture (Josephus and Tacitus, point 6). None of these records, Acts included, says that those events are the signs of 24:33 (Acts does not say they fulfilled Jesus' words, point 3); that link is my reading. So on my reading Rule 12's burden is not shown to be met; the two parts are these: Scripture records that such events happened (Acts), and the link between those events and the signs of 24:33 is not shown. "Not shown" is not "did not happen".

The same test applies to both sides. Shared words alone do not prove two passages speak of one event. That test cuts against my use of 1 Thessalonians 4 and 1 Corinthians 15 here just as much as against theirs. It also applies to my joining of Acts 1:11 and Revelation 1:7 to Matthew 24:30. Those joins are my reading, and whoever joins passages carries the burden of showing the join.

The strongest opposing reading, named fairly: the vindication reading. Scholars who put 24:30 in AD 70 do not say Jesus came in a way no one saw. They say 24:30 is about Jesus being vindicated and enthroned in heaven, with the fall of Jerusalem as the sign of it. R. T. France reads the coming in 24:30 "not of a "coming" to earth at the parousia but of a "coming" to God" (The Gospel of Matthew). Kenneth Gentry writes that "the judgments serve as a sign that the Son of Man is enthroned" ("The Sign of the Son of Man (1)"). N. T. Wright reads the "coming on the clouds" sayings in Mark 13:26 and 14:62 as "about Jesus' vindication, his "coming" to heaven from earth" ("Farewell to the Rapture"); that article does not name Matthew 24:30. Their key verse is Daniel 7:13: "with the clouds of the sky one like a son of man was approaching. He went up to the Ancient of Days and was escorted before him." In Daniel, the son of man comes to God to receive a kingdom, not down to earth. They also point to Jesus' words to the high priest: "from now on you will see the Son of Man sitting at the right hand of the Power and coming on the clouds of heaven" (Matthew 26:64; Greek ap' arti, "from now on").

The answer from the verses.

  • Daniel 7:13 fits my reading too. Daniel sees one like a son of man "with the clouds of the sky" coming to the Ancient of Days, and he receives "ruling authority, honor, and sovereignty" (Daniel 7:13-14). The Aramaic says he "reached" (meta) the Ancient of Days and was "brought near" (haqrevuhi) before him. The New Testament shows that movement toward God at the ascension. "a cloud hid him from their sight" (Acts 1:9). He is "exalted to the right hand of God" (Acts 2:33). "All authority in heaven and on earth has been given to me" (Matthew 28:18). Then the men in white say he will "come back in the same way you saw him go" (Acts 1:11). John takes the same cloud picture and writes "every eye will see him" (Revelation 1:7; the Greek verb is erchetai, "he is coming"). Jesus' own words to the high priest fit the same two steps: "from now on you will see the Son of Man sitting at the right hand of the Power and coming on the clouds of heaven" (Matthew 26:64). The sitting at the right hand begins at the ascension (Acts 2:33). The coming on the clouds is the part Acts 1:11 and Revelation 1:7 place at the return. All of this is my reading, and shared words alone do not prove one event, so the burden is mine. This point does not carry my case. My case rests on Matthew 24:26-27, 24:31, Acts 1:11 and Revelation 1:7. If Daniel 7:13 shows only movement to the Ancient of Days, it does not decide between the two readings, and it does not rule mine out.
  • In Matthew 24:30-31, the coming is followed by action on earth. He sends angels "from one end of heaven to the other" to gather his elect, and "all the tribes of the earth will mourn" as they "see" him.
  • Jesus has just said that his coming is like lightning seen from east to west (24:27), not a scene in heaven that people on earth cannot see.
  • Cloud language by itself cannot prove a final event or rule one out. So the case rests on what Matthew 24 itself speaks of with the clouds: seeing, lightning, trumpet, angels and the gathering of the elect.

Some scholars read 24:30 as the future return. Among them is D. A. Carson, who in a sermon on the Olivet Discourse takes it as a description of the Lord's return: "in my judgment that is conclusive". France himself puts a turn at 24:36, the same verse my reading turns on.

How the church has read it. Every early church writer cited here who speaks of the coming on the clouds puts it at the final return:

  • the Didache, ch. 16: "Then shall the world see the Lord coming upon the clouds of heaven."
  • Irenaeus, Against Heresies 5.30.4: "then the Lord will come from heaven in the clouds".
  • Tertullian, On the Resurrection of the Flesh 22: "Who has yet beheld Jesus descending from heaven in like manner".
  • Cyril of Jerusalem, Catechetical Lecture 15.20: "Then shall they see the Son of man coming on the clouds of heaven".
  • John Chrysostom, Homily 76 on Matthew: after the words about Jerusalem, "He passes on to His own coming", and then he quotes "Then shall appear the sign of the Son of Man in Heaven".

None of them, in the places cited, applies 24:30 only to AD 70. Tertullian and Chrysostom both split the Olivet talk into a Jerusalem part and a coming part, though at different places. The Catechism of the Catholic Church teaches that Christ's reign is yet to be fulfilled "with power and great glory" by the King's return (671). Those paragraphs (668-677, 1038-1041) do not cite Matthew 24:30 and do not mention AD 70. These writers and teachings are a witness to what the church believed, not proof of what the verse means.

