Michlaude Discipleship Project

The Rules List by Type, With Each Rule's Current Status

By Michael W Winslow ·

On this page (18 sections)
  1. 1. Conclusion (SOURCED, counted from the v18 tables)
  2. 2. The rules, by type (SOURCED)
    1. A. Olivet v7 rules (Rules 1 to 13 and G)
    2. B. Cross-book rules (CB1 to CB6)
    3. C. Witness rules (W1 to W4)
    4. D. The dating-word list (carried by Rule 6)
    5. E. Nearness (N1, N2, N3, R7a to R7c)
    6. F. Same-saying
    7. G. The death-sense rule v5
    8. H. The full-preterism test rules (FT1 to FT8 and the lettered wordings)
    9. I. Round 1 and Round 2 test wordings (not recorded as rules in v18)
    10. J. The nine Beta 3 Proposed wordings and the Terms block
  3. 3. Failed, retired or dropped (SOURCED)
  4. 4. What changes a status (SOURCED from v18's status table; the process wording is the record's)
  5. 5. Where it stands now (SOURCED)
  6. 6. Where the sources differ (SOURCED; v18's word used each time)
  7. 7. Grouping notes (the writer's judgment, labelled)
  8. 8. Notes: the rules behind each count (SOURCED)

Beta. This is a description of work in progress. It decides nothing, adopts nothing and changes no status. The author sets every status. 7 November 2026.

What this is. A list of every rule the project holds, grouped by type, with the status the record gives each one. It is built from version 18 of the author's rules reference (5 November 2026), which governs every wording and status here. It also uses the Beta 2 and Beta 3 prompts and the records of the outside-reader tests. Test findings are findings waiting on the author. They are never rulings. In this post, "v18" means that version of the rules reference.

How to read it. Status words are v18's words, copied as v18 gives them. Where v18 names the author inside a quoted cell, the cell says so. "Under review" is Beta 2's note and is shown beside the v18 status, never in place of it. The "What it says" column is a short summary. It is not the rule. The "Limit and basis" column carries the limit and the basis, in v18's words. "None stated" means v18 gives no word for that cell. Verse references are named only as the project's records name them. No verse text is quoted, and none was retrieved for this post, so each counts as RECALLED.

Test labels in the last column. R1 and R2 mean the outside-reader Round 1 and Round 2 (Round 2 ran 6 and 7 November). FTc1 and FTc2 mean the full-preterism convergence rounds 1 and 2 (5 November).

1. Conclusion (SOURCED, counted from the v18 tables)

v18 records 19 rules at Passed or Passed, limited: 11 at Passed (Rules 1, 2, 5, 7, 8, 11, G, CB3, W1, W2, W4) and 8 at Passed, limited (Rules 4, 6, 9, 10, 12, CB1, CB2, CB5). The dating-word list is also Passed, limited, and N3 passed with one reader and is not adopted. Four whole rules or tests are Failed (Rule 3, CB4, the v7 same-saying test, N1), one is Retired (Rule 13), and one is Untested (CB6). The death-sense rule v5 is Held as one rule. R7a to R7c is Working. v18 records three Proposed wordings (amended same-saying, FT5-A, FT6**), and Beta 3 adds nine more Proposed wordings that v18 does not record. FT2, FT7 and FT8 are Candidates. No FT3 wording has passed. The counts reconcile with Beta 2's summary (10 clean Passed plus 5 Passed, limited plus the 4 rules under review is 19), and the lists behind them are in section 8. No status in this brief is new.

