Pulling the Threads, Revised: What Changed from v37 to v38, and Why
On this page (18 sections)
- What changed, in short
- The detailed change log
- 1. A new section before Seam One
- 2. Seam Two: who saw a resurrection
- 3. Seam Two: the Josephus silence, corroboration and Matthew 27:53
- 4. Acts 1:11 and the promise of return
- 5. The line at Matthew 24:36 (Seam Five, the Argument section, the cost section)
- 6. Where the essay depends on a reading of its own
- 7. Seam Thirteen: the 1 Corinthians 15:51-54 check
- 8. Seam Fourteen: the graves
- 9. Speakers' claims labeled as theirs
- 10. Sentences that stated an absence as fact
- 11. Luke 21 and Luke 21:22 (the cost section)
- 12. Notes 105 to 111
- 13. Small fixes carried in
- What did not change
- How the changes were checked, and what was not
- Where this leaves the reader
Pulling the Threads, the essay that tests full preterism, has been revised. The new text is on the site now at the same address as before, and it replaces the earlier version (v37). Read it here: Pulling the Threads: Full Preterism. The new section that explains the rules is here: How This Paper Reads, and What It Did to Its Own Side.
What changed, in short
The essay's position has not changed. Full preterism's reading still fails at its seams, and the resurrection, Christ's return and the final judgment are still ahead. What changed is how firmly each claim is stated. The author turned the rules the essay uses on the essay's own side, and some sentences did not survive.
The witness claims in Seam Two were narrowed. The essay no longer says every resurrection Scripture describes was public, named and witnessed. It says that when Scripture describes God raising someone, it says who saw, though not always the public and not always by name, and that no report from the period has been shown for AD 70. That is a status, not a verdict. The line at Matthew 24:36 is now labeled a reading, because the same clause that closes verse 37 also closes verse 27, and no tested rule settles where the speech changes subject. A new section before Seam One lists the rules the essay leans on, the limit each was found to have, the rules that failed, and the author's two observations.
Seam Thirteen lost its claim that nothing in it is contested. It now runs a check of 1 Corinthians 15:51-54 under the same rules. The claim that the occasion Paul describes has already come is falsified under those rules, and that check depends on the author's ruling that a New Testament mystery is a disclosure. The same rules do not disprove the narrower claim about Jesus's own words, and the essay says so.
Several seams now say where they depend on a reading of the essay's own. About thirty-five sentences that said never, nobody or nothing now say what the essay has found. Seam Fourteen no longer says the graves are full, and rests on Baker's own statement of faith.
The detailed change log
The base is the text as it stood on the site, which was v37 plus ten small proofreading fixes made after it went up. Those ten fixes are carried into v38 and are not counted below. Every quotation is exact. "Before" is the old text, "After" is the new text, and the quotations are cut where a sentence contains a dash. The Short Version bullets at the top of the volume were changed to match each change below.
1. A new section before Seam One
The new section is "How This Paper Reads, and What It Did to Its Own Side". It sits first in the volume and has its own page.
- After: "This paper reads Scripture by a short list of tested rules, built in a separate study of the Olivet Discourse and checked one at a time against the text."
- After: "The rules were turned on this essay's own side, and the cost shows."
Why: the essay leans on rules about how Scripture uses its words, and a reader should be able to hold it to them. The section prints each rule with the limit it was found to have. It names two rules that failed their tests and are used nowhere in the essay. It defines four status words: falsified under these rules, not disproven, unsupported and not shown. The last two are statuses, not findings, and neither means false. It also states two observations the author holds, that death continues and that no visible bodily return of Christ has occurred, and it says the second states an absence, so the author's own limit applies to it: a lack of observation does not establish a fact.
2. Seam Two: who saw a resurrection
- Before: "whenever Scripture actually describes God raising someone, the event is public, named, and witnessed, without exception."
- After: "when Scripture describes God raising someone, it says who saw. Not always the public, and not always by name."
- Before: "AD 70's is the only one that wasn't witnessed by anyone at all."
- After: "For AD 70's, no such report from the period has been shown."
- After: "That is a status, not a verdict. This essay does not claim that no one saw it."
- Before: "never produced even a single witness"
- After: "no witness has been identified"
- Before: "Deuteronomy 19:15 requires two or three witnesses to establish any matter"
- After: "It sets a standard for charges."
- After: "This essay does not apply that count to an event, as though AD 70 needed two or three witnesses in order to have happened."