9. Where I stop: only the Father knows.

The cross and Pentecost are in Scripture's own account. Jesus foretold the temple's fall: "not one stone will be left on another" (Matthew 24:2). Josephus records that it burned, and when: "in the second year of the reign of Vespasian" (Wars of the Jews, bk 6, ch. 4). As I quote it, the record reports the burning and its date; it says nothing about the stones. That the fall Josephus records is the fall Jesus foretold is my reading; an outside record cannot make that link by itself. And I do not claim that the temple's fall was Christ's coming. When he returns and the dead are raised is not given to us: "as for that day and hour no one knows it ... except the Father alone" (Matthew 24:36). "You are not permitted to know the times or periods that the Father has set by his own authority" (Acts 1:7). To those who ask "Where is his promised return?", Scripture answers: "a single day is like a thousand years with the Lord" (2 Peter 3:4, 8).

My hope of his return rests on Matthew 24:30, read as above, on Acts 1:11, "will come back in the same way you saw him go into heaven", and on Paul. Its timing I leave with the Father.

Acts 1:11 is not the only place that hope rests: Jesus' own words carry the coming (Matthew 24:30), and the narrator's own words carry the sight, "while they were watching, he was lifted up and a cloud hid him from their sight" (Acts 1:9). I understand the two men in white as angels. John calls the two at the empty tomb "two angels in white" (John 20:12; Greek angelous, "angels", with leukois, "white"), the same pair Luke 24:4 calls "two men ... in dazzling attire". And angels do not always say who they are: "some have entertained angels without knowing it" (Hebrews 13:2). That is my reading, since Acts 1:10 calls them only "two men in white clothing".

Paul's own test

When some in Thessalonica were told "that the day of the Lord is already here" (2 Thessalonians 2:2; Greek enestēken, "has come" or "is present"), Paul did not just tell them to wait. He gave the church the defining elements of that day, so they could check the claim themselves:

  • What the claim is about. Paul makes his request "regarding the arrival of our Lord Jesus Christ and our being gathered to be with him" (2:1; Greek parousias, "coming", and episunagōgēs, "gathering together", with one "the", tēs, over both). The claim he answers is that "the day of the Lord is already here" (2:2). I read 2:1-2 this way: as Paul frames it, a claim that the day had come was a claim that the coming and the gathering had come. That is my reading; the words of 2:1 and 2:2 sit side by side, and no rule joins them by itself.
  • What must come first, in Paul's words:
  • "that day will not arrive until the rebellion comes and the man of lawlessness is revealed" (2:3; Greek apostasia, "falling away", and prōton, "first").
  • He "takes his seat in God's temple, displaying himself as God" (2:4). I read this as part of his being revealed (2:3).
  • What "holds him back" must be "taken out of the way" (2:6-7).
  • What comes with the day itself, in Paul's words:
  • Then "the Lord will destroy by the breath of his mouth and wipe out by the manifestation of his arrival" the lawless one (2:8; Greek tē epiphaneia tēs parousias, "by the appearing of his coming"). Paul's word for "arrival" here, parousia, is the word of 2:1, the arrival the claim is about: this destruction comes by the arrival itself, not before it.

Paul used these elements to settle the question: the day had not come, because what must come first had not yet happened. His words for what comes first are conditions ("that day will not arrive until", 2:3), and the test is as good today as it was then. On that reading, anyone who says the day came in AD 70 is saying that the coming of our Lord and our being gathered to him came then. To show it, they have to show that what Paul says must come first had come: the falling away, the man of lawlessness revealed and seated in God's temple, and the removal of what held him back. And they have to show that what Paul says comes with the day came with it: the lawless one's destruction by the appearing of Christ's coming. If one of them is not shown, the claim is not shown. Where the record does not show one, the answer is "not shown", never "did not happen". How each element is read is a reading, on both sides. That includes who the man of lawlessness is, what "God's temple" means here, and what holds him back.

One letter, one Lord, one coming. Paul wrote a letter, not chapters. The chapter number between 1:12 and 2:1 was added much later, so it is not Scripture's own division. From 1:3 to 2:12 is one continuous letter to the same readers about the same Lord Jesus and his coming.

He begins with a church that is suffering as he writes: "all the persecutions and afflictions you are enduring" (1:4); "the kingdom of God, for which in fact you are suffering" (1:5). The Greek verbs for the suffering are present tense (anechesthe, "you are bearing", 1:4; paschete, "you suffer", 1:5; thlibomenois, "being afflicted", 1:7). God will "give rest together with us when the Lord Jesus is revealed from heaven with his mighty angels" (1:7). In one sentence in the Greek (as the STEP data punctuates it; the NET ends a sentence at 1:7), this is "when he comes to be glorified among his saints and admired on that day" (1:10; Greek en tē hēmera ekeinē, "in that day"). Paul then prays for them: "we pray for you always ... that the name of our Lord Jesus may be glorified in you" (1:11-12).

Then he makes a request: "Now regarding the arrival of our Lord Jesus Christ and our being gathered to be with him, we ask you, brothers and sisters" (2:1). In Greek it opens Erōtōmen de humas, adelphoi, "Now we ask you, brothers", and goes on huper tēs parousias tou kuriou hēmōn Iēsou Christou, "concerning the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ". Those four opening words are the same ones Paul uses in his first letter when he turns to a new matter, respect for the church's leaders (1 Thessalonians 5:12). So 2:1 is a new request, and I say so plainly: the prayer turns into a request, and Paul calls them "brothers" for the first time since 1:3.