2. The rules, by type (SOURCED)

A. Olivet v7 rules (Rules 1 to 13 and G)

RuleWhat it says (short summary)Status (v18)Limit and basisIn testing now
1. Picture languageSun, moon and shaking-heavens language is used for judgments on named places in history, so by itself it neither proves nor rules out a passage about the final events.PassedDoes not show what the language means in Matthew 24. Basis: Observed (Isaiah 13, 19:1; Ezekiel 32; Zephaniah 1)No
2. Wording alone is not enoughTwo passages with the same words are not shown to be one event by those words alone (descriptive wording, not proper names).PassedDoes not prove two passages are different events. Basis: ObservedNo
3. An answer is about what was askedAn answer that reuses a word from the question is about what the question asked.Failed (Luke 10:29 against 10:36; conflicts with Rule 2)Not used anywhere.No
4. A clear joining statementTwo things are one occasion only when the text joins them ("when... then," "together with"); a plain "then" joins nothing.Passed, limited (labeled forced; best held loosely)Binds within one sentence, not across chapters or books. Basis: Forced (labeled in v18)No
5. Citation formulaA citation points to one verse only if the quoted words occur in one place.PassedCompares words, not small grammar points.No
6. Time words read as writtenNo general rule fixes how far a deadline reaches; each time word is read in its own verse. It carries the dating-word list.Passed, limited (the method's default)Does not fix what "all these things" covers.No (the list it carries is in testing; see D)
7. Near-words cannot dateSoon, near and at hand are true but set no number of years and no limit.PassedCan never bind or exclude a passage. Basis: ObservedNo
8. A permanent end of death happens onceIf the text says death or decay is ended for good, that ending happens once.PassedOnly where the text states the ending is complete. Basis: Forced and logicNo
9. A book's "soon"A book cannot call "soon" what it places after its own long wait (Revelation 1:1, 22:6 against 20:3, 20:7).Passed, limited (conditional)No rule says when the thousand years begin.No
10. A thousand years can mean a long spanA thousand years can mean a long span (Psalm 90:4; 2 Peter 3:8; Ecclesiastes 6:6).Passed, limited (weak)"Can" does not fix the length in Revelation 20.No
11. "Mortal" means the physical bodyPaul's word for "mortal" (six uses, all Paul) means the physical body.PassedNo counter-case found. Basis: ObservedNo
12. The record ruleThe dated-words input needs a record; without an observed case from Scripture, a record is not shown to meet it.Passed, limited (a burden rule)The stronger form, that no other kind of record counts, fails.No
13. Matthew and Luke not shown to be one occasion (title only; v18 gives no definition)Not stated beyond its title.Retired in v7Replaced by CB1 to CB5.No
G. "This generation""This generation" means the people alive when the speaker spoke.PassedThe one rule that fixes the deadline. Basis: Observed (eleven NET references)No

B. Cross-book rules (CB1 to CB6)

RuleWhat it says (short summary)Status (v18)Limit and basisIn testing now
CB1. A parallel is a witnessA parallel account witnesses that a saying was said and what it said in substance; it does not fix the exact words or the occasion.Passed, limited (amended; first wording failed). Beta 2 note: under review.Never argue from one account's exact wording to another's.Yes (R1, R2). A Proposed wording, P-CB1, sits beside it.
CB2. Differences are not contradictionsThree explanations are open for a difference between accounts: rewording, repetition, arrangement.Passed, limited (in parts). Same-saying round one questioned whether "forced" holds for the rewording clause. Beta 2 note: under review.Never says which explanation applies. For sayings, arrangement is never forced.Yes (R2). A Proposed wording, P-CB2, sits beside it.
CB3. Placement shows no timeWhere an account places a saying does not show when it was said; a dating word or a stated occasion does.Passed (forced, for events). Beta 2 note: under review.Needs the dating-word list. Never shows a saying was not spoken where placed. Basis: Forced, for eventsYes (R1, R2). A Proposed wording, P-CB3, sits beside it.
CB4. Two accounts in one settingTwo accounts that put a saying in one setting count as spoken there.Failed. Dropped.None statedNo
CB5. No borrowing meaningOne account's wording or context does not fix another's meaning, unless the account marks its own gloss.Passed, limited (a burden rule, with a forced carve-out for one utterance). Beta 2 note: under review.The carve-out needs a same-saying test. Basis: Forced, for the carve-outYes (R2). A Proposed wording, P-CB5, sits beside it.
CB6. Later books show first-generation application (title only; v18 gives no definition)Not stated beyond its title.UntestedNone statedNo