- Before: "for church doctrine and discipline"
- After: "for his dealings with the Corinthians (2 Corinthians 13:1) and for accusations against elders (1 Timothy 5:19)"
Why: Matthew 27:53 and Peter's words at Acts 10:40-41 show that when Scripture reports a bodily act of God in history it says who saw, though not always the public and not always by name. The Deuteronomy 19:15 count belongs to charges against a person, and the essay found no place where Scripture applies it to an event. A missing witness does not by itself prove a claim false. What is left is the plain demand: if there were chosen witnesses to AD 70, say who they were.
3. Seam Two: the Josephus silence, corroboration and Matthew 27:53
- Before: "He never once mentions graves opening or a body descending from the sky."
- After: "This essay has found him mentioning neither graves opening nor a body descending from the sky."
- Before: "has no outside corroboration either"
- After: "has no outside corroboration that this essay has found either"
- Before: "bodies, walking, seen, in a named city"
- After: "bodies that went into the holy city and appeared to many people"
Why: each of the first two claimed a silence as fact, and the essay's own rules do not let a claim rest on silence. The third was a correction of the text: Matthew 27:53 says the saints "appeared to many people" in the holy city. It does not say they were seen walking, and it does not name the city.
4. Acts 1:11 and the promise of return
- Before: "Nothing in the historical record answers to it at AD 70."
- After: "It is the two men's promise, as Luke reports it, and this essay holds it as theirs."
- After: "That he will return does not rest on the two men alone, because Hebrews 9:28 says in the writer's own voice that he will appear a second time."
- After: "This essay has found nothing in the historical record that answers to that promise at AD 70."
Why: the words at Acts 1:11 are the two men's, and the manner of the return, "in the same way," is theirs. The writer of Hebrews carries the return in his own voice, so the essay now puts that text beside Acts 1:11.
5. The line at Matthew 24:36 (Seam Five, the Argument section, the cost section)
- Before: "That's the actual difference: a contested brake is still a brake."
- After: "Three limits belong beside that sentence, and they cut against this essay as much as for it."
- After: "First, a marker doesn't prove a break by itself."
- After: "Second, the same clause stands on both sides of the line."
- After: "Third, the line at 24:36 is a reading."
- After: "That is a difference, and this essay does not claim it is a proof."
- Before: "The chain was built so that Matthew 24:36 would never need an answer."
- After: "The chain, as it is stated here, does not answer Matthew 24:36."
- After: "A full preterist reads it otherwise, and the reading is argued here, not proved."
Why: the phrase "peri de" ("now concerning") dates nothing. A marker can back up a seam the text already shows, and it cannot create one. Matthew 24:27 and 24:37 close with the same clause about the coming of the Son of Man, so a full preterist can read 24:36 through 24:39 as one coming, and no rule the method passed settles it. The essay still holds that the speech divides at 24:36 and still sees a difference between a marker offered for that reading and none offered for the other. It no longer calls that difference a proof. The Argument section also gains a sentence saying that the reach of "all these things" in 24:34 is a reading held because it fits the text best, and that the link depends on it.
6. Where the essay depends on a reading of its own
- After: "The seams that lean on one of this essay's own decided readings rather than on a tested rule say so where they make their claim, among them Seams Five, Eight, Nine, Eleven, Thirteen and Fourteen."
- After: "One dependency belongs on the page." (Seam Eight, with a paragraph saying its force depends on how the Olivet Discourse divides)
- After: "Two dependencies belong on the page." (Seam Nine)
- After: "A limit belongs here." (Seam Eleven)
Why: some seams stand on a tested rule and some stand on a reading the author decided. A reader is owed the difference. Seam Eight's answer to the watch-commands reply holds only if the warnings from 24:36 through 25:30 look ahead, and the essay says that is a reading and not a result. Seam Nine reads the gathering of the elect in Matthew 24:31 as the spread of the gospel, which uses the same first-century reach the full-preterist reply takes at Colossians 1:23, and it reads "the end of the age" at 28:20 as still ahead. In the SBL Greek text of Matthew 24:3 one article stands over both "your coming" and "the end of the age," and the essay says that whether one article over two nouns requires that they be one thing is a question for a Greek specialist. Seam Eleven says its John 6 claim is textual, that the essay finds no passage describing a believer-by-believer raising at death, and that the tests do not disprove the narrow claim about Jesus's own words. Seams Twelve and Ten gained short cross-references so that Seam Thirteen's dependence on them is visible.