But I read the subject as carrying straight on. The Lord Jesus is the same (1:12; 2:1). The readers are the same, "you" (1:10-12; 2:1-2). The coming is the same: "when he comes" (1:10, elthē) and "the arrival", or coming (2:1, parousia). And I read the day as the same subject, from the run of the letter itself: "that day" (1:10) and then "the day of the Lord" (2:2). Paul put no chapter break between them. In my judgment, and not as a rule result, whoever says he changed to a different day carries the burden of showing it.

Point 8's test still applies here. Shared words alone do not join two passages (Rule 2), and that holds for two places in one letter as much as for two books. So I do not rest the same day on the shared word "day": "that day" (1:10) and "the day of the Lord" (2:2) are not even the same words. I rest it on the run of the letter: one letter and one run of thought, from the same writer to the same readers, and nothing marks a change of subject except the new request, and that request is about the same coming. That the day is the same is still my reading. The subject continues, Paul makes a new request about it, and the chapter break is not his. On that reading, the rest promised in 1:7-10 comes on the day that 2:2-8 says had not yet come, and Paul's own test applies to it. (In 2:3, the NET's "that day" is carried over from 2:2; the Greek of 2:3 has no word for "day".)

What is shown, and what is not:

  • Shown: the readers were suffering when Paul wrote, and their rest is tied to the Lord Jesus being "revealed from heaven" (1:7).
  • Not shown: whether those readers would be alive or dead when that day comes. The present-tense verbs say they were suffering when Paul wrote. They do not say who would be living when the Lord is revealed. The text does not settle it either way, so I do not draw that conclusion.

One thing the text does not say: 2:2 says some were told the day had already come. It does not say they feared they had missed being caught up (the "rapture"). That idea is not in the text.

The Fully-Fulfilled View, Tested

What the fully-fulfilled view needs, and where each stands

Writers who hold the fully-fulfilled view differ among themselves: for example, on whether the resurrection and Christ's risen body were bodily, on whether those who had died saw the coming, and on what shape the resurrection takes. So each need below is a need of the view as I state it here (everything fulfilled in AD 70). A writer on that side who does not hold a given need is not answered by it, and the other needs still stand.