C. Witness rules (W1 to W4)

RuleWhat it says (short summary)Status (v18)Limit and basisIn testing now
W1. Two or three witnessesIn a charge against a person, two or three agreeing witnesses are needed.PassedNot applied to events in history. A missing witness does not prove a claim false. Basis: ObservedNo
W2. Bodily acts have named witnessesWhen Scripture says God did a bodily act in history, it says who saw it.PassedNot always the public. The number varies. Never eyewitnesses alone. Basis: ObservedNo
W3. What witnesses decideWitnesses speak to what happened, not to links between passages or to which event a prophecy named.A limit, not a rule (v18's words; not one of the eight status words)None statedNo
W4. Answering an "already" claimScripture answers a claim that an awaited event has come by naming what must come with it and noting it has not come (2 Thessalonians 2:2-3).PassedCannot date anything. Basis: ObservedNo

D. The dating-word list (carried by Rule 6)

RuleWhat it says (short summary)Status (v18)Limit and basisIn testing now
Dating-word listIt sorts words into those that date relative to an anchor, terminus words that bound a period without dating its end, and connectives that date nothing. A set of items stays unclassified (the tote of Matthew 25:1, chronizontos in 25:5, "that day" in 24:36 as a date, Mark 13:35, Luke 21:22, eita and epeita, the crucifixion hour).Passed, limited. Beta 2 note: under review.Basis: Olivet entries rest on two sources and the rest on oneYes, through CB3 (R1, R2)

E. Nearness (N1, N2, N3, R7a to R7c)

RuleWhat it says (short summary)Status (v18)Limit and basisIn testing now
N1 (3 Nov)A nearness word places the event within the hearers' lifetime.Failed (Haggai 2:6 with Hebrews 12:26; Isaiah 13:6 is a weaker second case)None statedNo
N2 (3 Nov)A nearness word does not by itself place the event in the hearers' lifetime; only a stated span or a sign does.First sentence passes (observed). The second ("only a span or a sign") fails, because Scripture has other dating devices (a number, a date, "in your days," Ezekiel 12:25).Basis: Observed (first sentence)No
N3 (3 Nov)A nearness word says the event is near from the speaker's standpoint and calls the hearers to act; it sets no number of years.Passed, one reader, brief v1. Not adopted.None statedNo (owes a second reader and a cross-check)
R7a to R7c, nearness working wording (4 Nov)A nearness word alone gives no number of years and no upper limit; a length comes only from what is written with the word. R7b7 (a span stated elsewhere) is held.Working (confirmed by the author, 4 Nov). Not adopted.None statedNo

F. Same-saying

RuleWhat it says (short summary)Status (v18)Limit and basisIn testing now
Same-saying test (v7 wording)Two accounts are one saying when they share a run of distinctive elements in the same order and their differences fall inside the range of named cases.Failed in round one (one reader, 3 Nov)None statedNo
Same-saying, amended (3 Nov)Two accounts are one saying only when Scripture itself ties them; wording, order and size of differences never settle it.Proposed. One reader, thin retrieval, brief v1. Owes a v2 rerun and a cross-check.None statedNo (the rerun and cross-check are owed)

G. The death-sense rule v5

The whole rule is Held. v18: the author put a hold on changes on 4 November ("i think it is sufficient for the work it was intended"). There is no yes or no on the whole yet. Do not edit it. Every row below carries the v18 status Held. A revised version (v6) is in preparation; v5 itself is untouched.

