Chapter Eight: One People or Two (2 of 2)

Ephesians 2:11–16 describes the reconciling of Jew and Gentile into “one new man”—not two peoples maintained in distinction, but one people created from the two. The dividing wall has been broken down. The hostility has been abolished. In Christ, access to the Father is through one Spirit, for both. The dispensational engagement with these texts is more sophisticated than a simple dismissal. Scofield’s own note at Ephesians 3:6 explicitly grants the point: the mystery hidden in God was the divine purpose to make of Jew and Gentile a wholly new thing—the church, which is his body—in which the earthly distinction of Jew and Gentile disappears. He does not suppress the unification. He contains it. The church is a new organism, a third entity, a parenthetical creation in which old distinctions are suspended. Israel’s national program continues outside that parenthesis. The containment is coherent on its own terms. It fails at the olive tree. A new organism requires a new root. Paul’s image in Romans 11 is not a new planting. It is the gardener working the same ancient tree. The Gentile is grafted in—not planted in new ground, but incorporated into the root that has been there since Abraham. Scofield’s containment requires a new tree. Paul gives you the old one.

Dispensationalists often point to Ephesians 3:1–6 as their strongest evidence for the church as a parenthesis: the church was a mystery hidden from Old Testament prophets, which means Daniel’s prophetic timeline runs on a separate Jewish track and the church age is an interruption. Scofield’s own note at Ephesians 3:6 concedes the key point: the mystery was “the divine purpose to make of Jew and Gentile a wholly new thing—the church, which is his body—in which the earthly distinction of Jew and Gentile disappears.” He grants the unity. The question is what the unity means: a parenthetical organism alongside a continuing Jewish program, or the disclosure of the full scope of one plan. Paul answers directly: the content of the mystery is that the Gentiles are fellow heirs, members of the same body, and partakers of the promise in Christ Jesus through the gospel (Ephesians 3:6). The Gentiles are heirs of the promise—the same promise Paul has already described as belonging to everyone in Christ, Jew or Gentile, because all are Abraham’s descendants (Galatians 3:29). A mystery previously hidden does not require its fulfillment to be a parenthesis in a different plan. It means the plan was more inclusive than earlier revelation had shown. The hiddenness is evidence of one program whose scope exceeded what the prophets had fully seen. Not two programs. One.

The stakes here are not merely academic. A theological framework that maintains two permanent peoples of God—with different promises, different destinies, and different modes of relating to the covenant—has real consequences for how the church understands its own identity, its relationship to the Hebrew Scriptures, and its mission in the world. A church that is a parenthesis in someone else’s story is a church that cannot fully inhabit its own.

One clarification belongs here. The argument of this chapter is not that Paul’s one-body theology dissolves every covenantal distinction between Israel and the nations. Romans 11 is explicit: God’s gifts and calling to Israel are irrevocable, the natural branches carry the promise of being grafted in again, and ethnic Israel retains a particularity that Paul refuses to spiritualize away. The argument is narrower than that. The dispensational two-peoples system—which assigns Israel and the church to parallel redemptive tracks with separate destinies, different promises, and a church-age parenthesis between them—cannot be sustained from Paul. Rejecting that system is not the same as claiming God is finished with the Jewish people. The former is a conclusion about a theological grid. The latter is a conclusion about God’s faithfulness. This volume affirms the latter and disputes the former. To be unambiguous: “the gifts and the calling of God are irrevocable” (Romans 11:29). The mystery Paul describes—a partial hardening until the full number of Gentiles comes in, and then the salvation of all Israel (Romans 11:25–26)—is not resolved by this volume and should not be flattened. The hope for ethnic Israel’s future is Paul’s hope, grounded in God’s own faithfulness, and it belongs in every honest reading of Romans 9–11.

————————