  1. A non-bodily resurrection. Shown against on Rule 11 for what 1 Corinthians 15:53-54 says, and, as I read it, for the raising of the dead in 15:52. Paul's "mortal" (to thnēton touto) means the physical body in all six places he uses it. I take that to reach "the resurrection" because of how the passage runs. Paul writes, "the dead will be raised imperishable, and we will be changed" (15:52), and goes straight on: "For this perishable body must put on the imperishable, and this mortal body must put on immortality" (15:53; the Greek has gar, "for", and no word for "body"). I read the raising of 15:52 and the mortal putting on immortality in 15:53-54 as one subject, from that run; the verse numbers are not Paul's.
  2. Death defeated in AD 70.
  • From the text: not shown. Paul says death is swallowed up "when ... this mortal puts on immortality" (15:54). On Rule 11, "mortal" is the physical body, and no record shows that happening in AD 70.
  • From what we see (an observation, not a rule result): people still die. This fits the text, but the text result does not rest on it.
  1. An early Revelation. Not shown. Irenaeus, quoted in Greek by Eusebius, puts what "was seen" toward the end of Domitian's rule. The Greek form does not show whether "it" or "he" was seen (point 7).
  2. Witnesses who saw it fulfilled. Not shown. No early writer saying it was all fulfilled was found in the writers cited here (the Didache, Polycarp, Irenaeus, Tertullian, Eusebius's Church History Book 3, Cyril, Chrysostom), and "not found" is not the same as "none".
  3. A coming no one saw. Not shown. Jesus warned, "if someone says to you, 'Look, he is in the wilderness,' do not go out, or 'Look, he is in the inner rooms,' do not believe him. For just like the lightning comes from the east and flashes to the west, so the coming of the Son of Man will be" (Matthew 24:26-27). And the men in white said he "will come back in the same way you saw him go into heaven" (Acts 1:11). I read that warning as telling against a coming no one saw.
  4. "Near" meaning a few years. Not shown. A near-word by itself gives no length (Rule 7: near-words set no length). Scripture's own cases show it where the text itself states the link, and on my reading where it does not: it sets near-words beside things that came long after (how long, by the scholarship dates in the note below) and beside things that came soon. How each case is tied, said plainly: the first is tied by the text itself through a word of promising, because Hebrews calls the words a promise ("he has promised"); whether it is the same promise as Haggai's, the text does not say, and I read it as the same. In the second and third, joining the near-word to Babylon's fall is my reading, from the names and the scroll the texts give.
  • Haggai 2:6 with Hebrews 12:26-27. Haggai said, "In just a little while I will once again shake the sky and the earth" (Haggai 2:6; Hebrew od achat me'at hi, "yet once, it is a little"). Hebrews has "once more" (Greek eti hapax, "yet once"; Haggai's Hebrew has od achat, "yet one") and calls it a promise: "now he has promised, 'I will once more shake not only the earth but heaven too'" (Hebrews 12:26; Greek epēngeltai, "he has promised"). Then it explains the word: "this phrase 'once more' indicates the removal of what is shaken" (12:27). Hebrews does not name Haggai, and its wording is not Haggai's (Haggai has "once again shake the sky and the earth"). The tie is the word of promising, "he has promised": the nearness rule counts a later text's word of saying or promising as a tie, and the same rule says it does not decide whether Hebrews 12:26 is the same promise as Haggai 2:6. I read it as the same promise. On that reading, long after "a little while" (how long, by the scholarship dates below), the shaking is still a promise ahead.
  • Isaiah 13:6 with 13:1, 13:17 and Daniel 5:30-31. "Wail, for the Lord's day of judgment is near" (Isaiah 13:6; Hebrew qarov, "near"). The text ties it to Babylon: it is "an oracle about Babylon that Isaiah son of Amoz saw" (13:1), and in the same oracle God says, "I am stirring up the Medes to attack them" (13:17). Isaiah's messages came in the reigns of Uzziah, Jotham, Ahaz and Hezekiah (Isaiah 1:1). Daniel records Babylon's end: "that very night Belshazzar, the Babylonian king, was killed. So Darius the Mede took control of the kingdom" (Daniel 5:30-31). That Daniel's night is the day Isaiah called near is my reading, from the names the two texts share: the Chaldeans (Isaiah 13:19; Daniel 5:30) and the Medes (Isaiah 13:17; Daniel 5:31). Isaiah names "the Chaldeans" (Isaiah 13:19; Hebrew kasdim) and "the Medes" (Isaiah 13:17; Hebrew madai). Daniel has "the Babylonian king" (Daniel 5:30) in the NET, where the Aramaic word is kasdaah, "Chaldeans", and "Darius the Mede" (Daniel 5:31; Aramaic madaah).
  • Jeremiah 51:33 with 51:59-64. "The time for her to be cut down and harvested will come very soon" (Jeremiah 51:33; Hebrew od me'at, "yet a little"). I read it as part of the scroll's prophecies: "Jeremiah recorded on one scroll all the judgments that would come upon Babylon—all these prophecies written about Babylon" (51:60). He sent it in "the fourth year" of King Zedekiah (51:59), to be read aloud in Babylon and thrown into the Euphrates with the words, "In the same way Babylon will sink and never rise again" (51:64). That the time Jeremiah called "very soon" is Babylon's fall, which Daniel records (Daniel 5:30-31), is my reading, from the scroll's words against Babylon.
  • Dates, as scholarship (not the text):
  • Haggai's "second year" of King Darius (Haggai 1:1, 1:15) is about 520 BC.
  • Hebrews is about AD 63-64 if early, or AD 70-100 if late. So the shaking was still a promise about 580 to 620 years after Haggai.
  • Hezekiah's reign ended about 687 BC, and Babylon fell in 539 BC: about 150 years or more after Isaiah 13:6.
  • Zedekiah's fourth year is about 594/593 BC: about 55 years before Babylon fell.
  • In fairness, near-words also stand before short waits.
  • In Gethsemane (Matthew 26:36) Jesus said, "Look, the hour is approaching, and the Son of Man is betrayed into the hands of sinners" (26:45; Greek ēngiken hē hōra, "the hour has drawn near"). "While he was still speaking, Judas, one of the twelve, arrived" (26:47), and "they came and took hold of Jesus and arrested him" (26:50). Here the near-word and the event stand in one scene, told by the narrator: Judas arrives while Jesus is still speaking. The nearness rule names exactly this, in its own words, as "an event the text tells as arriving while the word is being spoken", one of the few things that can add a length or a bound to a near-word. It is not one of the rule's ties between a saying and another text. Earlier, on "the first day of the feast of Unleavened Bread" (26:17), Jesus had sent a message to a man in the city: "My time is near" (26:18; Greek ho kairos mou engus). That evening he ate the Passover with the twelve (26:20) and told Peter, "on this night, before the rooster crows, you will deny me three times" (26:34). That the "time" of 26:18 is the hour of 26:45 is my reading: 26:18 is a message for a man in the city, and its word is kairos, "time", not hōra, "hour".
  • Ezekiel said "the day is near" (Ezekiel 7:7) to "the land of Israel" (7:2). That message is not dated ("The Lord's message came to me", 7:1); it stands in the book before his "sixth year" (8:1). The news "The city has been defeated!" reached him in "the twelfth year of our exile" (33:21). The year numbers are Ezekiel's own. A wait of six years or more is my reading, and the order of the book is the only reason for it: the message of 7:7 is undated, and an undated message's place in the book is not a date. That the day of 7:7 is the fall reported in 33:21 is my reading too.
  • So Scripture has both kinds.

That is the point: a near-word by itself does not tell you how long; the length has to come from somewhere else in the text. That is Rule 7: near-words set no length. In Scripture's own cases a near-word stands before a wait of hours or of years, and, by the scholarship dates in the note above, of centuries. Peter adds how the Lord counts time: "a single day is like a thousand years with the Lord and a thousand years are like a single day" (2 Peter 3:8). That verse is not a near-word; it says how the Lord reckons days and years.