RuleWhat it says (short summary)Status (v18)Limit and basisIn testing now
Death-sense rule v5, as a wholeIt sorts uses of the words die, dead and death by seven signs found in the original text.HeldIt does not say what condition anyone is in before God, or what happens after the body dies.No (a revised v6 is in preparation; reader tests on it are not sent)
Definitions and tests (Parts 2 and 3)A closed death-word list; a sign must be in the Hebrew or Greek; rules for where a sign may sit and whose words count.Held. The death-word list, where a sign may sit, and whose words count are marked the author's decision.Same as aboveNo
Sign 1. Relation phraseA phrase saying how a person stands toward someone or something (died to sin; made alive with Christ) is written "Relational."Held. The 2 Corinthians 5:14 wording still awaits the author's confirmation.Gives no finding on the body either way (CHOICE 1, option A).No
Sign 2. Same person shown aliveWhere the text shows the same person living while a death-word is said of him, write "Not a completed bodily death."Held (OPEN M, OPEN O decided)Known gap: another person who is alive only when the sentence is spoken.No
Sign 3. Told facts about the bodyTold facts (age at death, burial, body gets up, struck down) are written "Bodily death."Held. John 5:28 "in the tombs" is a told fact about bodies by the author's decision.Not inside a relation phrase.No
Sign 4. What a use is tied toA use takes the kind found on the word it is tied to, by a remark in the same text, a later text, or a same-word saying in one exchange.Held. 4(b) at 1 Corinthians 15:54 is unfinished, with no label. 4(c) clause (2) was found false of John 11:21-27 (passes in part, first reader, 4 Nov); a fix is pending the author's choice.None statedNo (the fix is part of the v6 work)
Sign 5. Dead and not deadWhere the text says the same person at the same time is dead and not dead, the two uses differ (John 11:26: "Not that bodily death").HeldNone statedNo
Sign 6. Not a bodyWhere the thing called dead is not a person or creature (faith, sin, works, the law), write "Not bodily."HeldNone statedNo
Sign 7. One Hebrew spellingHebrew met is used both ways; this is a caution only, with no label of its own.Held (reworded 4 Nov)None statedNo
Parts 7 to 9. When signs meet or fail, and the labelsIdentification outranks imagery; Sign 2 beats Sign 3; other conflicts print "two signs disagree"; where no sign fits, write "the text does not tell."Held (CHOICE 2 for Sign 2 over Sign 3)None statedNo

H. The full-preterism test rules (FT1 to FT8 and the lettered wordings)

RuleWhat it says (short summary)Status (v18)Limit and basisIn testing now
FT1. What counts as Jesus's prophecyScope C: Jesus in the Gospels and Acts 1, the risen Jesus in Revelation, and apostolic words marked as from the Lord.Defined by the author (not one of the eight status words)None statedNo
Test frame: six verdict points, verdicts V1 to V3, barred inputsA case falsifies the claim only if all six points hold; the barred inputs are kept out.Fixed in advance (not one of the eight status words)None statedNo
FT2. The stated conditionA prophecy is fulfilled when what its printed words state comes to pass; a reading that changes the condition carries the burden.Candidate, untestedNone statedNo
FT3, original candidateA reading of death, tomb and raising words other than the body is shown only by a printed mark.Passes in part (first reader). v18: no FT3 wording has passed.None statedNo
FT3-AThe first reader's amendment of FT3.ReplacedNone statedNo
FT3-BThe first reader's repair of FT3.Passes in part (first reader, second pass), then fails (cross-check reader)None statedNo
FT3-CThe cross-check reader's repair of FT3.Fails on 1 Corinthians 15:3-5 (project check)None statedNo
FT4. Completeness ("all," "every," "no longer")"All" means every member of the named set unless a limit is printed.Passes in part (first reader)The default in clause 1 fails on Exodus 9:6.No
FT5. The reader's amendment of FT4"All" reaches only as far as the named set; how far inside it is shown only by a printed limit, counter-instance or check.Fails (cross-check reader, 5 Nov): opposite outputs at Hebrews 2:8; Genesis 42:13; Romans 3:10 with Luke 1:6None statedNo
FT5-A (cross-check reader's amendment of FT5)Adds that only Scripture's own voice counts, with rules for removals, printed inclusion and printed time.Proposed, one reader. Not cross-checked (Part 5). Part 12: FTc1 not converged; both readers "passes in part"; amendments FT5-A.1 (cross-check reader) and FT5-B (first reader) proposed.None statedNo (FTc1 done)
FT5-CA merge of FT5-A.1 and FT5-B by the project, tagged by source.Round 2: breaks (first reader 0/2/0; cross-check reader 1/7/0)None statedNo (FTc2 done)
FT5-DA merge of the two FTc2 amendments of FT5-C.Draft. Waits for the author's go.None statedNo
FT6. "All that is written"Is "all that is written" bounded by the subject its sentence names, or by the matter its setting names?Passes in part (first reader)The ceiling holds; the floor fails (Acts 13:29 with 13:30-35, forced). Luke 21:22: not decidable from its own text.No
FT6* (reader's amendment of FT6)A phrase does not reach past a subject its sentence names; with no named subject, the reach is at most the matter in the same sentence.Passes in part (cross-check reader, 5 Nov)Clause 3 fails; the scope line mis-sorts obedience uses of fulfil verbs. Basis: Clauses 1, 2 and 4 observedNo
FT6** (cross-check reader's amendment of FT6*)Scope by sense, not verb; clauses 1, 2 and 4 kept; clause 3 split into 3(a) and 3(b).Proposed, one reader. Not cross-checked (Part 5). Part 12: FTc1 not converged; both readers "passes in part"; each amendment labeled FT6**-A.3(a) rests on one case (John 19:28).No (FTc1 done)
FT6***A merge of the two readers' amendments of FT6** by the project, tagged.Round 2: breaks (first reader 0/2/1; cross-check reader 0/2/1)None statedNo (FTc2 done)
FT6-DA merge of the two FTc2 amendments of FT6***.Draft. Waits for the author's go.None statedNo
FT7. Raising with two outcomesA positive form of an earlier finding about raising language paired with opposite lasting outcomes.Candidate, untestedNone statedNo
FT8. Two kinds of raisingRe-animation against resurrection (cannot die again); v18 calls it the author's conviction, kept as his.Candidate, untestedNone statedNo