7. Seam Thirteen: the 1 Corinthians 15:51-54 check
- Before: "Nothing here is contested the way Seam Five's brake or Seam Two's silence require careful sourcing to establish."
- After: "One more check, run under the same rules."
- After: "Three passed rules fix what has to happen."
- After: "The same tests were run on Jesus's own words"
- After: "No case on Jesus's own words met all six."
- After: "That screen was run by the working session that built the rules, not by a blind reader."
- After: "Two things the claim rests on are not rules."
Why: the old sentence claimed more than the seam could carry. The new check counts Paul's words at 1 Corinthians 15:51 as marked from God because Paul introduces them as a mystery, and Seam Ten argues that a New Testament mystery is a disclosure. That ruling is the author's, and the check stands or falls with it. Under it, three tested rules fix what must happen: Paul's word for "mortal" means the physical body in all six places he uses it, "when... then" ties two events into one occasion, and a permanent end of death happens once. Believers have died since AD 70 and bodies are still mortal, so the occasion of verses 52 to 54 has not come, and the claim that every promise was fulfilled by AD 70 is falsified under these rules so far as it includes that occasion. The result is limited to Paul's words. For Jesus's own words (John 5:28-29, Luke 20:34-36, John 6, Matthew 25:31-46 and others), no case met all six conditions that would falsify the claim, so the narrow claim is not disproven. That is not the same as proven, and the essay's reading of those words stays a reading. The seam also prints the costs, which are four things that would make the check lose: a use of "mortal" for something other than the physical body, a showing that verse 54 does not state a complete ending, a reading of "when... then" that does not make one occasion, or a reversal of the ruling on "mystery."
The seam also adds a note on Charles Meek, a full preterist who publishes at prophecyquestions.com. His list reads "2nd death = physical death." Revelation prints the identification of the second death with the lake of fire twice, at 20:14 and 21:8, and his page offers no printed source for the equation.
8. Seam Fourteen: the graves
- Before: "It isn't in the graves, because they're full."
- After: "This essay does not claim to have looked in the graves."
- Before: "On IBV-R, that day came and every tomb stayed full."
- After: "On IBV-R, that day came and, by its own account, the tombs stayed occupied."
- Before: "On its reading the tombs are full because the call hasn't come yet."
- After: "On its reading, which is a reading and not a result, the call of John 5:28-29 has not yet come, so occupied tombs are what it expects."
Why: "the graves are full" was a claim about what is in the graves, and the essay has not looked. The sentence now rests on Baker's own statement of faith, point 67, which says that physical bodies return to the Earth and are not physically resurrected. The Short Version bullet says the same. The reading that Jesus's words at John 5:28-29 are still ahead is marked as a reading, and the essay says the tests do not settle between that reading and the full-preterist one.
9. Speakers' claims labeled as theirs
- Before: "An occupied tomb meant no resurrection."
- After: "An occupied tomb meant no resurrection, Peter argues. That is his claim in his sermon, and this essay uses it as his test, not as a statement in Scripture's own voice."
- After: "That is Peter's claim, and this essay holds it as his." (Acts 3:21)
- After: "That is Peter's claim in his sermon, and it is used here as his, not as Scripture's own statement." (Acts 10:40-41)
Why: Peter's sermons report what Peter said. The essay uses them as his claims and no longer presents them as Scripture's own statements. The Acts 3:21 point now rests on Matthew 26:64, in Jesus's own words, which puts sitting at the right hand of the Power and coming on the clouds in one sentence.
10. Sentences that stated an absence as fact
The author searched the whole essay by word list for sentences with never, no one, nobody, nothing, none, nowhere, not one, every, always, any and similar words, read every hit, and made 35 edits that scope each sentence to what the essay has found or shown, or label it as the essay's judgment. Examples:
- Before: "The church has never stopped sending, teaching, or claiming the ongoing presence the commission promises."
- After: "This essay has found no point at which the church stopped sending, teaching, or claiming the ongoing presence the commission promises."
- Before: "Every creed the church has used to mark the edge of the faith says only what Paul said"
- After: "The creeds this paper has read that mark the edge of the faith say only what Paul said"
- Before: "Scripture describes no such resurrection."
- After: "This essay finds no passage in Scripture that describes such a resurrection."
- Before: "it has to be found in the text or it is not found."
- After: "until it is shown from the text, it is not shown."
- Before: "No passage of Scripture describes it."
- After: "This paper finds no passage of Scripture that describes it, and Seam Eleven states the limit of that finding."