  1. Matthew 24 as one event, with 24:30 in AD 70. Not shown. 24:30 is seen, comes with trumpet, angels and the gathering of the elect, and matches Acts 1:11. I read a turn at 24:36, from three marks together (point 8). At the place where Matthew says "Immediately after the suffering of those days" (24:29) and Mark says "in those days, after that suffering" (Mark 13:24), Luke puts "Jerusalem will be trampled down by the Gentiles until the times of the Gentiles are fulfilled" (Luke 21:24) between "those days" and the signs. Whether Luke's "until" carries into Matthew's account is not shown. The text does not say where the break falls, so my side's reading is not proven either.
  2. "All these things" including the coming and the resurrection. Not shown. In 24:33, "all these things" are signs pointing to something else that is near.
  3. This age ended in AD 70. Not shown. Jesus says of "those who are regarded as worthy to share in that age and in the resurrection from the dead" that "they can no longer die" (Luke 20:35-36). The verse does not say when this age ends, and the ages rule (each "age" word is read by the words printed in its own verse) does not decide that either. My step from it runs through what we see: people still die. That is an observation, not a rule result, as in need 2.
  4. The temple's fall being Christ's coming. Not shown. No verse says so.
  5. Paul expecting to be alive at the coming. Not shown. Paul says "we" both of those alive at the coming, "we who are alive, who are left until the coming of the Lord" (1 Thessalonians 4:15), and of those who will be raised: "Now God indeed raised the Lord and he will raise us by his power" (1 Corinthians 6:14); "the one who raised up Jesus will also raise us up with Jesus" (2 Corinthians 4:14). In both, the Greek verb is future, "he will raise" (exegerei; egerei), with "us" (hēmas, first person plural), in every edition the STEP data lists. As I read it, the "we" of these two verses is said of those who will be raised, Paul among them. So "we" by itself does not show that Paul expected to be alive at the coming.

One point I grant: "this generation" means the people alive when Jesus spoke. My answer is about what "all these things" covers and where Jesus turns to "that day".

What the fully-fulfilled view would raise, and my answer

I named the vindication reading as the strongest reading of Matthew 24:30. Here are the strongest other texts the fully-fulfilled view brings, in the NET's words, with what that view uses each one for and my answer.