Part 14 of v18 records two changes proposed before round 3 and one ruling for the author (one test for whose words count: options i, ii or iii). Those are open and are the author's.

I. Round 1 and Round 2 test wordings (not recorded as rules in v18)

v18 does not record these. They have no status in v18. The "What it says" cells use the Round 2 wording as Beta 3 quotes it.

WordingWhat it says (short summary)Status (v18)Limit and basisIn testing now
CB7. Setting facts do not date fulfillmentFacts about a saying's setting show where and to whom it was said, not when it is fulfilled.None in v18None in v18Yes (R1, R2)
RW. Window and recordA time word fixes a window; that an event happened inside it is shown only by a record.None in v18None in v18Yes (R1, R2)
CB8. Silence is symmetricAn account's silence about a detail shows neither that it happened nor that it did not.None in v18None in v18Yes (R1, R2)
CB8b. Compatible differencesDifferences that can both be true of one saying or event are recorded as compatible.None in v18None in v18Yes (R2 only)
CB10. Addressee and hearersPeople addressed and people present are different; a saying addressed to some applies to others only where words or other Scripture say so.None in v18None in v18Yes (R1, R2)

J. The nine Beta 3 Proposed wordings and the Terms block

Beta 3 gives each the status Proposed "and nothing higher." They are for testing only and are never support for a conclusion. None is a v18 status. The basis notes are as Beta 3 gives them. The passages named there are RECALLED pointers, not test cases, and no reader has checked them.