- Before: "A method with no brakes doesn't stop where you'd like it to."
- After: "If it has no brake, it will not stop where you'd like it to."
Why: the essay's own rules do not let a claim rest on silence, and sentences with never and nobody are claims about everything that exists. The sentences about the word "mystery" in Seam Ten are scoped the same way, because the count of every New Testament use of the Greek word was not made. A word-list search can miss an absence stated without those words, so the essay does not say the sweep found them all. Quoted words were not changed.
11. Luke 21 and Luke 21:22 (the cost section)
- Before: "A contested brake is still a brake, as Seam Five itself argues."
- After: "Seam Five's marker can back up a seam the text already shows and cannot create one, as Seam Five says."
- Before: "explicit in two of the three"
- After: "marked in two of the three by a shared clause, on this essay's reading"
- After: "The text does not say whether that is a retelling, a repetition or a different arrangement"
- After: "The tests found that reading unsupported, which is not the same as false."
- After: "It does not show that Luke 21:22 means less than full preterism says. It shows that the verse does not settle it."
Why: the old paragraph leaned on "a contested brake is still a brake," a sentence removed from Seam Five for the reasons in item 5, and called the seam "explicit" in two Gospels, which went past what the rules support. It now says what the text does not say. The new paragraph takes up Luke 21:22 ("to fulfill all that is written"), which some full preterists read as saying all prophecy was to be fulfilled in that generation. A printed time fixes when, not how much, and Paul uses a similar phrase at Acts 13:29 for the stage reached at the cross, with the resurrection following. That is observed use, not a rule, and it cuts both ways.
12. Notes 105 to 111
Seven notes were added, bringing the total to 111. Note 105 gives the NET text of Acts 10:41, Matthew 27:53 and Deuteronomy 19:15. Note 106 gives Matthew 24:27 and 24:37. Note 107 covers the Greek of Matthew 24:3. Note 108 covers 1 Corinthians 15:51-54 and the Greek checks. Note 109 gives Charles Meek's pages and the dates they were checked. Note 110 covers Luke 21:22 and Acts 13:29. Note 111 says the rules and their limits are those recorded as of November 5, 2026, and ends: "A rule's status can change if a later test finds a counter-case."
13. Small fixes carried in
- Before: "IBV-R then says of everyone who has died since AD 70"
- After: "IBV-R says of everyone who has died since AD 70"
- Before: "That is a clear answer, and it has a price."
- After: "The answer is clear, and it has a price."
- Before: "That is the point this seam has been pressing"
- After: "This seam has been pressing the same point"
Why: in Seam Eleven the word "then" reached back across an intervening paragraph, and two openers that began "That is" were reworded. The same pass changed "best-known popularizer" to "most prolific popularizer," "Standard biblical reference works" to "Two standard biblical reference works," and "Every New Testament call to readiness" to "Each of these New Testament calls to readiness," so that each sentence says only what the text in front of it supports.
What did not change
There are still fourteen seams, and no fifteenth was added. The closing section, "What's Actually Left, Once All Fourteen Are Pulled," is unchanged. Scripture is quoted from the NET Second Edition throughout, and the verses quoted in the new passages were checked against it on November 5, 2026.
How the changes were checked, and what was not
The changes were checked in stages. A first reader, an AI chat outside the project, was given the 25 changed passages, before and after, with the rules and their limits and the NET text of every cited verse. It held 12, flagged 12 as overreaching, and called one unclear. All 13 were repaired. The author's working session then read every repaired and added passage against the same rules. A second reader, also an AI chat outside the project, was given the 26 edits of that pass and the additions. It held 11, flagged 13, and called 2 unclear. Of its 15 flags, 12 were accepted, 3 were accepted in part, and none were declined.
Three limits belong here. The sweep described in item 10 was read by no fresh reader, by the author's ruling that the reader checks were enough. The Greek for 1 Corinthians 15:51-54 is carried from earlier two-source checks and was not re-read for this version. And this post does not claim that any human scholar has reviewed these changes.
Where this leaves the reader
The essay still ends on knowing Christ and not on a timetable. The measure it asks you to keep in view through all fourteen seams is not who wins the argument. It is whether any of it drives someone back toward actually knowing Him, the way John 17:3 means it, present tense. As the essay puts it near its end, "Getting the timing right was never going to be what that hinges on."
Read the revised essay here: Pulling the Threads: Full Preterism. If you find a sentence that still says more than it can show, use the Reply to the author button below.
Share this post:Share on Facebook