  • Matthew 16:28. "there are some standing here who will not experience death before they see the Son of Man coming in his kingdom." Their use: some of Jesus' hearers would live to see his coming, so it came in their lifetime. My answer: Matthew dates the next thing he tells: "Six days later Jesus took with him Peter, James, and John ... And he was transfigured before them. His face shone like the sun" (17:1-2). I read 16:28 as pointing to that: some of those standing there saw him in his glory within the week. Counting the six days from 16:28 is my reading too: Matthew prints no anchor for "Six days later", and he tells it after the sayings of 16:24-28. The chapter number between the two is not Matthew's. Matthew does not write "this fulfilled it", so that is my reading. The words just before speak of the Son of Man coming "with his angels in the glory of his Father" to "reward each person according to what he has done" (16:27). Which of the two 16:28 points to, the text does not say: not shown either way. The rules apply to my side too, so here is what the other branch gives. 16:28 prints no near-word. But the nearness rule (only a few things can give a saying a length or a limit, and one is a span measured by a death) takes "some standing here who will not experience death before they see" as such a span: whatever 16:28 names is seen before all of those standing there have died. The same rule does not say which event a saying names. So if 16:28 points to the coming of 16:27, that coming falls within the lifetime of some who stood there; if it points to the transfiguration, it came six days later. I read it as the transfiguration; that is my reading, not the text's words.
  • Matthew 23:36. "I tell you the truth, this generation will be held responsible for all these things!" (Greek hēxei tauta panta epi tēn genean tautēn, "all these things will come upon this generation"). Their use: the same "all these things" and "this generation" come again in 24:34, so everything in Matthew 24 came on that generation. My answer: I grant "this generation": it means the people alive when Jesus spoke. I read "all these things" here as the blood of the verse just before: "on you will come all the righteous blood shed on earth, from the blood of righteous Abel to the blood of Zechariah" (23:35). The verse does not say "these things are" that blood, and no rule fixes what "these" covers, so that is my reading. On it, 23:36 is judgment for the blood of the prophets, and I read it as having come on that generation. Jesus goes straight on to Jerusalem: "Look, your house is left to you desolate!" (23:38), and then to the temple: "not one stone will be left on another" (24:2). But in the same breath he says, "you will not see me from now until you say, 'Blessed is the one who comes in the name of the Lord!'" (23:39; Greek ap' arti heōs an, "from now until"). I read that as a seeing of Jesus still ahead, after the house is left desolate. 23:36 names the judgment; it does not name the coming on the clouds or the raising of the dead. And 23:36 and 24:34 are said in different places to different hearers ("to the crowds and to his disciples", 23:1; "privately" on the Mount of Olives, 24:3). In the NA28 text the Greek words also stand in a different order (tauta panta in 23:36, panta tauta in 24:34), but the local STEP data marks a different place for them in 23:36 in the Tyndale House, Tregelles and Byzantine texts, so I rest nothing on the order. Shared words alone do not join two passages (Rule 2), on either side, so whether 24:34's "all these things" is the same list is not shown either way.
  • Luke 13:35. "you will not see me until you say, 'Blessed is the one who comes in the name of the Lord!'" (Luke 13:35). Their use: Luke has this before Jesus reaches Jerusalem, where his disciples cry "Blessed is the king who comes in the name of the Lord!" (Luke 19:38), so it may be met there, not at a coming still ahead. My answer: in Luke it was said to Jerusalem (13:34) and cried by "the whole crowd of his disciples" (Luke 19:37); whether it was met there is not shown, and I rest nothing on Luke. Matthew, which I quote, has the other order: the crowds shout "Blessed is the one who comes in the name of the Lord!" (Matthew 21:9) as he enters the city, and later Jesus says "you will not see me from now until you say" (Matthew 23:39; Greek ap' arti, "from now"). So in Matthew the seeing is still ahead when he speaks. The verse gives no date; that it is his return is my reading.
  • 1 John 2:18. "Children, it is the last hour ... so now many antichrists have appeared. We know from this that it is the last hour." Their use: John's readers stood at the very end, so the end came in their time. My answer: the verse says "it is the last hour" (Greek eschatē hōra), and it gives John's own sign for it: "many antichrists have appeared". It does not say that Christ has come, and it does not say how long the hour lasts. In the same letter, John still looks ahead: "remain in him, so that when he appears we may have confidence and not shrink away from him in shame when he comes back" (2:28; Greek en tē parousia autou, "at his coming"), and "whenever it is revealed we will be like him, because we will see him just as he is" (3:2). So John wrote in "the last hour" and still waited for Christ to appear.
  • James 5:8 and 1 Peter 4:7. "the Lord's return is near" (James 5:8; Greek hē parousia tou kuriou ēngiken, "the coming of the Lord has drawn near"); "the culmination of all things is near" (1 Peter 4:7; Greek pantōn de to telos ēngiken, "the end of all things has drawn near"). Their use: "near" means within a few years. My answer: need 6: a near-word by itself gives no length. James himself tells his readers to wait like a farmer: "be patient, brothers and sisters, until the Lord's return. Think of how the farmer waits for the precious fruit of the ground and is patient for it until it receives the early and late rains" (James 5:7).
  • John 5:25. "a time is coming—and is now here—when the dead will hear the voice of the Son of God, and those who hear will live." Their use: the resurrection was already under way when Jesus spoke, so it is spiritual, not bodily. My answer: John 5:25 does speak of a raising that was "now here", and the words just before explain it: the one who believes "has crossed over from death to life" (5:24). But Jesus goes straight on to a second raising: "a time is coming when all who are in the tombs will hear his voice and will come out" (5:28-29). There is no "and is now here" this time, and the dead are "in the tombs" (Greek en tois mnēmeiois). So John 5 has both: a raising now, by faith, and a raising from the tombs, still to come. I read Paul as tying death's defeat to that second kind; joining John 5 to 1 Corinthians 15 is my reading, because they are different books, and shared words alone do not join them. Paul writes, "when ... this mortal puts on immortality, then the saying that is written will happen, 'Death has been swallowed up in victory'" (1 Corinthians 15:54). His own "when ... then" joins the two in one sentence, and two things are one occasion when the text itself joins them that way (Rule 4). And "mortal" is the physical body in all six places Paul uses it (Rule 11). A raising by faith does not meet that.
  • Genesis 2:17. "when you eat from it you will surely die" (Genesis 2:17). Their use: Adam's body did not die that day, so the death "in Adam" was covenantal. My answer: Genesis does not say his body died that day. The Hebrew "in the day" (beyom) is the phrase the same account uses for a making that Genesis tells over six days (Genesis 2:4); the NET gives "when" in both, and so I read it. God then quotes his command, "You must not eat from it" (Genesis 3:17; the same Hebrew words as 2:17), and names the sentence in the body's own words: "until you return to the ground ... for you are dust, and to dust you will return" (Genesis 3:19). "The entire lifetime of Adam was 930 years, and then he died" (Genesis 5:5; the Hebrew verb of 2:17, mut). That the death of 2:17 is this return to dust is my reading, and none of this shows the penalty was only bodily. Paul ties death to Adam: "death through sin" (Romans 5:12); "in Adam all die" (1 Corinthians 15:22). In the same chapter Paul uses the same Greek verb for "Christ died for our sins ... and that he was buried" (1 Corinthians 15:3-4); that the "die" of 15:22 is that kind of dying is my reading, from the run of the chapter.
  • 1 Corinthians 10:11. "These things happened to them as examples and were written for our instruction, on whom the ends of the ages have come." Their use: Paul's readers stood at the end of the ages, so the end came in their lifetime, in AD 70. My answer: Paul's verb is katēntēken, "have come", already: the ends of the ages had reached his readers when he wrote. So the phrase itself does not point to AD 70. Hebrews speaks the same way of Christ's first coming: "now he has appeared once for all at the consummation of the ages to put away sin by his sacrifice" (Hebrews 9:26; Greek epi sunteleia tōn aiōnōn), and in the next breath, "he will appear a second time, not to bear sin but to bring salvation" (9:28). The Greek words differ (telē in 1 Corinthians, sunteleia in Hebrews), so I do not join the two verses as one event. I show only that the New Testament speaks of the end of the ages as already come with Christ's first coming, with his second appearing still ahead. Paul's own letter fits that: his readers "wait for the revelation of our Lord Jesus Christ" (1 Corinthians 1:7), and "then when Christ comes, those who belong to him" (15:23). In 1 Corinthians the ends of the ages had come, and the coming was still ahead.
  • Daniel 12:7. "It is for a time, times, and half a time. Then, when the power of the one who shatters the holy people has been exhausted, all these things will be finished." Their use: the holy people's power was shattered in AD 70, and "all these things" include the raising of 12:2, so the resurrection was finished then. My answer: the Hebrew has no separate word for "the one who". Word for word it says "and when the shattering of the power of the holy people is finished, all these will be finished" (ukhekhallot nappets yad-am-qodesh tikhleynah khol-elleh; yad is "hand", used for power). So the verse ties "all these things" to "a time, times, and half a time" and to the end of a shattering of the holy people's power. It does not name the year or the one who shatters, and it does not list what "all these things" are; the question just before asks, "When will the end of these wondrous events occur?" (12:6). Whether that shattering is AD 70, and whether "all these things" include 12:2, the verse does not say: not shown either way. What 12:2 and 12:13 add: those who awake are "those who sleep in the dusty ground" (12:2; Hebrew admat-afar, "the ground of dust"), a physical cue like the ones at the start of this argument. And Daniel himself is told, "You will rest and then at the end of the days you will arise to receive what you have been allotted" (12:13; Hebrew tanuach, "you will rest", and ta'amod, "you will stand"). That his arising is out of the dust is my reading: the "dusty ground" is said of the "many" of 12:2, and 12:13, said to Daniel in a later answer (12:8-9), prints neither "dust" nor 12:2's "will awake" (Hebrew yakitsu). 12:13's own words carry the point: "You will rest" and "you will arise" are said to Daniel himself, so the raising he is promised is his own. No record shows that in AD 70 (point 5).
  • Revelation 20:4-6. "They came to life and reigned with Christ for a thousand years. (The rest of the dead did not come to life until the thousand years were finished.) This is the first resurrection." Their use: the first resurrection is spiritual, or it came in AD 70. My answer: whatever the first resurrection is, Revelation itself ties things to the finishing of the thousand years, with time words of its own: "The rest of the dead did not come to life until the thousand years were finished" (20:5; Greek achri telesthē, "until ... are finished"), and "when the thousand years are finished, Satan will be released" (20:7; Greek hotan telesthē, "when ... are finished"). Later in the book come the sea, Death and Hades giving up their dead (20:13) and "death will not exist any more" (21:4). The Greek joins those with a plain "and", so placing them after the thousand years is my reading of the order the book gives them. So, on its own time words, the book ties at least two things to the finishing of the thousand years: it does not put the rest of the dead coming to life before the finishing ("until", 20:5), and it puts Satan's release no earlier than the finishing ("when", 20:7). Rule 9, in its own words: "A book cannot call 'soon' what it places after its own long wait" (it names Revelation 1:1 and 22:6 against 20:3 and 20:7). Its own wording needs the wait to be long. So it bears on Revelation's "what must happen very soon" (1:1; 22:6; Greek en tachei) only if the thousand years are a long wait, and whether they are is not fixed: a thousand years can mean a long span ("in your eyes a thousand years are like yesterday", Psalm 90:4; "a thousand years are like a single day", 2 Peter 3:8), but "can" does not fix the length in Revelation 20 (Rule 10). The rules stop there, and I do not claim the condition is met. And whether Revelation's "soon" says when or how is not decided either: the nearness rule says the word sources allow both. When the thousand years begin, no rule says (that is Rule 9's own limit), and I do not claim to know: not shown either way.