WordingWhat it says (short summary)Status (Beta 3)Limit and basisIn testing now
P-CB7. Setting facts do not date fulfillmentA fulfillment time comes only from a dating expression in the promise or from another text that says when; a setting alone gives none.ProposedBasis: Observed, RECALLED leads (Genesis 40:13 with 40:20; Joshua 6:26 with 1 Kings 16:34); points 3 to 7 are reading definitionsNo
P-RW. Window and recordA dating expression on the event fixes a window; a record, not the prediction itself, shows the event happened; two kinds of record are reported apart.ProposedBasis: Forced for point 3, first sentence; observed, RECALLED leads; point 4(b) is judgmentNo
P-CB8. Silence is symmetricSilence about a detail shows neither that it happened nor that it did not; a stated detail is not silence; a conflict is not by itself a contradiction.ProposedBasis: Observed, RECALLED lead (Luke 24:13 with 24:18); forced for the last sentence of point 3No
P-CB8b. Compatible differencesWhere both details can be true as stated, the difference is recorded as compatible and is no evidence of one occurrence or two.ProposedBasis: Forced for point 1; observed for the word-sense sentence, RECALLED leads (John 4:1-2; John 19:1)No
P-CB10. Addressee and hearersA statement addressed to some applies to others only where its words widen it or another statement of Scripture applies it; question one statement at a time.ProposedBasis: Observed, RECALLED leads (Deuteronomy 29:14-15; Ephesians 6:1-3)No
P-CB3. Placement shows no time (beside the recorded CB3)Order of telling does not show time; a dating expression or stated occasion does, and each output is written in one of five set forms.Proposed. The recorded CB3 wording stays the recorded one.Basis: Forced for point 1 (as recorded); Rule 6 for point 5; observed lead, RECALLED (John 13:1)No
P-CB1. A parallel is a witness (beside the recorded CB1)Each account witnesses what it reports; comparing parallels fixes neither the exact words nor the occasion; actor and number differences go to P-CB8 first.Proposed. The recorded CB1 wording stays the recorded one.Basis: Forced for points 2 and 3No
P-CB2. Differences are not contradictions (beside the recorded CB2)A difference between true accounts has an explanation; the three listed explanations are open only where no account's words rule them out; the rule never chooses among them.Proposed. The recorded CB2 wording stays the recorded one.Basis: Forced for point 1; point 5 rests on CB3No
P-CB5. No borrowing meaning (beside the recorded CB5)A marked gloss carries to another account only where one utterance is shown, and only to what the gloss names; whoever borrows meaning carries the burden.Proposed. The recorded CB5 wording stays the recorded one.Basis: Observed, RECALLED lead (John 6:70-71); forced for point 4No
Terms block (7.1)Defines account, saying, event, statement, states, setting, dating expression, Scripture's own voice and "not shown," for use inside Section 7 only.Proposed (Beta 3, Section 8 row)None statedNo

Beta 3 lists "Open for the author" items under several of these wordings. They are the author's to answer, and this post does not settle any of them.

3. Failed, retired or dropped (SOURCED)

Nothing on this list is a passed rule or is used as support.

  • Rule 3 (an answer is about what was asked): Failed.
  • CB4 (two accounts in one setting): Failed. Dropped.
  • Rule 13: Retired in v7. Replaced by CB1 to CB5.
  • Same-saying test (v7 wording): Failed in round one. The amended wording is only Proposed.
  • N1 (a nearness word places the event in the hearers' lifetime): Failed. N2's second sentence also failed.
  • FT5, FT3-B (after the cross-check) and FT3-C: fail, as v18 records them. FT3-A is replaced.
  • Wordings that broke in FTc2: FT5-C and FT6*** (v18: "Round 2: breaks").
  • CB1's first wording failed, and the amended wording is the recorded one.
  • Seven candidates tried and dropped in v7 (v18 gives a reason, not a status word): the "all these things" scope rule; "you" always means the people addressed; a ceiling on near-words (about 170 years); mello means "about to"; "never before or after" means literally once; the list of marks identifying the five awaited events (argued from silence); different wording means different events.
  • Not passed, by Beta 2: CB6 is Untested. FT2, FT7 and FT8 are Candidates. W3 is a limit, not a rule.

4. What changes a status (SOURCED from v18's status table; the process wording is the record's)

No helper changes a status. Only the author's yes or no does, after a rule passes the two-source test: it is observed in Scripture with named examples, or forced by inerrancy; no rule rests on silence; and it states what would make it lose.

  • Passed: a rule passed the two-source test in a blind or fresh-reader test, and the author's yes or no decides whether it is adopted.
  • Passed, limited: the same, but only in the limited form named, and the limit goes with the word every time.
  • Failed: the rule failed the test and is not used; a replacement is a new wording that has to be tested.
  • Untested: the rule was stated and never run through a reader; it moves only after a reader test and the author's yes or no.
  • Proposed: a wording that came out of a test and has not been tested on its own; it moves only after its own test and the author's yes or no.
  • Held: the author wrote decisions into it and called it "sufficient" but has not said yes or no on the whole; only that yes or no moves it.
  • Working: the author confirmed the wording, but it is not adopted into a paper; his yes or no on adoption moves it.
  • Candidate: it is listed for testing and is not a rule; it becomes one only after a test and the author's yes or no.

