Where the Dividing Line Falls in the Olivet Discourse, and What Holds It There
Why this reading and not the other
The rival reading says the end of the age in 24:3 is AD 70. It then has two options for 25:31-46, and both fail. If the passage is first century, the dated words would call for a recorded judgment of all nations with eternal outcomes, and no such record exists. It would also contradict the final judgment, which Scripture holds ahead in other places. If the passage is left Open, there is no dividing line at all.
The reading at 25:31 does not conflict with any of the author’s inputs, and it leaves the fewest passages Open. It also treats 24:36 and 25:31 by one rule. The word “For” joins 24:36 to the dated coming, so no second coming begins there. Nothing joins or dates 25:31, so a second, future coming can begin there. Same rule, two results.