Dates and Sources

Dates and sources used

Dates (all of these are scholarship, not the text):

  • Domitian: Eusebius says he reigned fifteen years after Titus, which is AD 81-96 by the standard dating.
  • The temple's fall: Josephus dates it to "the second year of the reign of Vespasian", which is AD 70.
  • Revelation: the date is open. Irenaeus says the end of Domitian's reign (about AD 95-96); others say before AD 70.
  • Writers:
  • Irenaeus: about AD 180.
  • Polycarp: early 100s.
  • Tertullian: about AD 200-210.
  • 2 Peter: disputed.
  • Old Testament dates in need 6:
  • Haggai's "second year" of Darius: about 520 BC.
  • Hezekiah's reign ending: about 687 BC.
  • Babylon's fall: 539 BC.
  • Zedekiah's fourth year: about 594/593 BC.
  • Hebrews: about AD 63-64 if early, AD 70-100 if late.
  • Ezekiel (neither scholarship nor the text's own count): the year numbers, the sixth and the twelfth, are his own; "six years or more" is my reading from the order of the book only, because the message at 7:1 is undated and an undated message's place in the book is not a date (Ezekiel 7:1; 8:1; 33:21).

Matthew 24:36, the wording: the NET prints it without "nor the Son"; the Greek text (NA28) has "nor the Son" (oude ho huios), which STEP lists for NA28, NA27, Tyndale House, SBL and Westcott-Hort, not for Tregelles, the Textus Receptus or the Byzantine text. The quote in point 8 is the NET.