5. Where it stands now (SOURCED)

  1. Outside-reader Round 1 (six rules) and Round 2 (eight prompts, all 48 cells now answered) are done. Their findings are findings, waiting on the author's decisions. Round 2 open items include the RW threshold wording, CB7 John 7:37-39, four pre-registration points, two cells that gave no answer at first on one platform, and the quote checks.
  2. CB1, CB2, CB3, CB5 and the dating-word list keep their recorded statuses and carry the Beta 2 note "under review."
  3. The nine Beta 3 Proposed wordings and the Terms block have not been tested as written.
  4. The death-sense rule v5 stays Held. A revised version (v6) is in preparation: it fixes Sign 4(c) clause (2) and adds a known-limit statement for 1 Corinthians 15:54. Reader tests on it have not been sent.
  5. In the full-preterism test, no FT3 wording has passed. FT5-D and FT6-D wait for the author's go. The Part 14 changes and the "whose words count" ruling are his.
  6. Still owed on other rules: the same-saying rerun with a cross-check, a second reader and cross-check for N3, and CB6, which is untested.

6. Where the sources differ (SOURCED; v18's word used each time)

No two sources give different status words for one rule. These are differences in wording or in age, listed so none is mistaken for a conflict:

  1. Held. Beta 2 and Beta 3 write "Held, not passed." v18 writes "Held." v18's word is used.
  2. Counts. Beta 2's summary (10 Passed, 5 Passed, limited) leaves out CB3, CB1, CB2 and CB5 because they are under review. v18's tables give 11 and 8. Section 8 shows they reconcile.
  3. FT5-A and FT6**. v18 Part 5 says "Not cross-checked." Part 12 (newer) records FTc1, where both readers read each wording. The status word is Proposed in both places. Both are shown.

7. Grouping notes (the writer's judgment, labelled)

  1. Grouping. The rules are grouped by type. The v7 same-saying test is shown under its own type, although v18 lists it in the Olivet v7 table. The Terms block is grouped with the Proposed wordings. FT1 and the test frame are in the full-preterism group, because v18 gives them the words "Defined by the author" and "Fixed in advance," which are not among the eight status words. W3 sits with the witness rules but is labelled "a limit, not a rule," as v18 says.
  2. Left out because they are not rules. The tests and inputs that govern every rule, the author's observations, the Stage 5 leads and links, the test cases, and the point-3 screen. The seven dropped v7 candidates are in section 3 only.
  3. "In testing now." It means the rule has been run in a round whose findings still wait on the author (Yes, with the round), or it has not (No). The full-preterism rows say No where v18 records the round as finished.
  4. Summaries. The "What it says" cells are short summaries and are not the rules. For Rule 13 and CB6, v18 gives no definition, so only the title is shown.

8. Notes: the rules behind each count (SOURCED)

  • Passed (11): Rules 1, 2, 5, 7, 8, 11, G; CB3; W1, W2, W4. (Beta 2's clean 10 leaves out CB3.)
  • Passed, limited (8): Rules 4, 6, 9, 10, 12; CB1, CB2, CB5. (Beta 2's 5 leaves out CB1, CB2, CB5.) The dating-word list is a ninth item at Passed, limited and is counted apart because it is a list.
  • Failed, whole rules or tests (4): Rule 3, CB4, same-saying test (v7 wording), N1. Part-failures: N2's second sentence. Wordings that fail: FT5, FT3-B, FT3-C.
  • Retired (1): Rule 13. Untested (1): CB6. A limit, not a rule (1): W3.
  • Check on the v18 Part 2 table: 25 rows = 11 Passed + 8 Passed, limited + 3 Failed (Rule 3, CB4, same-saying test) + 1 Retired + 1 Untested + 1 limit (W3).
  • Held (1 rule): the death-sense rule v5, with all its parts.
  • Working (1 item): R7a to R7c.
  • Passed with one reader, not adopted (1): N3.
  • Proposed in v18 (3): same-saying amended, FT5-A, FT6**. Proposed in Beta 3 (9): P-CB7, P-RW, P-CB8, P-CB8b, P-CB10, P-CB3, P-CB1, P-CB2, P-CB5.
  • Candidate (3): FT2, FT7, FT8. Passes in part (3): FT4, FT6, FT6*. No status word in v18 (5): CB7, RW, CB8, CB8b, CB10 as tested wordings.