Early Christian writers and creeds:

  • The Didache (Teaching of the Twelve Apostles), ch. 16, tr. M. B. Riddle, in Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 7, ed. A. Roberts, J. Donaldson and A. C. Coxe (Buffalo: Christian Literature Publishing Co.). https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/0714.htm
  • Irenaeus, Against Heresies, bk 5, ch. 30, sec. 4, tr. A. Roberts and W. Rambaut, in Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 1. https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/0103530.htm
  • Tertullian, On the Resurrection of the Flesh, ch. 22, tr. P. Holmes, in Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 3. https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/0316.htm
  • Polycarp, Epistle to the Philippians, ch. 2, tr. A. Roberts and J. Donaldson, in Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 1. https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/0136.htm
  • The Apostles' Creed, English form in Philip Schaff, The Creeds of Christendom (Christian Classics Ethereal Library). https://www.ccel.org/creeds/apostles.creed.html
  • Eusebius, Church History, bk 3 (chs. 5, 7, 17-18, 20, 23, 26, 39), tr. A. C. McGiffert, in Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 1, ed. P. Schaff and H. Wace (Buffalo: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1890). https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/250103.htm. The Greek of Irenaeus quoted by Eusebius (3.18.3; 5.8.6-7) is from the Greek text of Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History, ed. K. Lake and J. E. L. Oulton (First1KGreek edition).
  • Cyril of Jerusalem, Catechetical Lectures, Lecture 15, secs. 10, 20 and 22, tr. E. H. Gifford, in Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 7, ed. P. Schaff and H. Wace (1894). https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/310115.htm
  • John Chrysostom, Homilies on the Gospel of Matthew, Homily 76, secs. 2-4, tr. G. Prevost, rev. M. B. Riddle, in Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 1st series, vol. 10. https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/200176.htm
  • Catechism of the Catholic Church, paras. 668-677 and 1038-1041 (Libreria Editrice Vaticana). https://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG0015/__P1V.HTM and https://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG0015/__P2P.HTM

Historians of the war:

  • Josephus, The Wars of the Jews, bk 6, ch. 4 (the temple's burning and its date) and ch. 5, sec. 3 (the signs), tr. William Whiston (Project Gutenberg ebook 2850). https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/2850
  • Josephus, Antiquities of the Jews, tr. William Whiston (Project Gutenberg ebook 2848). https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/2848
  • Tacitus, The Histories, bk 5, ch. 13, tr. W. Hamilton Fyfe (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1912), Project Gutenberg ebook 16927. https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/16927

Scholars:

  • R. T. France, The Gospel of Matthew, New International Commentary on the New Testament (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2007), comments on Matthew 24:30 and 24:36. Excerpt: https://www.harvestherald.com/sop/rtfrancematt24.html
  • Kenneth L. Gentry Jr., "The Sign of the Son of Man (1)", Postmillennial Worldview, 16 November 2016. https://postmillennialworldview.com/2016/11/16/the-sign-of-the-son-of-man-1/
  • N. T. Wright, "Farewell to the Rapture", Bible Review 17:4 (August 2001). https://ntwrightpage.com/2016/07/12/farewell-to-the-rapture/
  • D. A. Carson, "The Olivet Discourse, part 3 (Matthew 24-25)", sermon, The Gospel Coalition. https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/sermon/the-olivet-discourse-matthew-24-25-part-3/

The Bible and its words:

  • Bible quotations: the NET Bible, Second Edition.
  • Greek, Hebrew and Aramaic words: STEP Bible data (Tyndale House, Cambridge; www.STEPBible.org), CC BY 4.0.
  • The physical cues in the opening come from a search of the NET text of 1 Corinthians 15:20-28 and 15:35-58, Revelation 20:11-21:8 and 2 Peter 3:3-13. "No marker found" means none was found in those passages.
  • Chapter and verse numbers are used in this argument only to point to places. They were added to the text long after it was written, so they are not treated as joining or separating anything.

Which rule is used where (the conclusions follow from each rule's wording, not from its status):

  • Rule 1 (cloud language alone decides nothing): "His return will be seen" and point 8.
  • Rule 2 (shared words alone do not join passages): points 1 (Matthew 5:18), 5 and 8, the answer on Matthew 23:36, and the 2 Thessalonians section ("One letter, one Lord, one coming").
  • Rule 4 (two things are one occasion only when the text joins them, as in "when ... then"): 1 Corinthians 15:54, in the answer on John 5:25.
  • Rule 7 (near-words set no length): heading 1 (Hebrews 8:13), point 7, need 6, and the answer on James 5:8 and 1 Peter 4:7.
  • Rule 9 (a book cannot call "soon" what it places after its own long wait; its own limit is that no rule says when the thousand years begin): the answer on Revelation 20:4-6.
  • Rule 10 (a thousand years can mean a long span, but "can" does not fix the length in Revelation 20): the answer on Revelation 20:4-6.
  • Rule 11 ("mortal" is the physical body): the opening, point 5, needs 1 and 2, and the answer on John 5:25.
  • Rule 12 (dated words need a record that they were met): point 8, on 24:33-34, for my reading as for theirs.
  • Rule G ("this generation" is the people alive then): the point granted at the end.
  • The nearness rule (a near-word by itself gives no length; only a few things can add one, such as a span measured by a death, an event told as arriving while the word is spoken, or a later text's word of promising; it does not say which event a saying names): the answer on Matthew 16:28, need 6 (Haggai with Hebrews; Matthew 26:45-47), and the answer on Revelation 20:4-6 (whether "soon" says when or how).
  • The ages rule (each "age" word is read by the words printed in its own verse; it does not decide when this age starts or ends): need 9.